List Mgmt. 2025 List Management discussion - part 2

[Joffaboy]

What's happened to the quality of trolls?

Campaigner Paddy put an end to it yesterday.

 

[Teflon]

You'd think if Tony was worried he would be playing damage control

Or he hasn’t heard

 

[Joffaboy]

Port's sensitive spot is Butters. Their board wouldn't trade him even if we had Jesus Christ himself on our list and he wanted to go back to SA.

Hey I'm not religious but the new rule is no mention of sky fairy's or their proclamations unless some posters have to retreat to their safe space.

Edit: reckon Christ would rather be crucified again than have to go to SA.

 

[Moquo]

Interesting the club just posted a random reel about Sincs/Harvey tied by the number 35. I saw a TikTok the other day exactly the same but it was Nas/Winmar and the 7

 

[snails13]

View attachment 2383782

Is he related to Nas

 

[Saint Shags]

Tony does have a track record.

Tony also has a record of being wrong at times as well.

Like everyone he is not infallible.

 

[Joffaboy]

Tony also has a record of being wrong at times as well.

Like everyone he is not infallible.

Only the Pope is infallible, maybe we should get him posting here.

Damn mentioned religion again

 

[Yawkey way]

View attachment 2383782

Of course we are.

 

[Yawkey way]

He makes no sense to our list build

A lot of things we do make no sense, so in a very strange way it makes sense.

 

[Joffaboy]

Of course we are.

Can you imagine trying to spin this at trade week end.
'Sure we lost the best generational talent in decades at this club for a packet of Tim Tam's and Travis Boak, but we got a new middling ruckman and reserve back for 2.5 million a year plus a past it selfish front running small forward for the great price of our first rounder'

 

[Saint Shags]

Only the Pope is infallible, maybe we should get him posting here.

Damn mentioned religion again

Spent many years on Saintsational just like yourself.
Tony has had some good info. He has also had some very incorrect info.

Last thing I wouldn't like to see is posters targeted for the information being incorrect in the end.

And im not sure why the need to be a smart arse comment with the religion aspect. Was asked as a consideration by a poster.

 

[TheJackal]

If we survive this and Nas stays, I could almost guarantee SOS and his ego will be offering the keys of Moorabbin to Butters as a FA next year.

 

[stavro#4]

Or he hasn’t heard

The club is aware/of the belief he wants to stay. Infact their belief is that there isn’t even ACTIVE negotiations happening with either SA clubs. By which I mean Williams going back and forth putting each offer on the table and putting them against each other. They are aware they are making offers and so they should.

And still no club has approached us to discuss what a trade would need to look like.

That is why there is zero pressure being applied to the player.

Everything is zeroed in on Williams. Hence yesterday’s leak back to Morris.

Which, fair play to the club for outing this Tex Wanganeen story. Whether you agree with the actual action of potentially recruiting a delisted afl player to retain their cousin or not. They have put the ball publicly back in the agents/players court.

Go home to family vs give your cousin another crack the big time

SA friends vs Vic friends

They have matched the key points here.

 

[stavro#4]

If we survive this and Nas stays, I could almost guarantee SOS and his ego will be offering the keys of Moorabbin to Butters as a FA next year.

Chasing someone else this year.

 

[Dard Ball Get]

If we survive this and Nas stays, I could almost guarantee SOS and his ego will be offering the keys of Moorabbin to Butters as a FA next year.

So, doing his job?
Wtf does ego have to do with that hahaha

 

[Mowman]

Can you imagine trying to spin this at trade week end.
'Sure we lost the best generational talent in decades at this club for a packet of Tim Tam's and Travis Boak, but we got a new middling ruckman and reserve back for 2.5 million a year plus a past it selfish front running small forward for the great price of our first rounder'

But sadly this is exactly what could/will happen

Liam Ryan they reckon LOL OH GOD

 

[Yawkey way]

Can you imagine trying to spin this at trade week end.
'Sure we lost the best generational talent in decades at this club for a packet of Tim Tam's and Travis Boak, but we got a new middling ruckman and reserve back for 2.5 million a year plus a past it selfish front running small forward for the great price of our first rounder'

Welcome to st Kilda, who once put one of my favourite players in a cab and sent him off to play for the hawks.

This club has disappointed generations of supporters, occasionally delighted or amused although more often bemused, it’s who we are.

I think it’s trying to solve the puzzle that is st Kilda that keeps a lot of supporters on board.

 

[Sully111]

View attachment 2383782

Phew

Seems everything is going to be ok after all...

 

[SainterinSydney]

The club is aware/of the belief he wants to stay. Infact their belief is that there isn’t even ACTIVE negotiations happening with either SA clubs. By which I mean Williams going back and forth putting each offer on the table and putting them against each other. They are aware they are making offers and so they should.

And still no club has approached us to discuss what a trade would need to look like.

That is why there is zero pressure being applied to the player.

Everything is zeroed in on Williams. Hence yesterday’s leak back to Morris.

Which, fair play to the club for outing this Tex Wanganeen story. Whether you agree with the actual action of potentially recruiting a delisted afl player to retain their cousin or not. They have put the ball publicly back in the agents/players court.

Go home to family vs give your cousin another crack the big time

SA friends vs Vic friends

They have matched the key points here.

It's actually very clever on the club's part. You'd imagine Gavin Wanganeen would love the idea of his son getting another shot at the AFL.

 

[Saintos The ITK]

The club is aware/of the belief he wants to stay. Infact their belief is that there isn’t even ACTIVE negotiations happening with either SA clubs. By which I mean Williams going back and forth putting each offer on the table and putting them against each other. They are aware they are making offers and so they should.

And still no club has approached us to discuss what a trade would need to look like.

That is why there is zero pressure being applied to the player.

Everything is zeroed in on Williams. Hence yesterday’s leak back to Morris.

Which, fair play to the club for outing this Tex Wanganeen story. Whether you agree with the actual action of potentially recruiting a delisted afl player to retain their cousin or not. They have put the ball publicly back in the agents/players court.

Go home to family vs give your cousin another crack the big time

SA friends vs Vic friends

They have matched the key points here.

Bit of a guilt trip for poor ole NaZ. Unless of course he’s the one who’s asked for it

 

[Joffaboy]

Spent many years on Saintsational just like yourself.
Tony has had some good info. He has also had some very incorrect info.

Last thing I wouldn't like to see is posters targeted for the information being incorrect in the end.

And im not sure why the need to be a smart arse comment with the religion aspect. Was asked as a consideration by a poster.

I'll post what I want to. You aren't a mod.

 

[stavro#4]

Bit of a guilt trip for poor ole NaZ. Unless of course he’s the one who’s asked for it

Well he would be aware of it wouldn’t he.

Again, the club went to sa around the time of the transfer to Sandy and thought we had a deal.

Nas had some big games post that meeting.

 

[Saintos The ITK]

Tex might get his choice of clubs. He’ll be the real winner out of all this

 

[MightySaint]

Chasing someone else this year.

Please be Flanders!!!

 

[Saints TV]

Tex might get his choice of clubs. He’ll be the real winner out of all this

we know who Benny Williams is REALLY working for.

Masterclass by Tex