Opinion 2022 Player X vs Y vs Z

[weltschmerz]

Coleman vs Ed Richard’s?

Keep an eye on Richards in the AAMI match, but I reckon he could be just as good as Coleman.

 

[Andrew Birch]

Keep an eye on Richards in the AAMI match, but I reckon he could be just as good as Coleman.

63 games with no upswing to speak off. Does Ed Richards have a more lucrative SC role this year?

 

[Northernsoul74]

63 games with no upswing to speak off. Does Ed Richards have a more lucrative SC role this year?

View attachment 1335110

He’s much better playing behind the ball as a running half back and that’s where he’ll be playing by the look of it.
Concerns are injuries and not sure he’ll get any kick ins compared to Coleman.

 

[weltschmerz]

63 games with no upswing to speak off. Does Ed Richards have a more lucrative SC role this year?

View attachment 1335110

Richard's always been swung around a lot and he's just not nearly as good in the forward line or on the wing. If he's consistently played in the back line, he'll score well for his price.

 

[Andrew Birch]

He’s much better playing behind the ball as a running half back and that’s where he’ll be playing by the look of it.
Concerns are injuries and not sure he’ll get any kick ins compared to Coleman.

I like Ed, had him in his rookie year. While he's a solid player and is a nice kick, he's never been much of an accumulator, even at under 18s level. There's a glass ceiling there that I don't see him breaking.

 

[Hack_Watts]

Crisp and Brayshaw

V

Dawson and Petracca

 

[Flandersss]

Crisp and Brayshaw

V

Dawson and Petracca

Dawson & Petracca

 

[stevebbb]

Curnow vs Brodie vs Ralpho

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Curnow vs Brodie vs Ralpho

Are things that desperate ? ....

 

[Claythesmiths]

Richard's always been swung around a lot and he's just not nearly as good in the forward line or on the wing. If he's consistently played in the back line, he'll score well for his price.

I think he's got too much competition for his spot with Dale, Daniel, Duryea, Williams, JJ and Crozier to be a safe pick.

 

[MacStradbroke]

Curnow vs Brodie vs Ralpho

Curnow easily for me.

 

[Flandersss]

Curnow easily for me.

+1.

 

[JuddgementDay]

Curnow easily for me.

Me three!

 

[Test Tickle]

Me three!

me four!

 

[Agent_99]

Rowell or Berry?
Davies or JFH?

 

[MacStradbroke]

Rowell or Berry?
Davies or JFH?

depends on cash
Davies

 

[Flandersss]

Rowell or Berry?
Davies or JFH?

Rowell
JHF

 

[JuddgementDay]

Caldwell vs JHF (+$60K)

 

[stevebbb]

Stewart + Crisp + Caldwell + Treloar + Curnow
vs
Sicily + Hewett + Oliver + Heeney/DeGoey/Bailey + Maginess



What's it look like, something like this?

105 + 105 + 85 + 100 + 70 = 465
vs
95 + 95 + 120 + 95 + 50 = 455

 

[Andrew Birch]

Stewart + Crisp + Caldwell + Treloar + Curnow
vs
Sicily + Hewett + Oliver + Heeney/DeGoey/Bailey + Maginess



What's it look like, something like this?

105 + 105 + 85 + 100 + 70 = 465
vs
95 + 95 + 120 + 95 + 50 = 455

90 down to 85 for Caldwell is still too high.

 

[Juzzomac]

Stewart + Crisp + Caldwell + Treloar + Curnow
vs
Sicily + Hewett + Oliver + Heeney/DeGoey/Bailey + Maginess



What's it look like, something like this?

105 + 105 + 90 + 100 + 70 = 470
vs
95 + 95 + 120 + 95 + 50 = 455

I think Caldwell probably about 10 points overrated in the first so gap isn't really there in scoring imo.

Cash gen better on the 1st and is overall less risky. 2nd has potential to be 4 keepers but could be stuck with sub-par options if Hewett and Sicily are neither here nor there.

Think a lot of people will start Curnow as well, could be a dangerous negative pod if he quickly shoots up 200k.

 

[stevebbb]

90 down to 85 for Caldwell is still too high.

I think Caldwell probably about 10 points overrated in the first so gap isn't really there in scoring imo.

Cash gen better on the 1st and is overall less risky. 2nd has potential to be 4 keepers but could be stuck with sub-par options if Hewett and Sicily are neither here nor there.

Think a lot of people will start Curnow as well, could be a dangerous negative pod if he quickly shoots up 200k.

Caldwell is getting a pure midfield role. They're giving midfield minutes to him over McGrath, that says a lot I reckon. I reckon he averages 85-95, he just needs to stay fit.

He's just a stepping stone, with the extra trades I'm happy to take him. Even an 80 average with a couple big scores in Bombers wins gets him to $400k, all I need

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

Stewart + Crisp + Caldwell + Treloar + Curnow
vs
Sicily + Hewett + Oliver + Heeney/DeGoey/Bailey + Maginess



What's it look like, something like this?

105 + 105 + 85 + 100 + 70 = 465
vs
95 + 95 + 120 + 95 + 50 = 455

Second option assuming Magginess plays. Don't like Caldwell and Treloar as picks, and Stewart ( ) and Crisp are priced at their maximum.

105 + 100 + 75 + 95 + 75 = 450
vs
100 + 95 + 125 + 95 (JdG) + 50 = 465

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Caldwell is getting a pure midfield role. They're giving midfield minutes to him over McGrath, that says a lot I reckon. I reckon he averages 85-95, he just needs to stay fit.

He's just a stepping stone, with the extra trades I'm happy to take him. Even an 80 average with a couple big scores in Bombers wins gets him to $400k, all I need

Berry versus Caldwell ?

 

[stevebbb]

Berry versus Caldwell ?

Berry is a must-have imo



Even if he has limited midfield minutes, he still gets an 80 average, and with a couple big scores a long the way, he gets to $400k. Great stepping stone