List Mgmt. 2022 List Management and trading thread

[Scorpus]

I saw this format on the West Coast board and thought it might help understand our current list position

 

[Crow till I die]

Troy Menzel likes this

Seedsman?

 

[Sanders]

Seedsman?

He was a mercurial, tantalising, high-talent underachiever?

Think more Hampton or Tambling.

 

[Crow till I die]

He was a mercurial, tantalising, high-talent underachiever?

Think more Hampton or Tambling.

Nah i was thinking more a guy that was not getting a real run at collingwood we brought over for a 2nd rounder and it worked out well. Not saying rankine would make that jump but he might?

 

[Amacca 23]

He could be worth a trade though. He may simply not have his heart in the Gold Coast. He could be keen on a home coming.

On SM-N981B using BigFooty.com mobile app

On current form no thanks not worth a packet of burnt chips

 

[Sanders]

Nah i was thinking more a guy that was not getting a real run at collingwood we brought over for a 2nd rounder and it worked out well. Not saying rankine would make that jump but he might?

Was Seedsman a lazy, lairising showman who wouldn’t put in the work?

 

[BunjiMC]

I'd still give our second for Rankine. Get him infront of a crowd at AO and who knows. Some of his under18 state form was incredible. The man has talent.

 

[Crow till I die]

Was Seedsman a lazy, lairising showman who wouldn’t put in the work?

Fair call..i shoukd have said he was a guy that was not getting the best out of himself consistently and a change of environment helped

 

[Viva la Mattner]

Troy Menzel likes this

Talent wise there’s a fair gap between those 2

 

[Sanders]

Rankine is a million dollar talent, with a buck fifty attitude.

We know how this story goes

 

[Sanders]

Talent wise there’s a fair gap between those 2

Lol. Sure

 

[Viva la Mattner]

Lol. Sure

You want to elaborate or just be a w***er?

 

[Sanders]

You want to elaborate or just be a w***er?

what words didn’t you understand?

 

[Viva la Mattner]

what words didn’t you understand?

AFL Tables - Troy Menzel - Stats - Statistics

afltables.com

AFL Tables - Izak Rankine - Stats - Statistics

afltables.com

Stats say to me Rankine worth the risk, much more than Menzel ever was

 

[FR0GGY]

I'd still give our second for Rankine. Get him infront of a crowd at AO and who knows. Some of his under18 state form was incredible. The man has talent.

Worked for GWS

 

[Crom14]

I'd still give our second for Rankine. Get him infront of a crowd at AO and who knows. Some of his under18 state form was incredible. The man has talent.

Agreed, he'd get less attention from opposition behind Rachele, he'd come into a Darren Burgess program as well as having competition from McHenry, Rowe to get a game. I think escaping those slippery GC conditions will also go a long way, he wouldn't be the first player to become instantly better after leaving (Prestia, Lynch, Brodie, Lyons, Scrimshaw to name a few).

 

[Danger in Texas]

Can anyone actually think of any high-talent players who, in recent times, coasted at their first club for a good four years without putting up consistent AFL performance, then actually went to another level at their second club?

I’m struggling

 

[Sanders]

AFL Tables - Troy Menzel - Stats - Statistics

afltables.com

AFL Tables - Izak Rankine - Stats - Statistics

afltables.com

Stats say to me Rankine worth the risk, much more than Menzel ever was

Do words not have meanings anymore?

FFS

 

[Sanders]

Can anyone actually think of any high-talent players who, in recent times, coasted at their first club for a good four years without putting up consistent AFL performance, then actually went to another level at their second club?

I’m struggling

There’s a reason for that

 

[jackster83]

Can anyone actually think of any high-talent players who, in recent times, coasted at their first club for a good four years without putting up consistent AFL performance, then actually went to another level at their second club?

I’m struggling

Will Brodie and Jordan Clark look like first round picks again now they are playing well at Freo.

 

[Danger in Texas]

Will Brodie and Jordan Clark look like first round picks again now they are playing well at Freo.

I wouldn’t say they ever ‘coasted’ on just talent, though. Brodie seems to be their version of Keays - finally found a role and situation where he can develop and flourish. Clark’s been building to this year as well, finally found consistent opportunity

 

[Sanders]

Will Brodie and Jordan Clark look like first round picks again now they are playing well at Freo.

Neither were high talent, low application guys

 

[Crom14]

Can anyone actually think of any high-talent players who, in recent times, coasted at their first club for a good four years without putting up consistent AFL performance, then actually went to another level at their second club?

I’m struggling

Steven May never showed his current level at the Suns, was either injured or suspended most weeks.

 

[Crom14]

Neither were high talent, low application guys

Both top 15 picks, interested to know what you consider 'high talent'. Seems like they've both showed at their new clubs the talent is there.

 

[safeandsound]

Can anyone actually think of any high-talent players who, in recent times, coasted at their first club for a good four years without putting up consistent AFL performance, then actually went to another level at their second club?

I’m struggling

Laurence Angwin took it up a few levels

 

[GrandGazza]

Both top 15 picks, interested to know what you consider 'high talent'. Seems like they've both showed at their new clubs the talent is there.

Both didnt have low application though.