Opinion 2022 Player X vs Y vs Z

[Hack_Watts]

Weller vs Hewett

 

[Significant]

Ridley and Cripps vs Sicily and Parish

I think Ridley and Cripps, Cripps presenting better value than Sicily ATS

Weller vs Hewett

See how Weller goes Monday night, but I think he has the higher chance of being a keeper

 

[Significant]

Risky picks...

Gawn v Darcy

Dawson v Short

 

[Flandersss]

Risky picks...

Gawn v Darcy

Dawson v Short

Gawn
Short

 

[Northernsoul74]

Risky picks...

Gawn v Darcy

Dawson v Short

Shocked to see Darcy nearly scored a ton. Not sure if that’s a positive or not.

 

[Significant]

Shocked to see Darcy nearly scored a ton. Not sure if that’s a positive or not.

Darcy and Dawson were staples of my team before preseason, and for obvious reasons have both fallen away in place of Gawn and Short.

My head says that any benefit of going Gawn and Short probably won't be a season defining one anyway (how much more points can Darcy and Dawson actually produce?) but I can't escape that nagging feeling that I was so set on them beforehand.

 

[Northernsoul74]

Darcy and Dawson were staples of my team before preseason, and for obvious reasons have both fallen away in place of Gawn and Short.

My head says that any benefit of going Gawn and Short probably won't be a season defining one anyway (how much more points can Darcy and Dawson actually produce?) but I can't escape that nagging feeling that I was so set on them beforehand.

Yeah Darcy was first picked for me and I was determined to go something different and than Gawndy. If Darcy’s ownership slips again it might still tempt me to back him in.

 

[AFDogs]

Darcy could not have played worse yesterday, against Nic Nat, and still scored 95. He is an absolute lock for me. He will score 200 when he plays Bulldogs.

 

[Northernsoul74]

Darcy could not have played worse yesterday, against Nic Nat, and still scored 95. He is an absolute lock for me. He will score 200 when he plays Bulldogs.

Now down to 16% ownership.

 

[Northernsoul74]

Onfield who scores more. Berry and JHF vs Rowell and Stephens.

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

Darcy could not have played worse yesterday, against Nic Nat, and still scored 95. He is an absolute lock for me. He will score 200 when he plays Bulldogs.

That was my take away from it too.

I think he's missed most of the intra-club hasn't he? So that was his first game in a while, will only improve.

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

Onfield who scores more. Berry and JHF vs Rowell and Stephens.

Reckon that will be close overall, and will vary wildly week to week.

 

[WaynesWorld19]

That was my take away from it too.

I think he's missed most of the intra-club hasn't he? So that was his first game in a while, will only improve.

Still had lingering issues with the finger .....not great for a Ruckman ....FREO probably happy t trade off getting some game minutes versus resting the finger anoter match

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

Still had lingering issues with the finger .....not great for a Ruckman ....FREO probably happy t trade off getting some game minutes versus resting the finger anoter match

Yeah I guess. The more people jump off the more tempting he becomes.

 

[MacStradbroke]

Weller vs Hewett

Weller

 

[Significant]

Crisp, Short, Rowell

vs

Sicily, Weller, Parish

vs

Sicily, Heeney, Jelly

 

[MacStradbroke]

Crisp, Short, Rowell

vs

Sicily, Weller, Parish

vs

Sicily, Heeney, Jelly

Tough question but option 2 for me.

 

[AFDogs]

Crisp, Short, Rowell

vs

Sicily, Weller, Parish

vs

Sicily, Heeney, Jelly

Option 1 IMO. See how Rowell goes tonight though.

 

[weltschmerz]

Hewett and Hinge, or Chapman and Blakey?

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

Hewett and Hinge, or Chapman and Blakey?

 

[weltschmerz]

Valid.

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

Valid.

No second year players, not worth the risk. Piggy is about the only one really worth it in recent times.

 

[JuddgementDay]

Brodie (hot preseason form, trap?) vs JHF (must have rookie?)

 

[WaynesWorld19]

This !!

No second year players, not worth the risk. Piggy is about the only one really worth it in recent times.

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

This !!
View attachment 1340259

Perkins looks good though.....