Opinion 2022 Player X vs Y vs Z

[A Bit Dusty]

Titch / Dusty / Sinn vs Sheil / Rowell / Tom Stewart

 

[Samples]

Hewett, Sicily, Berry v Crisp, Rowell, rookie

Crisp, rowell and rookie just

 

[MacStradbroke]

I've gone for Hinge at this stage - more mature body, looked lively on the weekend with 8 tackles and a kick-out. He doesn't have Seedsmans wing position which would make him more lucrative, but I liked what I saw.

Kemp scares me getting thrown around. If he is set down back, I would pounce, but Carlton seem stacked back there and now he is plugging holes with McKay away. Only 6 touches of the footy in a preseason stinks.

The footage posted on the weekend of Hinge making the two big tackles in one play was really impressive. If he starts I’m on I think.

 

[MacStradbroke]

Titch / Dusty / Sinn vs Sheil / Rowell / Tom Stewart

Titch Dusty Sinn - they’re all solid picks, Shiel is not.

 

[Ingy]

View attachment 1335942

Purely on job security, it's Curnow.

He's an absolute lock if he's fit.

His type of job security and ceiling (what's Brodie's highest ever score? Bet it's less than 154) for 224,300 is a gift from the SC gods and you are mental if you don't take it IMO.

 

[Ingy]

Hinge vs Kemp?

Is kemp likely to be a best 22? For 50k cheaper he could be the better option?

My D5 and D6.

Like asking me to chose between my sons.

Gotta say though Kemp isn't 50k cheaper than Hinge - it's like 24k bro.

If I had to choose, I'd take the guy that killed more in the Wizard Cup...

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

Berry/Curnow vs Hewett/$124k rookie (hard I know without knowing the rookie)

First option means I have 5 midpricers which is 2/3 more than I really want.

 

[Significant]

Berry/Curnow vs Hewett/$124k rookie (hard I know without knowing the rookie)

First option means I have 5 midpricers which is 2/3 more than I really want.

Isn't Hewett a midpricer? not a big enough jump for me to get rid of Berry and Curnow, although, I'm not the biggest fan of Curnow

 

[Duckworthy]

Berry/Curnow vs Hewett/$124k rookie (hard I know without knowing the rookie)

First option means I have 5 midpricers which is 2/3 more than I really want.

Berry/Curnow
Just make sure you take very few risks with your premo's....no injury prone guys

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

Isn't Hewett a midpricer? not a big enough jump for me to get rid of Berry and Curnow, although, I'm not the biggest fan of Curnow

Well I currently have the second option so 4 mid pricers. Was just looking at ways to get Berry in if he's necessary. Hewett is probably a midpricer, although right on the edge I guess.

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

Berry/Curnow
Just make sure you take very few risks with your premo's....no injury prone guys

Lol.....like Whitfield, Butters, Dunks, and Sicily? Those sort of premo's?

 

[Duckworthy]

Lol.....like Whitfield, Butters, Dunks, and Sicily? Those sort of premo's?

Well, we'll both go down together

 

[Obese Arachnid]

Well, we'll both go down together

 

[rocker_oz33]

Well, we'll both go down together

Ground floor ladies bras n nickers.

Going down .

 

[TempletonTheRat]

Touk, Berry & Coleman
v
Titch, Sicily, $124k rookie

 

[Significant]

Touk, Berry & Coleman
v
Titch, Sicily, $124k rookie

Ouch tough one - League or Overall?

 

[AFDogs]

Parish vs Laird vs Wines

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

Parish vs Laird vs Wines

laird

 

[JuddgementDay]

Assuming fit JDG vs Dusty

I hate them both, but I'm likely to start with one of them

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

Assuming fit JDG vs Dusty

I hate them both, but I'm likely to start with one of them

Wait to see where De Poey plays, surely he's forward more after his interrupted preseason? Wait until Dustbin is under $450k in about round 7.

 

[toxic]

Parish vs Laird vs Wines

Wines

 

[JuddgementDay]

Wait to see where De Poey plays, surely he's forward more after his interrupted preseason? Wait until Dustbin is under $450k in about round 7.

I think you either have faith to start Dusty or not. $50k diff by RD7 is not that worthwhile to wait for

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

I think you either have faith to start Dusty or not. $50k diff by RD7 is not that worthwhile to wait for

Dusty is never again for me, so I'd listen to someone else there

 

[buttox]

Well I currently have the second option so 4 mid pricers. Was just looking at ways to get Berry in if he's necessary. Hewett is probably a midpricer, although right on the edge I guess.

Hewett is the 75th ranked defender.
He is a midpricer.
The top 15 defenders averaged 95+
They are premos + anyone who has done that before I suppose for example Sicily.

 

[TempletonTheRat]

Ouch tough one - League or Overall?

overall - it will probably come down to rookie availability in the end