2nds AFC 2022 SANFL Thread

[Mutineer]

Strachan 57 HO's to Cleeland's 11 tells us what....Strachan was good but Cleeland was worse than awful..

 

[morris086]

Strachan 57 HO's to Cleeland's 11 tells us what....Strachan was good but Cleeland was worse than awful..

Rob will probably have the same tomorrow, Strachan should be playing the Blues

 

[LeftyLuke]

Borlase had an absolute shocker.

Too slow. We definitely need to trade in a decent KPD. Murray. Borlase, Frampton don't fill me with a lot of confidence.

 

[Jeffcrowe]

Kobe Ryan will almost certainly go 1st round it will be just how high...

28 disposals in the reserves last week and 21 disposals and 2 goals on League debut is pretty bloody impressive..

Going at 96% disposal efficiency against an Adelaide team chockful of AFL listed player...and let's not forget it's been with a greasy ball most of the day.

Yep fair call , he was really good today and that’s first time I’ve seen him

 

[Jeffcrowe]

Fog had a better last quarter admittedly

Would like to see him start like that and string 4 QTRs together each week

 

[Crow-eater]

Soligo our best. First game he’s really had on ball and really shone.
Crouch was Crouch. He’s too good for this level.
Strachan bullied his opponent. Wasn’t really a fair match up.
Parnell had his moments. Nank had some moments. Worrell pretty solid down back. Fog/McAsey presented well. Not really a day for key forwards.

The top ups were pretty good. The opponent was very bad . Second quarter won us the game, then it was pretty much cruise control to the final siren.

 

[Magma]

Strachan 57 HO's to Cleeland's 11 tells us what....Strachan was good but Cleeland was worse than awful..

Cleeland isn't a ruck and would only be a backup if we had anyone else who wasn't complete crap

 

[Velvet George]

I didn’t see the game except for last 5 mins. Was Worrell up forward?

And commentators talking about best on and comparing Soligo and Crouch, both agreed Soligo did more with it. Says it all really.

 

[Mr MysteryGuest]

Strachan 57 HO's to Cleeland's 11 tells us what....Strachan was good but Cleeland was worse than awful..

That’s probably but not necessarily. They’re in direct competition, so if Strachan’s numbers are high, it stands to reason that Cleeland’s would be low.

 

[Mutineer]

I didn’t see the game except for last 5 mins. Was Worrell up forward?

And commentators talking about best on and comparing Soligo and Crouch, both agreed Soligo did more with it. Says it all really.

no played half back but got on his bike to kick a cuppla snags

 

[pjcrows]

Crouch with 12 kicks 24 handballs.

I'd be disappointed if his instruction was "go back in to the twos and get heaps and heaps of handballs".

 

[Mutineer]

That’s probably but not necessarily. They’re in direct competition, so if Strachan’s numbers are high, it stands to reason that Cleeland’s would be low.

Fair go did you watch the game....Cleeland isn't even a SANFL standard ruck..

 

[Crow-eater]

I didn’t see the game except for last 5 mins. Was Worrell up forward?

And commentators talking about best on and comparing Soligo and Crouch, both agreed Soligo did more with it. Says it all really.

Worrell played back. Snuck forward and launched one from 50 after a handball from a Soligo mark. I missed the first goal.

Soligo was definitely more impactful.

 

[Mutineer]

Crouch with 12 kicks 24 handballs.

Yep played at the coalface for a change and fed the ball out to the runners effectively, pretty similar to Soligo's game too

 

[BRL121]

I didn’t see the game except for last 5 mins. Was Worrell up forward?

And commentators talking about best on and comparing Soligo and Crouch, both agreed Soligo did more with it. Says it all really.

Crouch was pretty ineffective. He gets the ball a lot, but is too slow of mind to dispose of it properly. He often chooses to hold the ball out in traffic, and then pull it back in and go HTB. A lot of his SANFL teammates are yet to learn and choose to handball it to him!

On the positive side, he did contribute well to a few fast handball-chain incursions by us. This is only possible when he is not in too much traffic, and only occurred because our SANFL side likes fast attacking chains much more than our AFL side.

 

[LeftyLuke]

Crouch with 12 kicks 24 handballs.

I'd be disappointed if his instruction was "go back in to the twos and get heaps and heaps of handballs".

As soon as he has to run with the ball he is stuffed. Scott Thompson mark 2 final year.

 

[morris086]

Yep played at the coalface for a change and fed the ball out to the runners effectively, pretty similar to Soligo's game too

For a change? When is Crouch not played there?

 

[Geoffa32]

For a change? When is Crouch not played there?

Laird doing that the past two years.

Crouch doesn't have a role in our AFL team with Laird in the middle.

It really is one or the other.

On SM-A325F using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Mutineer]

For a change? When is Crouch not played there?

He hasn't been our first receiver for ages...

 

[morris086]

He hasn't been our first receiver for ages...

Maybe Im misunderstanding "coalface", what is his role considering his high centre bounce attendance?

 

[beartoo]

Maybe Im misunderstanding "coalface", what is his role considering his high centre bounce attendance?

Coalface=inside mid?

On SM-A115F using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[morris086]

Coalface=inside mid?

On SM-A115F using BigFooty.com mobile app

That was my understanding

 

[Mr MysteryGuest]

Fair go did you watch the game....Cleeland isn't even a SANFL standard ruck..

Not at all and never said I did. But you claim about what the stat sheet tells us, and it doesn’t tell us much other than Strachan dominated.

I know you don’t want him the AFL but ROB has been awful lately, strachan couldn’t do any worse.

 

[crows dude]

I didn’t see the game except for last 5 mins. Was Worrell up forward?

And commentators talking about best on and comparing Soligo and Crouch, both agreed Soligo did more with it. Says it all really.

No he was back. Ran down to kick a couple

 

[Mutineer]

Not at all and never said I did. But you claim about what the stat sheet tells us, and it doesn’t tell us much other than Strachan dominated.

I know you don’t want him the AFL but ROB has been awful lately, strachan couldn’t do any worse.

You must have missed where I said was quite happy to see Strachan get another shot at AFL, just don't go expecting him to be the messiah like some on here seem to think off of beating up on mostly suburban level rucks in the SANFL.