I was torn again. With this team in mind and on the basis we'd have Charlie, Harry, Gov and Jack plus TDK - I omitted him. But in reality, he deserves a place in the team. We'll just be too tall.
I think we'll definitely see the first two come round 1. Newman, I'm not so sure.Casboult, Murphy and Newman will all be in the best 22.
You are basing this on the other players people have voted for?The consensus of those who voted in this, the Consensus thread.
I voted for Levi in the forwardline, but given who others voted for, I can't put him in this 22nd spot. It would make us too unbalanced.
This final vote is about who we add to the selected 21.You are basing this on the other players people have voted for?
Levi plays round 1 and most of the year, yeah?
Unbalanced in you eyes to vote for a favorite, while Gibbons, Murphy, Cuners, Levi make more sense, so does NewnesThis final vote is about who we add to the selected 21.
Voting Levi into the 22nd spot makes us unbalanced. Levi missed his spot in the forward 7. He doesn't get into the mid 7.
And he will play round 1. Charlie won't be there, so Full Forwad is open. That's not what this vote is about, though.
If you want, you're welcome to start the "Arr0w's Best 22" thread where there's no poll so other can't accidentally submit the wrong answers to what they think is the best 22.At this stage he sits well outside the top 25
Good post, although I reckon Walsh is a lock.This is what I have heard/read that Teague and other coaches have said over last few weeks
SPS will play off HBF - definite
Marchbank/Williamson/Docherty can play wing - underlining coaches acknowledge wing spots are the open question ?
Williams will train and start midfield if it isn't working will go back to HBF - definite
Eddie Betts will start - definite
Fisher is seen as a small forward - definite
Cuningham will play to provide burst receiver around contests like Walsh/Williams ( Teague's words) = so looking to bring Cuningham into midfield
asked about Charlie - long term situation Charlie is doing everything he can blah blah blah = fingers crossed
Teague is looking at younger players to lift and push to establish themselves as 'locks' ( his word) - he believes these blokes developing will be the key to Clubs progress :
If you pencil in the definite statements you get a team that looks like:
Plowman Jones Marchbank*
Saad Weitering Docherty
Williamson Cripps Murphy?/Cuningham
TDK Setterfield Wiliams
Martin Harry McGovern
Eddie Levi Fisher
IC: Ed | SPS | XXX | XXX
I would assume that Teague will continue wanting to play Pittonet and TDK as a pair - especially given TDK's mobility
doesn't leave much space for the rest of the list does it?
I have never seen a Carlton list with so much potential competition for places.
You'd think finals in VFL would be a certainty - for starters.