Draft Review 2023 - Re-do the draft

[Yoda_]

I read what you were basing it off.
Would still argue strongly COS is on that list ahead of Curtin, Wilson and Sanders.

look to be fair, I didnt bother looking to far down the list mate. I value your input on BigFooty, wasn't looking too far down the rankings. Could well make a case as you say for some interchanging to those at the bottom of the 10

 

[Milanista28]

I'd still take Harley 1st.

 

[KissKiss]

I'd still take Harley 1st.

First 3 years I'd still be going something like 80% on potential, 20% on performance. So yeah Harley and even guys like Walter would still be considered high.

 

[Sonny Hayes]

my rankings was based on the careers so far, lets all cool our jets a bit here.

You are significantly overrating Robert’s here, probably the easiest position in football to play. Good stats and decent player but impact far below what the numbers say.

No where near guys like Reid, Morris, Watson on current output or potential

 

[Yoda_]

You are significantly overrating Robert’s here, probably the easiest position in football to play. Good stats and decent player but impact far below what the numbers say.

No where near guys like Reid, Morris, Watson on current output or potential

im just going with actual output and influence on games

 

[Yoda_]

I'd still take Harley 1st.

to be fair here, so would i

Kid looks like he could be a generational talent in the Dusty, Buddy mould

 

[Sonny Hayes]

im just going with actual output and influence on games

I know but I think you are vastly overrating Robert’s impact or underrating the others

 

[Yoda_]

I know but I think you are vastly overrating Robert’s impact or underrating the others

are posters under rating Roberts' game having gone to another level ?

 

[HeHateMe]

Roberts should now be considered along side someone like Curtin who had a period of footy last year that was class. I originally had him Tier 4 that's too low, tier 3 boarding tier 2 is his go, for now let's see how he goes on with it.

Revised after 5 weeks this year.

Tier 1
Ried, Watson, Morris
Tier 2
Mannagh, Freijah, Mckercher, Caddy
Tier 3
Curtin, Roberts, Sanders, O'Sullivan, Read
Tier 4
Humphries, Walter, Duursma, Wilson, Windsor, Garcia, Fonti, Thomas, Graham, Dear

I'll revisit it again end of season but as of right now this is where I see it.

 

[Sonny Hayes]

are posters under rating Roberts' game having gone to another level ?

Don’t think so, he’s a good player. He is however playing the easiest position on the ground, and his raw numbers are elite but I don’t think he’s a highly damaging player.

Benefited greatly especially these past 2 weeks from the game plan

 

[JHF1870]

I'd still take Harley 1st.

For the remainder of this season I'd take Nick Watson.

Beyond that, probably Reid but only if he cleans up his game, and he needs to improve his fitness.