List Mgmt. 2020 Trade and List Management Thread II

[Groucho]

I assumed they “walk someone to the PSD like Hately.

We could grab Paddy next.

I’d rather take the risk on him, given the upside, than have a Garner, Turner or EVW on the list.

Does he need to go to the draft or is he a DFA?

 

[ChoppyGun]

Garner got on the park in 2020.. didnt do much, but he got there

Garner was lucky but has clear ability and likes a scrap.

I'm happy enough to keep him for a year compared to the 11.

 

[New_Roo]

What did they pay Martin and McGovern in their first years?

i’d be very surprised if Kreuzer and Simpson were anywhere near a million combined.. With one of them on the veterans or marc murphy

Martin was more than a mil first year was he not to prevent anyone else taking him in the psd


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[New_Roo]

I assumed they “walk someone to the PSD like Hately.

We could grab Paddy next.

I’d rather take the risk on him, given the upside, than have a Garner, Turner or EVW on the list.

Thought we were trying to walk saad there!


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[hcd199]

It’s interesting that the Neeld GoDeez saga is rolled out but on the flip side there’s the McCartney GoDoggys saga and well we know how that turned out.

Or Blight to Adelaide and culling three of their most beloved senior players.

If it nets us a flag then obviously we'd all take it. But the successes of those two clubs are probably the flimsiest premiership models to emulate - their H&A finishing positions in the 'successful' five years (from the arrival of Beveridge/Blight) are 6-7-10-13-7 and 4-5-13-11-8 respectively, only fractionally better than what we managed under Laidley or Scott. Not exactly the kind of formula you risk Neeldesque disaster to replicate...

 

[New_Roo]

I’d be happy with both.

Brodie is really homesick
...I get the feeling he’ll explode if he gets back home. Far more natural footballer compared to someone like Bonar.

Player of the Round: Will Brodie

Will Brodie is the Round 12 Player of the Round, presented by Ultra Stainless Security.

www.goldcoastfc.com.au

There was talk earlier that 2mP was a cheap option as a replacement to brown...not really seeing that. Currently on maybe 100k less than brown and have to give up a last first early second which is all we may get for brown....


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[archereleven]

He was sore for a bit, but he's a-okay now. Just an annoying injury to recover from, especially at an age where you've been coping it for a decade at the coalface.

Good to hear.

He will be the best thing development wise for our young mids. Its a much simpler game for them if Cunners is inside doing his thing.

On SM-G975F using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Gasometer]

If it nets us a flag then obviously we'd all take it. But the successes of those two clubs are probably the flimsiest premiership models to emulate - their H&A finishing positions in the 'successful' five years (from the arrival of Beveridge/Blight) are 6-7-10-13-7 and 4-5-13-11-8 respectively, only fractionally better than what we managed under Laidley or Scott. Not exactly the kind of formula you risk Neeldesque disaster to replicate...

 

[Star]

Does he need to go to the draft or is he a DFA?

i imagine he is DFA as has been delisted

 

[Star]

I’d be happy with both.

Brodie is really homesick
...I get the feeling he’ll explode if he gets back home. Far more natural footballer compared to someone like Bonar.

Player of the Round: Will Brodie

Will Brodie is the Round 12 Player of the Round, presented by Ultra Stainless Security.

www.goldcoastfc.com.au

Essendon right into Brodie

 

[GS WARRIORS]

Does he need to go to the draft or is he a DFA?

DFA I would have thought. The article said he was a free agent

 

[Star]

There was talk earlier that 2mP was a cheap option as a replacement to brown...not really seeing that. Currently on maybe 100k less than brown and have to give up a last first early second which is all we may get for brown....


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

pick up his wage and watch that 1st/2nd become a 3rd

 

[DuckYeah]

There was talk earlier that 2mP was a cheap option as a replacement to brown...not really seeing that. Currently on maybe 100k less than brown and have to give up a last first early second which is all we may get for brown....


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

How that makes any sense whatsoever, dumb founded. BBB has his flaws but I doubt Wrightys career will be no BbB career

 

[DuckYeah]

I’d be happy with both.

Brodie is really homesick
...I get the feeling he’ll explode if he gets back home. Far more natural footballer compared to someone like Bonar.

Player of the Round: Will Brodie

Will Brodie is the Round 12 Player of the Round, presented by Ultra Stainless Security.

www.goldcoastfc.com.au

Jy’s Mate too

 

[DuckYeah]

Essendon right into Brodie

20 games in 4 years, i know rowell came a long but it reeks of another mediocre player, could be wrong though

 

[1975]

How that makes any sense whatsoever, dumb founded. BBB has his flaws but I doubt Wrightys career will be no BbB career

I don’t think Shaw and co will be judging our new forwards on goals kicked alone.

 

[DuckYeah]

I don’t think Shaw and co will be judging our new forwards on goals kicked alone.

We dont kick any, so how can you judge?

 

[year of the roo]

All laughs aside, its worth the risk, but when this guy is dribbling in a chair and cant remember his own name in his 40’s dont say I didnt tell ya so

wtf is wrong with you?

 

[Scallop Industry Thug]

All laughs aside, its worth the risk, but when this guy is dribbling in a chair and cant remember his own name in his 40’s dont say I didnt tell ya so

Dude. It's football.

 

[1975]

We dont kick any, so how can you judge?

Good point but you know what I mean

 

[Scallop Industry Thug]

And Im sure McCartin will have a clearance, but CTE can only be diagnosed post-mortem.

Paddy should be ultra careful, and clubs should probably help him from himself.

 

[DuckYeah]

wtf is wrong with you?

I take peoples well being and long history of concussions seriously.. so I guess its not whats wrong with me you need to ask? Oh but a dr has cleared him, so its all good

 

[shinboner magic]

Tom Phillips from pies might be out as they look to pay DeGoey and Moore. I thought he was "good" but just checked his stats which are mainly below average.

Don’t think that’ll help the pies that much.
He wouldn’t be on big money.

Former amateur boxing champion.

Always welcome.

Guess he won’t be a JZ whipping boy then.

pick up his wage and watch that 1st/2nd become a 3rd

Yeah there shouldn’t be many clubs with to much since in their cap.

 

[Rad Roo]

So I believe ess are giving him what 700by4.... so Carl giving more than that what the?


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

Ahh yes, carltank is a club of open cheque books. There are plenty of talents coming from the drafts and based on our recent draft selections, we have done very well since 2016 in that we have gotten around 3 into the starting 22 each year. If we can nail pick 2 and 9 plus 2 more from the later rounds then we are laughing all the way to the bank. If we can finish in the bottom 4 next year, another top pick, we are ready for the rise up the ladder in 2022.

 

[7577969923]

I take peoples well being and long history of concussions seriously.. so I guess its not whats wrong with me you need to ask? Oh but a dr has cleared him, so its all good

I reckon if I was Ben Buckley and Brady came to me saying he was thinking drafting McCartin I would say I want three independent neurologists to give Paddy the okay, i would want the AFL to sign off on it, and whoever is the relevant insurer.