List Mgmt. 2023 Trade & List Management Thread III

[GS WARRIORS]

View attachment 1838078

Perez is not on the list anymore. He is missing Taylor. Has this bloke ever written an article that doesn't have a big mistake in it.


Do they not have anyone reading their articles before publishing them? If they did they would have seen Perez listed in the departed list. We have two of him do we?

 

[Hearts to hearts]

Perez is not on the list anymore. He is missing Taylor. Has this bloke ever written an article that doesn't have a big mistake in it. Do they not have anyone reading their articles before publishing them?

He said eight players were left then listed nine names, so it fell the first hurdle.

 

[GS WARRIORS]

He said eight players were left then listed nine names, so it fell the first hurdle.

I didn't count that. I thought he could at least count to 8 correctly using his fingers.

 

[King Corey]

Perez is not on the list anymore. He is missing Taylor. Has this bloke ever written an article that doesn't have a big mistake in it.


Do they not have anyone reading their articles before publishing them? If they did they would have seen Perez listed in the departed list. We two both of him do we?

To be fair I'd like to forget Taylor is on the list too.

 

[Shinboner1]

To be fair I'd like to forget Taylor is on the list too.

CCJ who?..

 

[DocSholl]

Tom Highmore currently out of contract as per HS article. He worth a spot? Has gone missing as of late but I remember him being an ok defender.

More of a third tall type than a KPD

 

[Merlin007]

Perez is not on the list anymore. He is missing Taylor. Has this bloke ever written an article that doesn't have a big mistake in it.


Do they not have anyone reading their articles before publishing them? If they did they would have seen Perez listed in the departed list. We have two of him do we?

sub-editors went the way of the dinosaur (and the Age printing press on the Tulla freeway) as ad revenue collapsed in the print media.

it's publish and be damned now

 

[ferball]

View attachment 1838078

Lmac was the only player on the list when we cut Boomer etc.

10 or 11 in 2016, 8 in 2017, 11 or 12 in 2018 and at least 6 in 2019. So 35 - 37 in those four years as well.

So 80 - 82 players have been turned over since (and including) Boomer etc.

 

[lockheed]

If things click and we're up and about early in the season then I'd love to be chatting to Ben King and Aaron Cadman about a potential mid season trade.

We'll have a big hole at CHF and we could be looking good in most other spots if the Comben move back works, our draft picks are contributing and the others young players are fit and firing.

The other move to watch would be Sean Darcy's contract situation and whether we can bring him across after next season.

The dream being both of those moves + our young guys living up to expectations and we are looking at a really talented side.

FB: Corr - Logue - Archer/Bergman
HB: Reid/McKercher - Comben - Fisher
C: Scott - LDU - Stephens
HF: Zurhaar - King/Cadman - Sheezel
FF: George - Larkey - Curtis
Foll: Darcy - Wardlaw - Thomas

Int: pick from Duursma, Simpkin, Goater, Phillips, Ford, Powell, Lmac, Stevo, Xerri, CCJ...

Obviously the more likely scenario is modest improvement and another good draft/trade period in 2024 with hopes of climbing the ladder after that. But I can dream.

We have to dream big. Otherwise, what's the point.

 

[shimaburnsgrieg]

View attachment 1838078

I would expect a further 10-12 players to be cut at the end of '24 as well - we have a ways to go yet.

 

[year of the roo]

I would expect a further 10-12 players to be cut at the end of '24 as well - we have a ways to go yet.

OOC end of 24:
44 Cameron Zurhaar Restricted Free Agent 2024
5 Curtis Taylor Non-Free Agent 2024
8 Bailey Scott Non-Free Agent 2024
14 Liam Shiels Non-Free Agent 2024
18 Hugh Greenwood Non-Free Agent 2024
24 Tom Powell Non-Free Agent 2024
26 Tarryn Thomas Non-Free Agent 2024
29 Will Phillips Non-Free Agent 2024
33 Brayden George Non-Free Agent 2024
34 Jackson Archer Non-Free Agent 2024
35 Charlie Lazzaro Non-Free Agent 2024
37 Cooper Harvey Non-Free Agent 2024
40 Eddie Ford Non-Free Agent 2024
41 Blake Drury Non-Free Agent 2024
42 Kallan Dawson Non-Free Agent 2024
0 Toby Pink Non-Free Agent 2024
46 Robert Hansen Jr Non-Free Agent 2024
45 Hamish Free

Yet again, so many in 2025 OOC list that should be in the gun but will be safe: Corr, Tucker, CCJ, Xerri.

Of the 2024 list, right now I am only offering contracts to Scott, Ford and TT (assuming no more incidents). Zurhaar is a watch this space. Really like him as a player and a clubman, but depending on FA offers he gets elsewhere and assuming we finish low again, his compensation might be too good to refuse (I'm also assuming that George comes in and shows potential in a role not dissimilar to Zurhaar's).

 

[Sheezel2Wardlaw]

Freo want a pick before West Coasts to take Collard. I think we should also be trying to move up the board but also keeping 5 picks.

How about Pick 17 to Freo for F1 tied to Collingwood.

Pick 6 & 11 from Melb for our F1 & 15

Head to the draft with 2, 3, 6, 11 & 18
And still have an F1 for 2024.

 

[Playthekids76]

That would be a colossal error. Think of how Darcy Tucker plods up the ground, then increase the ploddiness twofold. That's what you've got with Bonner

Nah you are off here mate. Bonner is quick and agile compared to Tucker. Two different players IMO.

 

[Harris 10]

Nah you are off here mate. Bonner is quick and agile compared to Tucker. Two different players IMO.

Bonnar is a better player than Tucker, at least he has a weapon.

In saying that if both of them can get another 25 to 35 AFL games out of themselves they've done well.

 

[Snowy off the Tram]

Why would he never get it? Knowing he is a good user, his teammates would look for him... Blake Coleman doesn't overly defend but got it plenty on gf day first qtr particularly before they moved him


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

Keidean aka Kiddy?

 

[Playthekids76]

Pendlebury's a fair rebuttal. One in a million player though. Bonner doesn't have that evasiveness. Sheezel can move well enough to the point that his slowness doesn't stick out. Likewise with Lipinski

Totally disagree, watch his footage he is evasive. Would be a good get for you, coming into his prime and will provide experience. Poorly treated at my club and played out of position this year. 2022 was best 22 all day but x2 nasty injuries robbed him of a complete season.

 

[BlueandWhiteinmyBlood]

Freo want a pick before West Coasts to take Collard. I think we should also be trying to move up the board but also keeping 5 picks.

How about Pick 17 to Freo for F1 tied to Collingwood.

Pick 6 & 11 from Melb for our F1 & 15

Head to the draft with 2, 3, 6, 11 & 18
And still have an F1 for 2024.

Why would Melbourne do that?

 

[Sheezel2Wardlaw]

Why would Melbourne do that?

If we are garbage again, it could land them a pick inside 3 for next year.

 

[Playthekids76]

Actually, in defence of Bonner, he has averaged 17.27 disposals a game in his 93 games, though he was down to 12.91 disposals a game this year.

As a fan of him I can tell you he was played out of position in 2023, Hinkley played him on the wing which if you watched my shite club you will note they didnt use.....either.. 2022 he played HB all year and was best 22, copped x2 nasty impact injuries which robbed him of a top 10 BnF finish. Would be a good get, undervalued at Port.

 

[The Nostradamus]

Bonner is a spud
Hard pass

Take our 5 picks in the draft
Grab a KPP dfa
Take rookie pick 2 or leave a spot spare for ssp/msd

 

[hilly]

Freo want a pick before West Coasts to take Collard. I think we should also be trying to move up the board but also keeping 5 picks.

How about Pick 17 to Freo for F1 tied to Collingwood.

Pick 6 & 11 from Melb for our F1 & 15

Head to the draft with 2, 3, 6, 11 & 18
And still have an F1 for 2024.

Freo would bite our hand off for that.

 

[Sillygit]

Freo want a pick before West Coasts to take Collard. I think we should also be trying to move up the board but also keeping 5 picks.

How about Pick 17 to Freo for F1 tied to Collingwood.

Pick 6 & 11 from Melb for our F1 & 15

Head to the draft with 2, 3, 6, 11 & 18
And still have an F1 for 2024.

Death ride the current premiers? Bold.

Also, no trading of any of our F1's until we arent a bottom 6 team. Cause its entirely possible that ends up we could have had top 2 pick but instead we have a late teens.

 

[The Filth Wizard]

If we are garbage again, it could land them a pick inside 3 for next year.

Just for what it's worth the Hawks had 7 wins, the GC had 9 this year and still in a normal draft that is pick 3 and 4. It's wildly optimistic to back ourselves to climb that far and you want to add 15 (19?) to those picks for 6 and what will end up 15-16? Not to mention trading 17 for the future F1 of the reigning premier.

We would be booed for making either of those deals until my voice is hoarse.

 

[GS WARRIORS]

Freo want a pick before West Coasts to take Collard. I think we should also be trying to move up the board but also keeping 5 picks.

How about Pick 17 to Freo for F1 tied to Collingwood.

Pick 6 & 11 from Melb for our F1 & 15

Head to the draft with 2, 3, 6, 11 & 18
And still have an F1 for 2024.

How about we take Collard for ourselves.

 

[King Corey]

There is virtually no deal now that player trades are gone that would justify trading our F1.

No realistic (or even unrealistic) pick swap would hedge against the risk.