Opinion 2022 Player X vs Y vs Z

[Northernsoul74]

Dawson or Short? I have Dawson at the moment but his lack of preseason games worries me.

Ridley.

 

[ForeverHardcore]

Dawson or Short? I have Dawson at the moment but his lack of preseason games worries me.

Short by miles
Not touching Dawson without seeing his role
Also in doubt for round 1 so think it’s an easy pick now

 

[Significant]

Short by miles
Not touching Dawson without seeing his role
Also in doubt for round 1 so think it’s an easy pick now

Yep, I traded up to Crispy

 

[Test Tickle]

Hinge v Coleman?

 

[Duckworthy]

Hinge v Coleman?

Coleman. But a big watch this week to see what the Minge does

 

[Obese Arachnid]

Coleman. But a big watch this week to see what the Minge does

Agree totally, big watch on what Minge does.

 

[Duckworthy]

Agree totally, big watch on what Minge does.

In a 1v1, Coleman takes the Minge though, yeah?

 

[Obese Arachnid]

In a 1v1, Coleman takes the Minge though, yeah?

I would never back against the Minge.

As the old saying goes, "a Minge in the hand isn't worth jack shit compared to two in the bush."

 

[Duckworthy]

I would never back against the Minge.

As the old saying goes, "a Minge in the hand isn't worth jack sh*t compared to two in the bush."

 

[WaynesWorld19]

I would never back against the Minge.

As the old saying goes, "a Minge in the hand isn't worth jack sh*t compared to two in the bush."

A true poet ...

 

[Significant]

Weller vs Hewett? via the magic of Paddy McCartin

 

[Corleone]

 

[Significant]

View attachment 1335942

Have Curnow atm, and the group think will talk you out of Brodie.

I think I would prefer to have Brodie, but really need to see his role this week with a full Freo team being named.

Mind commenting on the one above?

 

[Corleone]

Have Curnow atm, and the group think will talk you out of Brodie.

I think I would prefer to have Brodie, but really need to see his role this week with a full Freo team being named.

Mind commenting on the one above?

I'm looking to fill a F5 slot in my starting team being filled by either player and I'm really on the fence ...

For me; if Brodie is going to play he's a better option - the DPP really makes him the superior option and yet Curnow is clearly the preferred option in a lot of teams.

I can also foresee a scenario where we are unclear if Brodie is going to make the R1 team (Freo playing Sunday afternoon) and with Curnow playing 3 days earlier it might be a big call to miss out on him for Brodie. I'm not a fan of anyone else in that price range either if Brodie doesn't make the team.

As for Hewett VS Weller; I have neither in my team, but I think Hewett is the better option.

 

[Juzzomac]

Have Curnow atm, and the group think will talk you out of Brodie.

I think I would prefer to have Brodie, but really need to see his role this week with a full Freo team being named.

Mind commenting on the one above?

Shame that Tucker won't play this week, by all reports he was set for a shift into inside midfield as well so could very well take Brodie's CBA's when he's back.

 

[stevebbb]

View attachment 1335942

I think we'll need both, plus Ginnivan

 

[Significant]

I'm actually keen on Won'tHe Rioli.

Anyone see how he went?

 

[Agent_99]

Hinge vs Kemp?

Is kemp likely to be a best 22? For 50k cheaper he could be the better option?

 

[Significant]

Hinge vs Kemp?

Is kemp likely to be a best 22? For 50k cheaper he could be the better option?

I've gone for Hinge at this stage - more mature body, looked lively on the weekend with 8 tackles and a kick-out. He doesn't have Seedsmans wing position which would make him more lucrative, but I liked what I saw.

Kemp scares me getting thrown around. If he is set down back, I would pounce, but Carlton seem stacked back there and now he is plugging holes with McKay away. Only 6 touches of the footy in a preseason stinks.

 

[JRyan23]

Hewett, Sicily, Berry v Crisp, Rowell, rookie

 

[rocker_oz33]

I'm actually keen on Won'tHe Rioli.

Anyone see how he went?

Willie ?

Didn't play WC board saying he had a hammy .

 

[Significant]

Willie ?

Didn't play WC board saying he had a hammy .

He definitely played. Numerous media outlets saying he kicked a nice goal.

 

[rocker_oz33]

He definitely played. Numerous media outlets saying he kicked a nice goal.

Funny WC Surporter s didn't know he played ...lol.

 

[Northernsoul74]

Hinge vs Kemp?

Is kemp likely to be a best 22? For 50k cheaper he could be the better option?

I prefer McCartin and Sinn over both.

 

[Significant]

I prefer McCartin and Sinn over both.

I prefer McCartin, Sinn I am a little wary of... unsure if he makes R1