Section 5
Norm Smith Medallist
- Nov 26, 2018
- 9,304
- 14,877
- AFL Club
- Brisbane Lions
So far, the two changes are 5 on the bench no sub, the bounce down is scrapped. There could be some other changes to come, or not.
Personally, i love the “no bounce down” but others may not.
I think most will agree that 5 on the bench is better than 4 and a sub.
I hated the sub and regularly mentioned i did not care who the sub was during the season
Will it stay at 5 as we have seen changes to the sub rule before. I think it will.
Each club is in a different stage of development and will use the extra player differently.
I see debuting players and other players with just a few AFL games playing via the bench being a good move for a lot of clubs.
Maybe some will try to run two rucks without having that forward ruck position player.
Easing good players back with limited game time rather than via the VFL may be considered
Sheedy often said you can't have enough midfielders in your team. A lot of clubs may go that way. If not pure midfield likely a forward/wing/mid versatile player
Who the opposition is could also come into consideration
I don’t necessarily see that 5th player as being just the next best 23 player in line.
In my opinion the bench selection will change as the season progresses. Coaches will learn and adjust with each game
Our GF team below as a reference point as it's not a best 23 thread. Proven or new/injured best 23 AFL players to the side in brackets. For now, i did not include Coleman, Doedee or McCarthy as they have a lot to prove in the preseason. All used to be best 23 though. Also, a few Drafts to come but i included Annable
B: D.Zorko, D.Gardiner, R.Lester (Payne inj)
HB: D.Wilmot, H.Andrews (c), J Fletcher (Answerth inj)
C: S.Marshall, H.McCluggage, L.Ashcroft (Berry inj,)
HF: C.Cameron, L.Morris, T.Gallop, (Allen inj, Hipwood inj)
F: Z Bailey, C.Rayner, K Lohman (McKenna,)
FOLL: D.Fort, J.Dunkley, W.Ashcroft (Draper inj)
I/C: B. Reville, C Ah-Chee, B Starcevich, O.McInerney , L Neale (c) sub.
.............................................................................
The remaining players below. Looking at these players we are short on midfielders and small forwards
Defense: Coleman inj, Doedee, Brain, Beecken, Lloyd, Zakostelsky, Joyce
Midfield/Ruck: Smith, Tunstill, Annable, Torrent
Forward: McCarthy inj, McLachlan
EDIT 1 29/10/25 7 rule changes now approved for season 2026
www.afl.com.au
Last season, the AFL's findings discovered that the goalsquare was the last remaining facet of 6-6-6 to be organised at 10 per cent of all post-goal restarts. On average, that delayed the game by 8-10 seconds per instance. The League subsequently expects the total time saved through this rule change will be around 20-30 seconds per match.
It will operate similar to SANFL in the sense that if a player blocks an opponent or doesn't play the ball before it crosses the line, a normal boundary throw-in will occur instead of a last disposal free kick.
In the 2025 season, the AFL's findings discovered that there were 20 boundary throw-ins paid between the arcs and 0.5 insufficient intent free kicks paid between the arcs per game. The League then adapted those numbers for a scenario where the last disposal rule had been introduced. Its adapted numbers showed boundary throw-ins would be reduced by three per game, while 0.3 current insufficient intent free kicks would be negated by a last disposal free kick.
The adapted numbers also showed that there would have been an average of 3.25 last disposal free kicks per game paid across the 2025 season.
The query from club land has been whether a last disposal rule would kill the ruck. However, there still would have been 67 stoppages per game on average in 2025 based on the adapted numbers. That would have brought it back in line with the AFL's 2023 and 2024 averages.
The AFL has said this rule would not have been possible without the end of the 'centre bounce', as opposed to the 'centre ball-up', due to the variables of which direction the ball can go from a bounce. The ball-up also gives the umpire extra time and ability to assess where the ruck is stationed when he engages his opponent.
The AFL's findings discovered that only 21 per cent of centre bounce ruck contests had at least one ruck jumping in the 2025 season. In 2023, just two years ago, that number was at 63 per cent.
There will still be an opportunity for the more physical wrestling rucks to impact the game at around-the-ground stoppages and boundary throw-ins.
The AFL sampled more than 1200 kick-ins across the 2025 season, with a quarter of those lasting longer than 10 seconds and 13 per cent lasting longer than 12 seconds.
There was an average of 21 kick-ins taken per game across the 2025 season. If a quarter of those are reduced by four or five seconds, the League is conservatively hoping that around 21 seconds of match length is knocked off through kick-ins alone.
The 'third-man up' is still outlawed, so if no rucks nominate – or if the two nominated rucks are too far away when play is restarted – the ball will be thrown up and will have to hit the ground before 'play on' is called.
The AFL discovered that there were on average four ball-ups and six boundary throw-ins per game last season with a delay due to the umpire waiting for nominated rucks to arrive at a contest before restarting the play. It contributed to an average of three and a half seconds worth of delay on ball-ups and around one second worth of delay on boundary throw-ins.
One particular example from St Kilda's victory over Melbourne late in the year saw two rucks nominate for a boundary throw-in on the opposite wing, despite only just returning to the field of play from the bench. The umpire waited more than 25 seconds for the two rucks to arrive at the contest, before restarting the play.
It's hoped this will stop players from contributing to a high tackle, while making the rule easier to adjudicate for umpires.
Now, if you are within 5m of a mark or a free kick when it is paid, deemed the protected area, you will be required to 'stand' and can no longer reverse to being 'outside five'.
The AFL found that more and more players have left the protected area to stand 'outside five' across the last season. In 2025 alone, the AFL's findings discovered that only 58 per cent of opposition players would 'stand' when told while 18 per cent of players went to the area deemed 'outside five' by the umpire.
It's hoped this will see more players take the game on, encourage overlapping possessions and more free-flowing ball movement.
Personally, i love the “no bounce down” but others may not.
I think most will agree that 5 on the bench is better than 4 and a sub.
I hated the sub and regularly mentioned i did not care who the sub was during the season
Will it stay at 5 as we have seen changes to the sub rule before. I think it will.
Each club is in a different stage of development and will use the extra player differently.
I see debuting players and other players with just a few AFL games playing via the bench being a good move for a lot of clubs.
Maybe some will try to run two rucks without having that forward ruck position player.
Easing good players back with limited game time rather than via the VFL may be considered
Sheedy often said you can't have enough midfielders in your team. A lot of clubs may go that way. If not pure midfield likely a forward/wing/mid versatile player
Who the opposition is could also come into consideration
I don’t necessarily see that 5th player as being just the next best 23 player in line.
In my opinion the bench selection will change as the season progresses. Coaches will learn and adjust with each game
Our GF team below as a reference point as it's not a best 23 thread. Proven or new/injured best 23 AFL players to the side in brackets. For now, i did not include Coleman, Doedee or McCarthy as they have a lot to prove in the preseason. All used to be best 23 though. Also, a few Drafts to come but i included Annable
B: D.Zorko, D.Gardiner, R.Lester (Payne inj)
HB: D.Wilmot, H.Andrews (c), J Fletcher (Answerth inj)
C: S.Marshall, H.McCluggage, L.Ashcroft (Berry inj,)
HF: C.Cameron, L.Morris, T.Gallop, (Allen inj, Hipwood inj)
F: Z Bailey, C.Rayner, K Lohman (McKenna,)
FOLL: D.Fort, J.Dunkley, W.Ashcroft (Draper inj)
I/C: B. Reville, C Ah-Chee, B Starcevich, O.McInerney , L Neale (c) sub.
.............................................................................
The remaining players below. Looking at these players we are short on midfielders and small forwards
Defense: Coleman inj, Doedee, Brain, Beecken, Lloyd, Zakostelsky, Joyce
Midfield/Ruck: Smith, Tunstill, Annable, Torrent
Forward: McCarthy inj, McLachlan
EDIT 1 29/10/25 7 rule changes now approved for season 2026
Watch examples of the seven rule changes that will impact 2026
Ruck contests, the stand rule, and the 'last disposal' out of bounds rule are among a host of changes ahead of 2026
www.afl.com.au
GOALSQUARE STARTING POSITION
While the 6-6-6 rule will remain from centre ball-ups, there will no longer be a requirement for at least one player per team to start in the goalsquare. This will be a measure to help reduce dead time after goals.Last season, the AFL's findings discovered that the goalsquare was the last remaining facet of 6-6-6 to be organised at 10 per cent of all post-goal restarts. On average, that delayed the game by 8-10 seconds per instance. The League subsequently expects the total time saved through this rule change will be around 20-30 seconds per match.
LAST DISPOSAL
A free kick will now be awarded when the ball crosses the line from a disposal between the arcs, bringing the men's game in line with the AFLW's 'lasso' rule.It will operate similar to SANFL in the sense that if a player blocks an opponent or doesn't play the ball before it crosses the line, a normal boundary throw-in will occur instead of a last disposal free kick.
In the 2025 season, the AFL's findings discovered that there were 20 boundary throw-ins paid between the arcs and 0.5 insufficient intent free kicks paid between the arcs per game. The League then adapted those numbers for a scenario where the last disposal rule had been introduced. Its adapted numbers showed boundary throw-ins would be reduced by three per game, while 0.3 current insufficient intent free kicks would be negated by a last disposal free kick.
The adapted numbers also showed that there would have been an average of 3.25 last disposal free kicks per game paid across the 2025 season.
The query from club land has been whether a last disposal rule would kill the ruck. However, there still would have been 67 stoppages per game on average in 2025 based on the adapted numbers. That would have brought it back in line with the AFL's 2023 and 2024 averages.
CENTRE BALL-UP CONTESTS
At all centre ball-ups, competing rucks will now be unable to cross the centre line before engaging with their opposition ruck. This is born from a desire to see the jumping rucks return to the game.The AFL has said this rule would not have been possible without the end of the 'centre bounce', as opposed to the 'centre ball-up', due to the variables of which direction the ball can go from a bounce. The ball-up also gives the umpire extra time and ability to assess where the ruck is stationed when he engages his opponent.
The AFL's findings discovered that only 21 per cent of centre bounce ruck contests had at least one ruck jumping in the 2025 season. In 2023, just two years ago, that number was at 63 per cent.
There will still be an opportunity for the more physical wrestling rucks to impact the game at around-the-ground stoppages and boundary throw-ins.
ALIGN KICK-IN TIME
Umpires currently allow 'reasonable time' for a kick-in, which is deemed at around 12 seconds. However, 'reasonable time' for a mark or free kick paid around the ground is deemed at eight seconds. From 2026 onwards, both of these will align to be eight seconds.The AFL sampled more than 1200 kick-ins across the 2025 season, with a quarter of those lasting longer than 10 seconds and 13 per cent lasting longer than 12 seconds.
There was an average of 21 kick-ins taken per game across the 2025 season. If a quarter of those are reduced by four or five seconds, the League is conservatively hoping that around 21 seconds of match length is knocked off through kick-ins alone.
RUCK NOMINATIONS
Umpires can now restart play without a nominated ruck being present, bringing the men's game in line with AFLW rules. If there is no nomination, or the nominated ruck is too far away, the play will be restarted immediately.The 'third-man up' is still outlawed, so if no rucks nominate – or if the two nominated rucks are too far away when play is restarted – the ball will be thrown up and will have to hit the ground before 'play on' is called.
The AFL discovered that there were on average four ball-ups and six boundary throw-ins per game last season with a delay due to the umpire waiting for nominated rucks to arrive at a contest before restarting the play. It contributed to an average of three and a half seconds worth of delay on ball-ups and around one second worth of delay on boundary throw-ins.
One particular example from St Kilda's victory over Melbourne late in the year saw two rucks nominate for a boundary throw-in on the opposite wing, despite only just returning to the field of play from the bench. The umpire waited more than 25 seconds for the two rucks to arrive at the contest, before restarting the play.
SHRUGGING IN THE TACKLE
A shrug in a tackle will now be deemed prior opportunity. It will be similar to how a fend, or an attempt to evade a tackle is deemed prior opportunity.It's hoped this will stop players from contributing to a high tackle, while making the rule easier to adjudicate for umpires.
STAND
There will be a stronger enforcement of players being told to 'stand' if they are inside the protected area.Now, if you are within 5m of a mark or a free kick when it is paid, deemed the protected area, you will be required to 'stand' and can no longer reverse to being 'outside five'.
The AFL found that more and more players have left the protected area to stand 'outside five' across the last season. In 2025 alone, the AFL's findings discovered that only 58 per cent of opposition players would 'stand' when told while 18 per cent of players went to the area deemed 'outside five' by the umpire.
It's hoped this will see more players take the game on, encourage overlapping possessions and more free-flowing ball movement.
Last edited:
