Opinion 2022 Player X vs Y vs Z

[SloppyJoe]

Upgrade time

Out:
Green
Gresham
(1,121,000)

In:
A) Bont/Merrett - Heeney
B) Steele - Rozee
C) Steele - Dunc
D) Warner - Dunc et al
E) Laird - Nobody
F) Bont - Paps (pod)

thoughts

I think Bont is a must have if you can get him.

As to who to partner with him, Heeney seems to have turned a corner.

Assuming you need a forward priced around $450k, Tex Walker is a real left field option to consider.

 

[SloppyJoe]

Mills and $80k in the bank vs Steele and $94k?

2 trades left reserved for injury so the cash is pretty important.

 

[evo]

Mills and $80k in the bank vs Steele and $94k?

2 trades left reserved for injury so the cash is pretty important.

Warner seems to be taking some of Mills time in the centre, I d go Steele

 

[gh172]

Mills vs
R Marshall ?

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Mills vs
R Marshall ?

Mills ..... SYD in the Finals push for top 4 ....and a great run home

Marshall ... SAINTS maybe out of Finals contention soon ....Mills has the more consistent scoring trend, and has a higher ceiling than Marshall

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

Damn - I didn't see this - I would have advised differently

You get your chance for revenge straight away, we're matched up again haha.

 

[Test Tickle]

best JS?
Cumberland
Carmichael
Culley
I just need one of them to play the season out.

 

[JuddgementDay]

You get your chance for revenge straight away, we're matched up again haha.

View attachment 1452140

Sorry, I haven’t been paying attention, apart from beating me last week - how has your year been?

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

Sorry, I haven’t been paying attention, apart from beating me last week - how has your year been?

Shit, terrible year. But I'm on the charge now, gone from 29k to 17 in the last month. Might even sneak the top 10K

How about you?

 

[JuddgementDay]

s**t, terrible year. But I'm on the charge now, gone from 29k to 17 in the last month. Might even sneak the top 10K

How about you?

I started with a great team and progressively made it worst by my trades

But, I'm sitting on 3K or so

 

[VainGlorious]

best JS?
Cumberland
Carmichael
Culley
I just need one of them to play the season out.

Paul Vander Haar.

























Probably Culley.

 

[Cats_29]

Need help please.

To cover Hewett I could swing McCartin to def
and trade in Culley as a fwd.
Leaving 4 trades left and $140k
(Thinking Short to Stewart next week)

Or could trade in Burgoyne to cover Hewett and then upgrade McCartin to Marshall.
Leaving 3 trades left and $50k

Bit worried about Marshall being sick and Burgoyne’s job security.

Thoughts please..

 

[Mateyman]

Play Cameron or Coniglio this week?

 

[A Bit Dusty]

Play Cameron or Coniglio this week?

Coniglio

 

[toxic]

Play Cameron or Coniglio this week?

Ruckman

 

[Jiska]

Crisp to Stewart vs Cripps to Steele

 

[Soggy2112]

Crisp to Stewart vs Cripps to Steele

Crisp to Stewart for mine, think more people would be holding Cripps so less likely to hurt you

 

[Hava Alle]

Ridley, Short or Crisp to Stewart?

 

[Ingy]

Ridley, Short or Crisp to Stewart?

Short IMO

 

[Hava Alle]

Short IMO

ATM I've gone Ridley. Purely for the fact that Essendon have nothing to play for now. Redman should be out next week so he should get a few free chips though.

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

Ridley, Short or Crisp to Stewart?

Short

 

[King Max]

Crisp to Stewart vs Cripps to Steele

Crisp to Steward because he can go big. Plus most teams have Cripps which cancels out.

 

[ForeverHardcore]

Crisp to Stewart vs Cripps to Steele

Crisp to Stewart for sure
Crisp is in putrid form
At least Cripps showed he can score well again on the weekend and has a great draw the last month midfield wise to finish

Also Stewart with 3/4 at Cat stadium is going to be juicy

 

[weltschmerz]

I have one trade. Crisp to Stewart, DC to Himmelberg, or save for emergencies?

 

[buttox]

I have one trade. Crisp to Stewart, DC to Himmelberg, or save for emergencies?

Save the trade imo