Atley Vs Conca

[Psicosis]

And yet all the quantifiable evidence points to the fact that he's a tougher player than both Atley and Conca, with more CP per game and more tackles per game than both. Keep on trying champ, I'm sure you'll get there eventually.

Glenn Archer, possibly the toughest player of our generation did not always have outstanding stats in CP and tackles... does that mean he isnt tough? You have no backbone in this discussion, you rely on your precious statistics which really have little relevance. The fact is Heppell plays like an outside running downhill skiing fairy, when it comes to on-field physicality, he is not in the same league at Atley.

 

[eth-dog]

Glenn Archer, possibly the toughest player of our generation did not always have outstanding stats in CP and tackles... does that mean he isnt tough? You have no backbone in this discussion, you rely on your precious statistics which really have little relevance. The fact is Heppell plays like an outside running downhill skiing fairy, when it comes to on-field physicality, he is not in the same league at Atley.

Stats are the only quantifiable pieces of evidence in our game. The fact that you dismiss them in saying that they have little relevance just shows me you can't back up your argument with any solid, set in stone facts. Thanks for showing me this, I won't make the mistake of ever trying to argue with you again as it'll just be the same shit, different topic. I'll give Conca a little credit- he averages more clearances than Heppell, but Atley doesn't, even with 5% more TOG average than Heppell and 15% more than Conca

 

[ArjenTheGreat]

On toughness I'd have Conca ahead of Atley and Heppel.

Atley and Heppell are soft but I have a feeling that is how they are being coached more than them being died in the wool cowards/frauds like Deledio/Houli/Wells.

Heppell has clearly been the best performed thus far but on pure impact Atley has Conca covered by plenty.

Is Liam Anthony really just as good as Brett Deledio?

No, of course not, they are both impostors but using statistical analysis it's 18.6 effective disposals v 19.6.

 

[Donakebab]

Came into an Atley vs Conca poll to find a discussion about how soft Heppell is.
Jesus Christ. Ban all North, Richmond and Essendon supporters from the ******* polls board.

Yep this thread became a piece of shit real quick, never would of picked that... Agreed, the usual suspects in this horrid love triangle should cop long term or perma bans.

 

[Chism]

Thread is done.