All Australian thread 2015

[Farang83150]

Goldy get any votes the last time they met?

If you want to be the best you have to beat the best...

Goldy's not 1 dimensional like Sandy though so will always get the nod by those with nous.

 

[TennisPlayerAndy]

i trust the coaches view over a melbourne newspaper. fair dinkum

Goldstein: 73

Sandilands: Not close.

Sandi had 2 kicks in the match yesterday. Both in the first quarter from marks. Both were goals.

His around the ground work is average.

Did you happen to see him languishing in the background when Todd kicked his first after he had been run into the ground?

 

[BusinessMan]

Goldstein: 73

Sandilands: Not close.

Sandi had 2 kicks in the match yesterday. Both in the first quarter from marks. Both were goals.

His around the ground work is average.

Did you happen to see him languishing in the background when Todd kicked his first after he had been run into the ground?

Did you happen to see Sandi collecting 14 contested possessions and 6 clearances to Todd's 6 and 3? Another comprehensive victory for Sandi over Goldstein.

 

[The Joker]

Goldy's not 1 dimensional like Sandy though so will always get the nod by those with nous.

Because you were in first does that make you the one with nous? Thats so sweet...

Sandi man handled him H2H on the weekend.

Nice stats though

 

[Dan]

Goldstein: 73

Sandilands: Not close.

Sandi had 2 kicks in the match yesterday. Both in the first quarter from marks. Both were goals.

His around the ground work is average.

Did you happen to see him languishing in the background when Todd kicked his first after he had been run into the ground?

There it is boys and girls.

 

[A Swallow]

Sandilands is a better tap ruckman. Goldstein does far more around the ground.
NN is a freak who at times can do anything at all.
Freo fans are rightfully happy with Sandilands.
North fans are rightfully happy with Goldstein.
WC fans are rightfully happy with NN.

 

[Jootube]

Sandilands is a better tap ruckman. Goldstein does far more around the ground.
NN is a freak who at times can do anything at all.
Freo fans are rightfully happy with Sandilands.
North fans are rightfully happy with Goldstein.
WC fans are rightfully happy with NN.

 

[wraglesweb]

sandilands should be all australian. not beaten this year. beat Goldstein twice. fact. Beat Nic nat and Jacobs. fact. To Goldstein's credit he did say Sandi is the toughest tap ruckmen to go against by far. his words. both should get in but Sandi has been totally ignored by the media, especially the victorian media which is on a Goldstein love fest. this has been one of Sandi's most consistent years ever. pretty impressive considering his age. i guess Sandi being the reigning all australian for multiple years is taken for granted

Ahhh he might of one the tap outs slightly but Nic Nat kicked 2 goals and was much better around the ground

 

[TheMcManusNose]

Sandilands is a better tap ruckman. Goldstein does far more around the ground.
NN is a freak who at times can do anything at all.
Freo fans are rightfully happy with Sandilands.
North fans are rightfully happy with Goldstein.
WC fans are rightfully happy with NN.

Get the **** away from BigFooty, what is this shit.

 

[The Joker]

Sandilands is a better tap ruckman. Goldstein does far more around the ground.
NN is a freak who at times can do anything at all.
Freo fans are rightfully happy with Sandilands.
North fans are rightfully happy with Goldstein.
WC fans are rightfully happy with NN.

Goldstein does far more around the ground against weaker ruckmen yes.

You all can call Sandilands "The Truth". You want to find out how good you really are, just go see The Truth.

 

[Forward Press]

Goldstein does far more around the ground against weaker ruckmen yes.

You all can call Sandilands "The Truth". You want to find out how good you really are, just go see The Truth.

An opposition poster makes a pretty sensible and conciliatory post and you go on the attack anyway.

You probably should stick to actually discussing the All Australian team, by the way, which this thread is about.

 

[The Joker]

An opposition poster makes a pretty sensible and conciliatory post and you go on the attack anyway.

You probably should stick to actually discussing the All Australian team, by the way, which this thread is about.

Oh here we go, didnt want to send a PM but just call me out right here?

Its a discussion about 2 of the three ruckmen in line for an AA spot. Was i wrong in what i said or is this about hurting peoples feelings?

 

[Hardhat11]

Players that should, make it from my mob ..and I do t watch enough of other teams to really comment bar freo

Kennedy
Priddis
Gaff
Lecras

Chances ....Nic Nat and Sheppard

 

[wal]

Players that should, make it from my mob ..and I do t watch enough of other teams to really comment bar freo

Kennedy
Priddis
Gaff
Lecras

Chances ....Nic Nat and Sheppard

You cannot be serious?

 

[Dr Awkward]

Rance and Martin are the only two Richmond players likely to make it for mine. Deledio missing those games hurts. Cotchin role has been done better (not by a lot) by other mids in his position.

I think Riewoldt should still be in the calculations, considering he had a great first two thirds of a season, and there aren't many others putting their hand up. I still reckon he's been better than Walker than Cameron, although now maybe Stringer could be CHF.

 

[Hardhat11]

You cannot be serious?

He's played a lot of midfield/high half forward

What's his stats ......

 

[indy nile]

Goldy get any votes the last time they met?

If you want to be the best you have to beat the best...

You can't possibly expect Goldy to out-ruck himself, can you?

 

[the dog's kennel]

He's played a lot of midfield/high half forward

What's his stats ......

Ahhhh..... yeah, no.

http://www.footywire.com/afl/footy/...1=1519&tid2=14&pid2=3644&type=A&fid1=S&fid2=S

 

[richoatthedisco]

B - Shaw Hurley McGovern
HB - Wood Rance Murphy
C - Hannebery Priddis Dangerfield
HF - Martin Walker (v/c) Wingard
F - Betts Kennedy J.Riewoldt
R - Goldstein Fyfe Gray
I - Mitchell Rioli Neale Cotchin (c)

 

[Scotland]

You cannot be serious?

LeCras was in AA contention, but given the competition for HF/mid spots he's no chance.

Having a very good season, but not Robbie Gray/Dustin Martin good.

 

[kangaspurs]

sandilands should be all australian. not beaten this year. beat Goldstein twice. fact. Beat Nic nat and Jacobs. fact. To Goldstein's credit he did say Sandi is the toughest tap ruckmen to go against by far. his words. both should get in but Sandi has been totally ignored by the media, especially the victorian media which is on a Goldstein love fest. this has been one of Sandi's most consistent years ever. pretty impressive considering his age. i guess Sandi being the reigning all australian for multiple years is taken for granted

Lucky we beat Freo and West Coast then; by your logic it means we're the best team in the competition.

 

[Happy Mastenator]

Maybe add - "IMO"

Goldy's last quarter was huge. Blew Sandi up and was involved in most of our goals and kicked 2 himself.

IMO - I would prefer the match winning ruckmen to the hitout winning ruckmen. 4 points is worth more than more taps.

If freo had anything half resembling a key forward they beat you with sandi's ruck work being the decisive factor. He destroyed Goldy head to head in the ruck contest

 

[scarecrow2k1]

B - Shaw Hurley McGovern
HB - Wood Rance Murphy
C - Hannebery Priddis Dangerfield
HF - Martin Walker (v/c) Wingard
F - Betts Kennedy J.Riewoldt
R - Goldstein Fyfe Gray
I - Mitchell Rioli Neale Cotchin (c)

Not the sure AA captain has been on the bench before!

 

[richoatthedisco]

Not the sure AA captain has been on the bench before!

Our last premiership captain was!

 

[scarecrow2k1]

Our last premiership captain was!

Say no more!