Adam Treloar vs Dylan Shiel

[jakefooty23]

Switch the clubs the two play for and Treloar would 100% win.

No he wouldn't, stop acting like treloar is Chris Judd ffs

 

[adammania9]

No he wouldn't, stop acting like treloar is Chris Judd ffs

Are you trying to compare Dylan Shiel with Chris Judd?

 

[adammania9]

Shiel will poll high at this years Brownlow night.

Shiel will get more because he's a better player.

Ahem. Sorry, my throat is a bit dry.

 

[jakefooty23]

Are you trying to compare Dylan Shiel with Chris Judd?

Nope, but if I was, Shiel would be a lot closer to judd then Treloar.

 

[MightyDons4]

Ahem. Sorry, my throat is a bit dry.

118-32

Hence, why Shiel gets more votes is due to him being a better player than Treloar.

 

[Frank Gallagher]

Nope, but if I was, Shiel would be a lot closer to judd then Treloar.

Is shiel a ball butcher too? Shiela.

 

[Frank Gallagher]

118-32

Hence, why Shiel gets more votes is due to him being a better player than Treloar.

He was talking about Brownlow votes, pretty sure that's another area Treloar beat Shiel in, in case you didn't know, Collingwood players rarely win BF polls, we had recruited Shiel instead the Poll would be the exact opposite.

 

[jakefooty23]

Is shiel a ball butcher too? Shiela.

Nope. I find it hilarious how upset you are about the fact that 80% of voters voted Shiel and only 20% voted treloar, but no matter how uneven the poll is Treloar will always be better in the eyes of a Bias Collingwood Supporter.

 

[MightyDons4]

He was talking about Brownlow votes, pretty sure that's another area Treloar beat Shiel in, in case you didn't know, Collingwood players rarely win BF polls, we had recruited Shiel instead the Poll would be the exact opposite.

Nope, it would still be in Shiel's favour because he's better than Treloar.

 

[Frank Gallagher]

Nope. I find it hilarious how upset you are about the fact that 80% of voters voted Shiel and only 20% voted treloar, but no matter how uneven the poll is Treloar will always be better in the eyes of a Bias Collingwood Supporter.

Stats suggest Treloar is the better player, when they both played in the same team Treloar was the better player, he had to join Collingwood to become inferiour (even though again, the stats favour him).

And i'm upset am i? Ok mate.

 

[Frank Gallagher]

Nope, it would still be in Shiel's favour because he's better than Treloar.

either way, both would be your best player.

 

[MightyDons4]

either way, both would be your best player.

Wrong again.

 

[Frank Gallagher]

Wrong again.

Lol, i don't think so, who is your best player anyway? Heppel? If so, lol.

 

[adammania9]

Nope, it would still be in Shiel's favour because he's better than Treloar.

In your opinion.

 

[jakefooty23]

Stats suggest Treloar is the better player, when they both played in the same team Treloar was the better player, he had to join Collingwood to become inferiour (even though again, the stats favour him).

And i'm upset am i? Ok mate.

Stats don't make someone the better player. The quicker you realise that the quicker you will realise that Shiel is better then treloar. And yes you are upset

 

[jakefooty23]

Lol, i don't think so, who is your best player anyway? Heppel? If so, lol.

Heppell is an all Australian. Don't compare Treloar with him until he's donned the AA jacket.

 

[MightyDons4]

Lol, i don't think so, who is your best player anyway? Heppel? If so, lol.

One of multiple who have been AA. The mains answers I was looking for were Hooker and Hurley.

In your opinion.

Which seems to align with the dominant consensus, bar a few angry Collingwood fans.

 

[Frank Gallagher]

Heppell is an all Australian. Don't compare Treloar with him until he's donned the AA jacket.

Stats, like awards, shouldn't be used to judge a player, and wasn't Heppel jacked up in drugs at the time?

And TBH, it's you who sounds "upset"

 

[Frank Gallagher]

One of multiple who have been AA. The mains answers I was looking for were Hooker and Hurley.

Which seems to align with the dominant consensus, bar a few angry Collingwood fans.

Drug cheats should have their AA taken away.

 

[Donakebab]

Stats, like awards, shouldn't be used to judge a player, and wasn't Heppel jacked up in drugs at the time?

And TBH, it's you who sounds "upset"

Nope. Only blokes jacked up around that time where in the black and white.

 

[jakefooty23]

Stats, like awards, shouldn't be used to judge a player, and wasn't Heppel jacked up in drugs at the time?

And TBH, it's you who sounds "upset"

Maybe he was, maybe he wasn't, either way he still had a better year that year then treloar did this year. Speaking of drugs, Dane swan would be having an absolute Ben cousins of an offseason, wouldn't he?

 

[jakefooty23]

Drug cheats should have their AA taken away.

Can't wait to see this not happen

 

[SuperSteele22]

Nope. Only blokes jacked up around that time where in the black and white.

Would explain why we've won 9 of the past 11 ANZAC Day games.

 

[Frank Gallagher]

Maybe he was, maybe he wasn't, either way he still had a better year that year then treloar did this year. Speaking of drugs, Dane swan would be having an absolute Ben cousins of an offseason, wouldn't he?

Wow you are taking this to heart aren't you, think i might just back away and leave you alone now, you seem unhinged.

 

[jakefooty23]

Wow you are taking this to heart aren't you, think i might just back away and leave you alone now, you seem unhinged.

I'm not taking anything to heart, neither of the players we've spoken about play for my team. I just don't like seeing a bias Collingwood supporter being an annoying peens on a forum.