List Mgmt. 2022 List Management and trading thread

[Scorpus]

I saw this format on the West Coast board and thought it might help understand our current list position

 

[Mr MysteryGuest]

 

[Cleric]

Says who?

Someone who would know.
Wether he comes or not, I don't know.

 

[George CantStandYa]

Someone who would know.
Wether he comes or not, I don't know.

Have you had reliable intel before from them?

 

[Cleric]

Do we want him? He was looking good last year, but seems to have fallen off a cliff this year. Anyone know why??

Well he is a point of difference for our midfield.

 

[Cleric]

Have you had reliable intel before from them?

Not this guy before.
I would say where I met him but you never know who reads big footy.

 

[ams4crows]

Even Victorian sides don't want McAsey, we are legit going to delist a pick 6 next year, one of the biggest draft blunders by the AFC

 

[AdelaideFan14]

1. 5 to Gold Coast for Rankine 32 + 35 + 68
2. 35 to GWS for 43 + 58 + 60
3. 23 + 32 + 58 to Brisbane for Brisbane's 2023 1st + 70
4. Adelaide 2023 1st + 43 to Sydney for 14 + 36 + Sydney's 2023 1st
5. Frampton to Collingwood for 2023 3rd
6. 14 + 2023 2nd Round to Saints for 9
7. Rowe to Bulldogs for 66

IN
-Rankine
-9
-36
-60
-66
-68
-70
-2023 Sydney 1st Round Pick
-2023 Brisbane 1st Round Pick
-2023 Collingwood 3rd Round Pick

OUT
-5
-23
-2023 1st Round Pick
-2023 2nd Round Pick
-2023 3rd Round Pick
-Frampton
-Rowe

Gives us a pick to get Phillipou, whilst still having the points to match a bid for Michelanny and still retaining a presence in the 1st Round of a strong draft next season.

 

[Jeffcrowe]

Don't disagree at all really please to get both of those. The point I was trying to make is we a bottom tier team; let's say have four holes to fill a big bodied powerful top end mid is just one area it like to see us (because you can't address them all in one draft). I'd like to see us address two of those holes this draft and 2 next draft. As opposed to an excellent get this year in Rankine and another excellent get next year and we take four years at that pace.

I can't see us getting back into this draft at the pointy end unless we look trade our future 1st.

Yep ,we don’t seem to take those risks like Port do at times

 

[Scorpus]

Even Victorian sides don't want McAsey, we are legit going to delist a pick 6 next year, one of the biggest draft blunders by the AFC

One of the biggest draft blunders in the history of the modern draft by any club. Absolute howler

 

[Bearded Clam]

I
I hope we take Rankine to the PSD and they get nothing.

God these PSD posts are just so dumb.. and they never stop.

There is no way Rankine goes to the PSD.

Neither the crows nor Rankine himself would risk the PSD.. Rankine would re-sign with the Suns before risking the PSD.

 

[George CantStandYa]

1. 5 to Gold Coast for Rankine 32 + 35 + 68
2. 35 to GWS for 43 + 58 + 60
3. 23 + 32 + 58 to Brisbane for Brisbane's 2023 1st + 70
4. Adelaide 2023 1st + 43 to Sydney for 14 + 36 + Sydney's 2023 1st
5. Frampton to Collingwood for 2023 3rd
6. 14 + 2023 2nd Round to Saints for 9
7. Rowe to Bulldogs for 66

IN
-Rankine
-9
-36
-60
-66
-68
-70
-2023 Sydney 1st Round Pick
-2023 Brisbane 1st Round Pick
-2023 Collingwood 3rd Round Pick

OUT
-5
-23
-2023 1st Round Pick
-2023 2nd Round Pick
-2023 3rd Round Pick
-Frampton
-Rowe

Gives us a pick to get Phillipou, whilst still having the points to match a bid for Michelanny and still retaining a presence in the 1st Round of a strong draft next season.

Dude, GC aren’t giving us Rankine and 3 picks. It’s a shame because you’ve put in some effort but no chance.

 

[Bearded Clam]

1. 5 to Gold Coast for Rankine 32 + 35 + 68
2. 35 to GWS for 43 + 58 + 60
3. 23 + 32 + 58 to Brisbane for Brisbane's 2023 1st + 70
4. Adelaide 2023 1st + 43 to Sydney for 14 + 36 + Sydney's 2023 1st
5. Frampton to Collingwood for 2023 3rd
6. 14 + 2023 2nd Round to Saints for 9
7. Rowe to Bulldogs for 66

IN
-Rankine
-9
-36
-60
-66
-68
-70
-2023 Sydney 1st Round Pick
-2023 Brisbane 1st Round Pick
-2023 Collingwood 3rd Round Pick

OUT
-5
-23
-2023 1st Round Pick
-2023 2nd Round Pick
-2023 3rd Round Pick
-Frampton
-Rowe

Gives us a pick to get Phillipou, whilst still having the points to match a bid for Michelanny and still retaining a presence in the 1st Round of a strong draft next season.

Literally none of those trades are even remotely plausable..

All of them are laughably in our favour.

 

[Danger in Texas]

Literally none of those trades are even remotely plausable..

All of them are laughably in our favour.

I mean, isn't the Frampton one rumoured to be a done deal?

 

[crow2crow]

I have about as much confidence in our team during the off-season as I do in the actual season

clearly you are not referring to the womens team because they are the only ones that can be relied on

 

[AdelaideFan14]

Literally none of those trades are even remotely plausable..

All of them are laughably in our favour.

Where do you see Sydney, Brisbane and us finishing next season?

 

[crow2crow]

Focus should be on getting norths 2023 1st and getting harley reid because he will squash horne like a fly

 

[ams4crows]

Focus should be on getting norths 2023 1st and getting harley reid because he will squash horne like a fly

Or West Coast's they were also terrible and now no longer have Kennedy.

Do people think West coast will bounce back up the ladder and just thought this season was a one off with all their injuries? Finish above or below us?

 

[WaynesWorld19]

 

[Thetrader15]

Any news on Tarry Thomas?

 

[crow2crow]

View attachment 1525378

the return would be so low might as well keep and prey he has an epiphany

 

[maxlilly]

the return would be so low might as well keep and prey he has an epiphany

Even if we got a future 4th for McAsey this year, it would be a win

 

[ams4crows]

Any news on Tarry Thomas?

Allegedly we're interested, Allegedly he wants a NSW or QLD team

 

[Crowbling]

View attachment 1525378

We probably offered him to North Melbourne and Fish told us ‘I’m not that homesick’

 

[1970crow]

Do we want him? He was looking good last year, but seems to have fallen off a cliff this year. Anyone know why??

supercoach david noble.

 

[Danger in Texas]

Okay, which pick can we get up to by trading 23 and our future 2nd? Mid teens?

Which clubs would want to trade down? I can't see Bris wanting to unless they get another pick this year back, for Ashcroft and Fletcher. Maybe Sydney trades down one of their firsts? Though the Dawson wounds might sting a little bit for them, still. Possibly the Pies too, if they're low on picks after looking to trade in so many players

As for who we'd actually take, there might be a slight chance Phillipou slides, but other than that, you'd be looking at Hewett, Hollands, Keeler (if you want to go the KPF route), Hotton etc.