List Mgmt. 2025 List Management discussion - part 2

[Plugger35]

Both clubs have never met SOS if they genuinely think their current draft hands will get them a top 5 player in the comp.

Also, how f*cked is the competition if the minor premiers can poach a 22 year old top 5 player while offering him the lowest deal with nothing of value to trade.

It also doesn't seem fair that they could have both Rankine and Nas in the same team, they are similar exciting playmakers.

If they get Nas from us they should be forced to send us Rankine in return but I don't think he would be too keen on that idea.

He left the Suns to go back home to Adelaide so we could end up in the same situation with him if he had to move to Melbourne.

 

[Saint Shags]

leaving to a team because they’re close to winning a flag is as pea hearted as it gets.

Let's be real here.

You're a player and you have the Crows or Port to choose from? Keeping in mind you're leaving a team that hasn't been finals bound. Crows would be the logical option. Can't blame him for Port hitting the wall.

It sucks but thats what it is.

 

[Lennylegs]

Even more confident now. That Crom report is horseshit. He ain't going to the Crom.

The going home to Adelaide side of this story is fluctuating too much. Not really holding its ground.

Even more confident he's staying.

 

[Stan_Darsh72]

Let's be real here.

You're a player and you have the Crows or Port to choose from? Keeping in mind you're leaving a team that hasn't been finals bound. Crows would be the logical option. Can't blame him for Port hitting the wall.

It sucks but thats what it is.

Tbh given the choice of Crows vs Port I would pick Port every time.

Crows always can rebuild fast.

 

[BrutThough]

It also doesn't seem fair that they could have both Rankine and Nas in the same team, they are similar exciting playmakers.

If they get Nas from us they should be forced to send us Rankine in return but I don't think he would be too keen on that idea.

He left the Suns to go back home to Adelaide so we could end up in the same situation with him if he had to move to Melbourne.

They have to give up something of value. It not be Rankine but they will have to find something.

 

[dudeintheswamp]

I think Nas is going to stay home

 

[Broski]

“Hey lads - I definitely haven’t made my mind up, but if I did I would go to the Crows. But I haven’t made my mind up though. I am just saying if I was to leave that’s where I’d go.”

 

[Plugger35]

They have to give up something of value. It not be Rankine but they will have to find something.

Yeah you don't deserve to get a brand new Ferrari by trading in an old clapped out Datsun 180B.

 

[Verdun]

Lowest character poster those that post on other clubs boards

Supposedly we've been in his ear for a few years now which is why we reportedly offer him as much $1.3M 7 years before his breakout and haven't move from that offer despite Port Power offering him even more money and the Saints matching their offer.

Why didn't you draft him before us when you could have.

fk off to your own board.

 

[snails13]

If Nas ends up at Adelaide i wonder if his best mates,Borlase and Horn - Francis will continue to talk to him,they would've been so cocky that if he leaves Saint that he would go to Port

 

[my name was taken]

leaving to a team because they’re close to winning a flag is as pea hearted as it gets.

Exception for 30yr olds, not those with 10 years left

 

[beside the seaside]

I think these Crows reports are positive for us. Really don't think he goes there. If he has rejected Port then I reckon we are on like donkey kong.

 

[thekizzler]

No they asked for a future first, we offer a future third.

I understand that was a report at the time.

But my point is the club didn't balls up here.

It is hindsight rubbish to suggest so.

 

[BrutThough]

Yeah you don't deserve to get a brand new Ferrari by trading in an old clapped out Datsun 180B.

Unfortunately, their arrogance makes them believe they can.

 

[Joffaboy]

Ended up as pick 10 and a 3rd rounder given the future picks swap relative to our position on the ladder. Still too much for a player who was good for only half a season, our previous CEO told Reid to order pizza and get the deal done.

Ended up lol. It was two frdp's for the worst most overrated player at the time

Redirect Notice

Not jog on back to your own board with your bs.

 

[botts]

What did Carlton get for Squibbs the following year, lol

Squibbed was the most over rated player of the day and you got royally screwed, lol

Still got two first rounders for him the following year.

 

[snails13]

How long is a minimum contract for the PSD ?

 

[botts]

In regards to Fincher… do we have to get him beyond pick 20 or did they change that rule again? And is he expected to drift past pick 20? I’m not much of an U18 follower.

We can get him any time in the draft

 

[jwikked]

Exception for 30yr olds, not those with 10 years left

Nah no exception, it’s weak to do that. It was great when Deledio bailed on the Tigers for a flag and then missed out

 

[Mr Platinum]

Remember Daisy Thomas reported Nas is in a group chat with the Adelaide blokes.

 

[jwikked]

Remember Daisy Thomas reported Nas is in a group chat with the Adelaide blokes.

There’s be a lot less people in group chats, if it didn’t alert everyone when you leave it

 

[botts]

I understand that was a report at the time.

But my point is the club didn't balls up here.

It is hindsight rubbish to suggest so.

Not future first. They asked for a future second. I shouldn’t drink and type

 

[stavro#4]

Ended up as pick 10 and a 3rd rounder given the future picks swap relative to our position on the ladder. Still too much for a player who was good for only half a season, our previous CEO told Reid to order pizza and get the deal done.

You gave up 2 first rounders for Gibbs you imbecile and swapped second rounders.

 

[projectv]

It also doesn't seem fair that they could have both Rankine and Nas in the same team, they are similar exciting playmakers.

If they get Nas from us they should be forced to send us Rankine in return but I don't think he would be too keen on that idea.

He left the Suns to go back home to Adelaide so we could end up in the same situation with him if he had to move to Melbourne.

Brisbane got Levi for a handful of junk picks in the 40's, right after winning the premiership.

The AFL wouldn't bat an eyelid if Nas wanted to be in the same team as Rankine.

After Bassat's sooking this year, I'm sure they will be quite fine with letting us get screwed.

 

[Mr Platinum]

There’s be a lot less people in group chats, if it didn’t alert everyone when you leave it

Tony74 is Tony Brown?