Alan Didak or Mark Mcveigh

[Paddywhackers]

Whow would you prefer in your team? Someone had Mcveigh in there top 50 which had me thinking, he must be better than I thought? Is this true? Is he better than Didak? This guy was an Essendon supporter though.

 

[Merv]

As much as i am a huge wrap for McVeigh, it would be Didak for me.

No Poll?

 

[smiddaz123]

Didak easily.

He has just come back from a knee re-co. Nowhere near his best, and still dominates.

 

[G.O.B]

A fairer comparison for McVeigh would be against Rhys Shaw.

To put him up against Didak is just plain mean.

I did see that list and he did manage to squeeze 1 Collingwood player in at around 40 (Swan) so he wasn't totally biased against Collingwood.

 

[Ron]

A fairer comparison for McVeigh would be against Rhys Shaw.

More like Toovey.
McVeigh tries hard but shines in a midfield which wouldn't be VFL standard.
Wouldn't get a game at most other clubs.

 

[smiddaz123]

Don't under rate McVeigh. He's quality.

But Didak is better.

 

[Paddywhackers]

I just worked out how to create one. It's up now guys, enjoy!

 

[davey_magik]

Didak's a better player but I hate him so McVeigh.
Hate McVeigh too but Didak is scum.

 

[DapperDon]

More like Toovey.
McVeigh tries hard but shines in a midfield which wouldn't be VFL standard.
Wouldn't get a game at most other clubs.

name a club and i'll show you at least 10 players McVeigh would replace you muppet.

 

[croady_fan24]

Didak.

 

[DeesManiac]

Didak.

 

[marcmurphy3]

name a club and i'll show you at least 10 players McVeigh would replace you muppet.

McVeigh would make every side.

 

[MinerBoy]

McVeigh is a handy player, but Didak is CLEARLY better.

 

[Zachy45]

i wouldn't want Didak near Carlton. so McVeigh.

 

[samthemanlonergan]

http://www.footywire.com/afl/footy/ft_player_compare?tid1=6&pid1=356&tid2=5&pid2=166

Both good players

McVeigh kicks a lot of goals for a midfielder. He took a step up this year, and will take another one next year.

 

[tristo]

Different types of players.

Didak is a forward who can go into the midfield, and his "6th sense" of knowing where the goals are is brilliant!

McVeigh is more midfield orientated who can go forward and kick goals, can also play a shut down role on opposition players.

So really it comes down to what is needed in the team, both players would be in the best 22 of any of the 16 clubs.

 

[Cynic]

Didak > McVeigh
McVeigh > Average AFL Player

 

[smiddaz123]

Different types of players.

Didak is a forward who can go into the midfield, and his "6th sense" of knowing where the goals are is brilliant!

McVeigh is more midfield orientated who can go forward and kick goals, can also play a shut down role on opposition players.

So really it comes down to what is needed in the team, both players would be in the best 22 of any of the 16 clubs.

What's your point? The poll says 'Who would you prefer in your team?'. Does it really matter if they play a different style?

 

[goal sneak]

name a club and i'll show you at least 10 players McVeigh would replace you muppet.

Geelongs GF side

 

[Merv]

name a club and i'll show you at least 10 players McVeigh would replace you muppet.

Geelongs GF side

Backs: Harley Scarlett Hunt
Half-backs: Mackie Milburn Wojcinski
Centres: Corey Bartel Enright
Half-forwards: S Johnson Mooney Selwood
Forwards: Chapman N Ablett Stokes
Followers: Ottens Ling G Ablett
Interchange: King Byrnes Kelly Rooke
Emergencies: Varcoe Blake Prismall
In: King
Out: Blake

Probably only 6 in that team, could have been 8 but i was conservative

 

[DeesManiac]

Backs: Harley Scarlett Hunt
Half-backs: Mackie Milburn Wojcinski
Centres: Corey Bartel Enright
Half-forwards: S Johnson Mooney Selwood
Forwards: Chapman N Ablett Stokes
Followers: Ottens Ling G Ablett
Interchange: King Byrnes Kelly Rooke
Emergencies: Varcoe Blake Prismall
In: King
Out: Blake

Probably only 6 in that team, could have been 8 but i was conservative

Selwood No, Hunt No, the rest are just a maybe. Mcveigh would struggle to get a game with geelong.

 

[Merv]

Selwood No, Hunt No, the rest are just a maybe. Mcveigh would struggle to get a game with geelong.

lol, get a clue mate

 

[DeesManiac]

lol, get a clue mate

can you give me one?

 

[Merv]

can you give me one?

Hopefully when you grow up you will have one

 

[DeesManiac]

Good on ya mod