List Mgmt. 2021 Trade & List Management Thread I

[King Corey]

Oh this is way to close to the bone, at least you got power out of it

Hahaha. Power. Yeh it's just like being a fighter pilot, except for being a lot uglier and not getting paid.

 

[Le Grille]

Hahaha. Power. Yeh it's just like being a fighter pilot, except for being a lot uglier and not getting paid.

You get to punt fools though, do tell you don’t like that

 

[King Corey]

You get to punt fools though, do tell you don’t like that

Nah it's a cold and apathetic feeling. Think of The acurate one booking 4 web calls in one evening, by the last one he's weak and withered and just wants a warm meal.

 

[king of the road]

I’d expect more trade news this week as the AFL uses all means to keep a presence in the media with no game this weekend.

 

[Le Grille]

Nah it's a cold and apathetic feeling. Think of The acurate one booking 4 web calls in one evening, by the last one he's weak and withered and just wants a warm meal.

 

[lockheed]

I’d expect more trade news this week as the AFL uses all means to keep a presence in the media with no game this weekend.

If only there were state of origin matches this weekend

 

[Le Grille]

If only there were state of origin matches this weekend

I reckon a pre GF bye is worse than a pre finals bye .

 

[Psicosis]

Thought this was interesting & a nice precedent in regards to a pick upgrade in the pointy end.

Noble as BL GM of Football did the following trade in 2016:
BL Got: Pick 3, Pick 16
GWS Got: Pick 2, Pick 31, Pick 51 & Pick 60

Basically for a 1 spot upgrade, you're talking about an upgrade of later picks for an additional first rounder.

Let alone a 3 (5 after F/S) spot upgrade.

 

[The Nostradamus]

Thought this was interesting & a nice precedent in regards to a pick upgrade in the pointy end.

Noble as BL GM of Football did the following trade in 2016:
BL Got: Pick 3, Pick 16
GWS Got: Pick 2, Pick 31, Pick 51 & Pick 60

Basically for a 1 spot upgrade, you're talking about an upgrade of later picks for an additional first rounder.

Let alone a 3 (5 after F/S) spot upgrade.

And the other thing to factor is at the time there wasn’t even that big a gap if any between Taranto and mccluggage yet they still got a lot for moving down 1 spot

meanwhile there’s a huge gap between JHF, Callaghan and the rest of the field

we should be expecting that x2 at least

all in all won’t happen

only gws could tempt us to trade down so that we at least get Callaghan

 

[Psicosis]

And the other thing to factor is at the time there wasn’t even that big a gap if any between Taranto and mccluggage yet they still got a lot for moving down 1 spot

meanwhile there’s a huge gap between JHF, Callaghan and the rest of the field

we should be expecting that x2 at least

all in all won’t happen

only gws could tempt us to trade down so that we at least get Callaghan

Good call out TZ. Much like this year, there was a tier of 3 players (McGrath, Taranto & Glugg) which dropped away.

If we did the deal with Adelaide, it would be the equivalent of Essendon doing a deal with Carlton in 2016.

 

[RobZombie]

Maybe someone can enlighten me as to who actually said it, but the Mantra "Draft for talent, Trade for needs" makes serious sense the more you think about it.

The Brisbane list manager said it on the Road to the Draft pod.

 

[Le Grille]

The Brisbane list manager said it on the Road to the Draft pod.

A great mantra that


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

 

[Rooboy 96]

Agree, but the buzz is he wants more and the dees want more, hence my vociferous opposition to the move

are you saying GoDees are happy to trade him?

 

[hilly]

Servicable at best.

Was mainly going off what I had heard and AFL tables. Looked like he dropped off a bit.

Then again it's Carlton - four of their defenders never concede goals apparently.

 

[hilly]

Agree, but the buzz is he wants more and the dees want more, hence my vociferous opposition to the move

He doesn't have a contract at the moment so he should be careful.

 

[hilly]

There are posters on here born after we started posting..

If you'd asked me when I started how long I'd waste on here I'd have thought time would be up after an arbitrary 3 or 4 years.

(in terms of quality, obviously I peaked inside 3 or 4 posts)

That it has ticked into 20 years... all the things I could've done instead with all those wasted hours:

Learned a language
Learned a musical instrument
Earned a qualification, degree, multiple dan black belt or certificate
Volunteered for a charity
Exercised
Meditated
Worked an extra job

Instead I used all that time to debate how some blokes I don't know should conduct themselves during a weekly playtime session on a patch of grass.

All overrated pursuits.

 

[DocSholl]

are you saying GoDees are happy to trade him?

He's out of contract - if he wants to leave for better opportunities then it won't really matter if they're happy to trade him or not

 

[Le Grille]

He doesn't have a contract at the moment so he should be careful.

Absolutely, I’m just commenting on what’s being said, sure to take a pinch of salt

 

[7577969923]

I like Weidemen if we don't break the bank. I think 12 months up forward and a switch to defence could be the strategy. At the very least I would train him in both groups over the pre-season. He seems to move ok, good height and agility, allows Comben to develop without the pressure. Seems to be a good CHB option with the way he moves and that is the position we need covered with McKay/Corr being the more full back style players.

A touch of the Peter Manns about him?

 

[Rooboy 96]

I don't think he's what they need. He's slow, and they got torched on the outside and on the spread.

They had Powell Pepper and elected not to start him, and I'd take him over Dumont.

as usual we undervalue our own, Dumont sh1ts all over Powell Pepper, crikey SANFL player JHF is better than Powell Pepper

 

[Rooboy 96]

I reckon a pre GF bye is worse than a pre finals bye .

is footy still going?

 

[RobZombie]

I don't think he's what they need. He's slow, and they got torched on the outside and on the spread.

They had Powell Pepper and elected not to start him, and I'd take him over Dumont.

Powell-Pepper is terrible. People only think he's good because he was a great supercoach cash cow in his first year and they stop paying attention once they've culled him.

 

[Le Grille]

Powell-Pepper is terrible. People only think he's good because he was a great supercoach cash cow in his first year and they stop paying attention once they've culled him.

Yeah I’d sooner dumont over SPP even if SPP was an ex east Perth player

 

[Rooboys Rool]

Good call out TZ. Much like this year, there was a tier of 3 players (McGrath, Taranto & Glugg) which dropped away.

If we did the deal with Adelaide, it would be the equivalent of Essendon doing a deal with Carlton in 2016.

View attachment 1234726

SPS - worth a look?

(Seriously - I thought he showed a bit early days but haven't seen much of Carlton games in the last year or 3. I also thought he was about 26 and too old to be of interest, but he's actually only 23.)

 

[Le Grille]

SPS - worth a look?

(Seriously - I thought he showed a bit early days but haven't seen much of Carlton games in the last year or 3. I also thought he was about 26 and too old to be of interest, but he's actually only 23.)

What would you offer