AFL Dream Team 2008: Part 2

[maculosus]

A, B, C or D?

A: Hurn to Ibbo, N Jones to K Cornes
B: Hurn to Ibbo, Hill to Buddy
C: N Jones to Armi, Hill to Buddy
D: N Jones to Armi, Hurn to Goddard

A. Ibbo up for 3rd game and Kornes is due.

Good to give Hill one more chance to see if he can get back to big scores

 

[Deenamite]

Who to start out of Houli and Palmer? Other mids are Ablett, Kerr, Stevens and Griffen.

 

[Delroy]

Anyone else on that "for those who take it way too seriously site"?

Well that has J.Browns BE at 98, but fanfooty has it at 89. Anyone know which is the right one?

 

[Bollox]

NG Brown

 

[banana_bus]

NG Brown

 

[SAINTS 4 07 FLAG]

A. Ibbo up for 3rd game and Kornes is due.

Good to give Hill one more chance to see if he can get back to big scores

Wtf how can you say Kornes is due..he scored 119 last week

 

[Chrisrocks53]

ok folks heres my quandry

I still have the dud Nicoski

and I still have Stuey Dew on my Bench

should i trade Stuey down to someone like Valenti then upgrade Nicoski to Sam Fisher or Goddard?

I have 130k in the bank

The other options are trading down BJ or Trading down Bird

 

[banana_bus]

ok folks heres my quandry

I still have the dud Nicoski

and I still have Stuey Dew on my Bench

should i trade Stuey down to someone like Valenti then upgrade Nicoski to Sam Fisher or Goddard?

I have 130k in the bank

The other options are trading down BJ or Trading down Bird

Wouldnt be getting on Valenti just yet.

 

[TFLUA-Tiger]

Why trade him to Valenti - when Valenti isn't playing?

Go Ibbotson instead and upgrade Nicoski to Jake King or osmeone of his ilk.

 

[big_slick]

ok folks heres my quandry

I still have the dud Nicoski

and I still have Stuey Dew on my Bench

should i trade Stuey down to someone like Valenti then upgrade Nicoski to Sam Fisher or Goddard?

I have 130k in the bank

The other options are trading down BJ or Trading down Bird

Dew shouldn't be too long off coming back, if you have stuck with him this long keep going i say. Goddard should hold his price for another week at least so you won't miss the boat with that one. Less premium options would be to go to Kennely or wait another week and go to gilbee. Bit up and down but in comparison to Nicoski it's a win win plus you don't need to downgrade.

Who would you play out of hill and gamble this week. I think i will keep Hill for one more week. Geelong vs Freo means Gamble should get some good numbers.

 

[Rise_up_Stiffy]

I'm thinking of Trading Griffen to Scotland (will leave me with 5k in the bank). What are people's opinions on this trade? I think Griffen might start to taper off soon (already started last week with his 45), and Scotland is damn cheap. Help me please!!

*also posted in rd 6 trades thread*

 

[treefingers]

Dew should be right for next week thats the word from the hawks camp.

 

[Chrisrocks53]

Why trade him to Valenti - when Valenti isn't playing?

Go Ibbotson instead and upgrade Nicoski to Jake King or osmeone of his ilk.

I thought Valenti would be the automatic replacement for Neitz... but as Ive just read he isnt, so thats what I was basing my theory on

I think this maybe a good suggestion, i may just have to go with

However, i'd rather get one of the falling guns so i can have some spare change when i do my next down grade

but thanks alot

 

[adam10]

Starting Ibbotson over Barlow

And

Dyson over Palmer

 

[KnockOut]

ok folks heres my quandry

I still have the dud Nicoski

and I still have Stuey Dew on my Bench

should i trade Stuey down to someone like Valenti then upgrade Nicoski to Sam Fisher or Goddard?

I have 130k in the bank

The other options are trading down BJ or Trading down Bird

If you can wiat a few more weeks on Nicowski>Goddard it'd be ideal. Nicowski won't move in price and Goddard will be going down give it two weeks.

Dew is going to rise big time and it would be silly to waste a trade without reaping the benefits of your original selection. Valenti hasn't played a game yet so reap the rewards and make an educated guess on the downgrade in 3-4 weeks.

On Brad Johnson, bar serious injury you never-ever should trade a way a proven dream team gun, they don't grow on trees.

 

[adam10]

Over next few eeks will need to upgrade and downgrade:

E.Barlow (uprgarde)
Dyson(upgrade)
Stevens(upgrade)
Bird(Downgrade)
Sylvia(upgrade)
Rioli(downgrade)

Happy to keep
Gamble'
Mckliney
Ibbotson
Palmer

 

[Houli2Gumbleton]

Over next few eeks will need to upgrade and downgrade:

E.Barlow (uprgarde)
Dyson(upgrade)
Stevens(upgrade)
Bird(Downgrade)
Sylvia(upgrade)
Rioli(downgrade)

Happy to keep
Gamble'
Mckliney
Ibbotson
Palmer

y upgrade stevens? He is doing pretty good. I will wait another 6 rounds maybe.

 

[adam10]

y upgrade stevens? He is doing pretty good. I will wait another 6 rounds maybe.

In 2-3 weeks i reckon he will peak at about 340-350,000

 

[Houli2Gumbleton]

In 2-3 weeks i reckon he will peak at about 340-350,000

whats his price now? cbf checking

 

[Chrisrocks53]

A little bit late, but here is my team as it stands

Thanks for the suggestions guys

 

[adam10]

A little bit late, but here is my team as it stands

Thanks for the suggestions guys

In trouble.Get rid of Bowden for a B.Goddard/G.Birhcall. Get the cash and uprgrade Goodes/Griffen or Cloke
Take your pick.

 

[Hard Ball Get]

In trouble.Get rid of Bowden for a B.Goddard/G.Birhcall. Get the cash and uprgrade Goodes/Griffen or Cloke
Take your pick.

Ignore this advice.
Nicoski is a more pressing issue.
Starting Tippett is also far more worrying.

 

[adam10]

Ignore this advice.
Nicoski is a more pressing issue.
Starting Tippett is also far more worrying.

Yer sorry mate. Get rid of Nicokski first didnt see him Fix him up and i think you need to get the extra gun midfielder

 

[54Dogs]

I'm thinking of Trading Griffen to Scotland (will leave me with 5k in the bank). What are people's opinions on this trade? I think Griffen might start to taper off soon (already started last week with his 45), and Scotland is damn cheap. Help me please!!

*also posted in rd 6 trades thread*

Some commentary in the No Passengers link this week, which is now on the main board, about which midfield gun is best to trade in this week. Might be worth looking over before you decide. Also a player summary link to Scotland in the last post by Kildonan.

Personally I think Scotland is a fantastic choice in the price range but have a quick look at the player summary before deciding.

 

[Masss#10]

Might be with another Zero if Hansen doesnt get selected for kangas...All because of Bowden..is it wise to still hold onto him?? it seems everyone has traded him out..