Bastyy's 2015 Phantom Draft

[Bastyy]

Hey guys! I'm new around here, and its not even been 3 months since i joined BigFooty, but every year i make personal Phantom Drafts.
If you want reasons on why i think clubs will pick who they pick, just ask me and i'll answer
Anyway, too much talk, not enough draft

Pick 1- Carlton- Jacob Weitering
Pick 2- Brisbane- Josh Schache
Pick 3- Sydney- Callum Mills (Academy Selection, bid on by Melbourne, matched)
Pick 4- Melbourne- Clayton Oliver
Pick 5- GWS- Jacob Hopper (Academy Selection, bid on by Essendon, matched)
Pick 6- Essendon- Sam Weideman
Pick 7- Essendon- Darcy Parish
Pick 8- GWS- Matthew Kennedy (Academy Selection, bid on by Gold Coast, matched)
Pick 9- Gold Coast- Callum Ah Chee
Pick 10- Melbourne- Aaron Francis
Pick 11- Carlton- Harry McKay
Pick 12- Adelaide- Wayne Milera
Pick 13- Carlton- Charlie Curnow
Pick 14- Brisbane- Ben Keays (Academy Selection, bid on by Richmond, matched)
Pick 15- Richmond- Jade Gresham
Pick 16- Adelaide- Harley Balic
Pick 17- St. Kilda- Darcy Tucker
Pick 18- Hawthorn- Kieran Collins
Pick 19- Gold Coast- David Cunningham
Pick 20- North Melbourne- Luke Partington
Pick 21- Hawthorn- Mitchell Hibberd
Pick 22- Carlton- Ryan Burton
Pick 23- Brisbane- Eric Hipwood (Academy Selection, bid on by Western Bulldogs, matched)
Pick 24- Western Bulldogs- Josh Dunkley (Father/Son, bid on by Bulldogs, chose not to match)
Pick 25- Western Bulldogs- Ben McKay
Pick 26- GWS- Harrison Himmelberg (Academy Selection, bid on by Fremantle, matched)
Pick 27- Fremantle- Riley Bonner
Pick 28- West Coast- Daniel Rioli
Pick 29- Essendon- Tom Cole
Pick 30- Essendon- Brandon White
Pick 31- North Melbourne- Kieran Lovell
Pick 32- Collingwood- Brayden Fiorini
Pick 33- North Melbourne- Aidyn Johnson
Pick 34- Gold Coast- Declan Mountford
Pick 35- Western Bulldogs- Nathan Broad
Pick 36- West Coast- Ben Crocker
Pick 37- Port Adelaide- Nick O'Kearney
Pick 38- Fremantle- Jesse Glass-McCasker
Pick 39- Brisbane- Corey Wagner
Pick 40- Sydney- Alex Morgan
Pick 41- St. Kilda- Bailey Rice (Father/Son)
Pick 42- Melbourne- Blake Hardwick
Pick 43- North Melbourne- Kurt Mutimer
Pick 44- Hawthorn- Will Snelling
Pick 45- Port Adelaide- Mason Redman
Pick 46- Melbourne- Nash Holmes
Pick 47- Western Bulldogs- Dylan Smith
Pick 48- Richmond- Thomas Glen
Pick 49- Essendon- Mitch Brown
Pick 50- Carlton- Jack Silvagni (Father/Son)
Pick 51- Carlton- James Parsons
Pick 52- Fremantle- Callum Moore
Pick 53- Sydney- Sam Murray
Pick 54- West Coast- Greg Clark
Pick 55- GWS- Matthew Flynn
Pick 56- Collingwood- Yestin Eades
Pick 57- Geelong- Sam Skinner
Pick 58- Sydney- Tom Phillips
Pick 59- GWS- Lachlan Tizani
Pick 60- North Melbourne- Pass
Pick 61- Fremantle- Joshua Schoenfield

 

[VanDemonxx]

Pretty good, but Curnow doesn't slip to 25

 

[ExRoyboy]

Hey guys! I'm new around here, and its not even been 3 months since i joined BigFooty, but every year i make personal Phantom Drafts.
If you want reasons on why i think clubs will pick who they pick, just ask me and i'll answer
Anyway, too much talk, not enough draft

Pick 1- Carlton- Jacob Weitering
Pick 2- Brisbane- Josh Schache
Pick 3- Sydney- Callum Mills (Academy Selection, bid on by Melbourne, matched)
Pick 4- Melbourne- Darcy Parish
Pick 5- GWS- Jacob Hopper (Academy Selection, bid on by Essendon, matched)
Pick 6- Essendon- Sam Weideman
Pick 7- Essendon- Wayne Milera
Pick 8- GWS- Matthew Kennedy (Academy Selection, bid on by Gold Coast, matched)
Pick 9- Gold Coast- Aaron Francis
Pick 10- Melbourne- Clayton Oliver
Pick 11- Carlton- Harry McKay
Pick 12- Adelaide- Harley Balic
Pick 13- Carlton- Rhys Mathieson
Pick 14- Brisbane- Ben Keays (Academy Selection, bid on by Richmond, matched)
Pick 15- Richmond- Callum ah Chee
Pick 16- Adelaide- Ryan Burton
Pick 17- St. Kilda- Darcy Tucker
Pick 18- Hawthorn- Kieran Collins
Pick 19- Gold Coast- Ryan Clarke
Pick 20- North Melbourne- Luke Partington
Pick 21- Hawthorn- Mitchell Hibberd
Pick 22- Carlton- Jade Gresham
Pick 23- Brisbane- Eric Hipwood (Academy Selection, bid on by Western Bulldogs, matched)
Pick 24- Western Bulldogs- Riley Bonner
Pick 25- Western Bulldogs- Charlie Curnow
Pick 26- GWS- Harrison Himmelberg (Academy Selection, bid on by Fremantle, matched)
Pick 27- Fremantle- Ben McKay
Pick 28- West Coast- Daniel Rioli
Pick 29- Essendon- Tom Cole
Pick 30- Essendon- Josh Dunkley (Father/Son, bid on by Essendon, chose not to match)
Pick 31- North Melbourne- Kieran Lovell
Pick 32- Collingwood- Brayden Fiorini
Pick 33- North Melbourne- David Cunningham
Pick 34- Gold Coast- Aidyn Johnson
Pick 35- Western Bulldogs- Nathan Broad
Pick 36- West Coast- Ben Crocker
Pick 37- Port Adelaide- Nick O'Kearney
Pick 38- Fremantle- Jesse Glass-McCasker
Pick 39- Brisbane- Corey Wagner
Pick 40- Sydney- Alex Morgan
Pick 41- St. Kilda- Bailey Rice (Father/Son)
Pick 42- Melbourne- Blake Hardwick
Pick 43- North Melbourne- Brandon White
Pick 44- Hawthorn- Will Snelling
Pick 45- Port Adelaide- Mason Redman
Pick 46- Melbourne- Nash Holmes
Pick 47- Western Bulldogs- Dylan Smith
Pick 48- Richmond- Thomas Glen
Pick 49- Essendon- Gach Nyuon
Pick 50- Carlton- Jack Silvagni (Father/Son)
Pick 51- Carlton- James Parsons
Pick 52- Fremantle- Mitch Brown

I was just going to say the same thing. I was wondering what your reasoning was for Curnow slipping so far. While I would love to get him at the Bulldogs, I just don't think he will slip that far.

Personally I would be happy with Ben McKay at one of our picks so I'm just hoping he gets past Carlton and North Melb.

 

[HBF]

Would be happy those 4 if it came out that way on Tuesday night.

 

[hendo8888]

I was just going to say the same thing. I was wondering what your reasoning was for Curnow slipping so far. While I would love to get him at the Bulldogs, I just don't think he will slip that far.

Personally I would be happy with Ben McKay at one of our picks so I'm just hoping he gets past Carlton and North Melb.

I'm assuming it's because of his little escapade overnight.

 

[Bastyy]

I think Curnow will be the Darling of this draft. He could slip further than most think, some clubs take stuff like his escapade last night really seriously so their club doesn't get a bad rep.

Could see Hawthorn taking him, with the whole Luke Hodge thing. I probably don't want to say too much about that so I don't anger too many Hawthorn fans. Just a thought.

I was contemplating giving Ben McKay to Bulldogs and then giving Curnow to Freo, but A. That would seem a bit biased and wouldn't be a good start to my phantom drafting and B. If you were the Bulldogs, why wouldn't you want to take Curnow? I was thinking Curnow for Carlton as well, but on a more personal level i prefer Gresham and think he might end up doing more than Curnow

 

[ExRoyboy]

I think Curnow will be the Darling of this draft. He could slip further than most think, some clubs take stuff like his escapade last night really seriously so their club doesn't get a bad rep.

Could see Hawthorn taking him, with the whole Luke Hodge thing. I probably don't want to say too much about that so I don't anger too many Hawthorn fans. Just a thought.

I was contemplating giving Ben McKay to Bulldogs and then giving Curnow to Freo, but A. That would seem a bit biased and wouldn't be a good start to my phantom drafting and B. If you were the Bulldogs, why wouldn't you want to take Curnow? I was thinking Curnow for Carlton as well, but on a more personal level i prefer Gresham and think he might end up doing more than Curnow

I would be happy if the Dogs draft Curnow if he is available, so long as they also get a key defender with their other pick in the 20's. Based on most phantom's Ben McKay looks like being the best available at that pick and he also doesn't mind playing forward which is a bonus. Plus I really like his size, but really I would be happy with any of the key defenders that have been bandied about. It is a massive gap in our list at the moment which if not addressed soon will stop us from reaching our full potential. So I see this as a critical draft for the Doggies.

 

[Since 2001]

Hawks would swoop on Curnow

 

[coryne]

Swap Mathieson with Curnow and I would be pretty happy. Great kpd, raw kpf, a forward utility who can be whooped into line by his brother who is one of the most hard working and respected players at the club and a highly skilled (but teenie tiny) midfielder who would go much higher if he was a couple of cm taller

 

[rumoursofwinter]

If there are no major sliders I am hoping that Port get O'Kearney and Redman!

 

[dwoody15]

Crows would take Curnow. They need tall forwards. And less of a risk than Burton.

 

[Roughies Boys]

Well done, I like this one

 

[Bastyy]

I'm going to be doing another version of this on Monday, I'll add a few more picks and swap some things around.

Thanks for all the great feedback!

Crows would take Curnow. They need tall forwards. And less of a risk than Burton.

I do agree with this, and might change it, but I looked ahead into the future. If Burton came back and became a great tall forward, there would be no risk of him wanting to go home. If Curnow arrived, he might want to go play with his brother, or just go back to Victoria.

 

[19thcrow]

Crows won't take balic with pick 9. I'd be pissed off if they did. No way on earth curnow slips out of top 10.

 

[dwoody15]

I'm going to be doing another version of this on Monday, I'll add a few more picks and swap some things around.

Thanks for all the great feedback!




I do agree with this, and might change it, but I looked ahead into the future. If Burton came back and became a great tall forward, there would be no risk of him wanting to go home. If Curnow arrived, he might want to go play with his brother, or just go back to Victoria.

I would still be happy with Burton. Just think they would select Curnow. They would be thinking that the club would be a good environment for him.

 

[Footywizard]

I would still be happy with Burton. Just think they would select Curnow. They would be thinking that the club would be a good environment for him.

You guys need milera

Sent from my SM-N9005 using Tapatalk

 

[dwoody15]

You guys need milera

Sent from my SM-N9005 using Tapatalk

Why do we need Milera?

 

[cuved9]

Pretty good, but Curnow doesn't slip to 25

Agree, try doubtful that Curnow slips that low considering his upside

 

[purplerunsdeep]

Hey guys! I'm new around here, and its not even been 3 months since i joined BigFooty, but every year i make personal Phantom Drafts.
If you want reasons on why i think clubs will pick who they pick, just ask me and i'll answer
Anyway, too much talk, not enough draft

Pick 1- Carlton- Jacob Weitering
Pick 2- Brisbane- Josh Schache
Pick 3- Sydney- Callum Mills (Academy Selection, bid on by Melbourne, matched)
Pick 4- Melbourne- Darcy Parish
Pick 5- GWS- Jacob Hopper (Academy Selection, bid on by Essendon, matched)
Pick 6- Essendon- Sam Weideman
Pick 7- Essendon- Wayne Milera
Pick 8- GWS- Matthew Kennedy (Academy Selection, bid on by Gold Coast, matched)
Pick 9- Gold Coast- Aaron Francis
Pick 10- Melbourne- Clayton Oliver
Pick 11- Carlton- Harry McKay
Pick 12- Adelaide- Harley Balic
Pick 13- Carlton- Rhys Mathieson
Pick 14- Brisbane- Ben Keays (Academy Selection, bid on by Richmond, matched)
Pick 15- Richmond- Callum ah Chee
Pick 16- Adelaide- Ryan Burton
Pick 17- St. Kilda- Darcy Tucker
Pick 18- Hawthorn- Kieran Collins
Pick 19- Gold Coast- Ryan Clarke
Pick 20- North Melbourne- Luke Partington
Pick 21- Hawthorn- Mitchell Hibberd
Pick 22- Carlton- Jade Gresham
Pick 23- Brisbane- Eric Hipwood (Academy Selection, bid on by Western Bulldogs, matched)
Pick 24- Western Bulldogs- Riley Bonner
Pick 25- Western Bulldogs- Charlie Curnow
Pick 26- GWS- Harrison Himmelberg (Academy Selection, bid on by Fremantle, matched)
Pick 27- Fremantle- Ben McKay
Pick 28- West Coast- Daniel Rioli
Pick 29- Essendon- Tom Cole
Pick 30- Essendon- Josh Dunkley (Father/Son, bid on by Essendon, chose not to match)
Pick 31- North Melbourne- Kieran Lovell
Pick 32- Collingwood- Brayden Fiorini
Pick 33- North Melbourne- David Cunningham
Pick 34- Gold Coast- Aidyn Johnson
Pick 35- Western Bulldogs- Nathan Broad
Pick 36- West Coast- Ben Crocker
Pick 37- Port Adelaide- Nick O'Kearney
Pick 38- Fremantle- Jesse Glass-McCasker
Pick 39- Brisbane- Corey Wagner
Pick 40- Sydney- Alex Morgan
Pick 41- St. Kilda- Bailey Rice (Father/Son)
Pick 42- Melbourne- Blake Hardwick
Pick 43- North Melbourne- Brandon White
Pick 44- Hawthorn- Will Snelling
Pick 45- Port Adelaide- Mason Redman
Pick 46- Melbourne- Nash Holmes
Pick 47- Western Bulldogs- Dylan Smith
Pick 48- Richmond- Thomas Glen
Pick 49- Essendon- Gach Nyuon
Pick 50- Carlton- Jack Silvagni (Father/Son)
Pick 51- Carlton- James Parsons
Pick 52- Fremantle- Mitch Brown

Mate if freo take those 3 - id be stoked [emoji106]

 

[2006_Eagles]

Mate if freo take those 3 - id be stoked [emoji106]

When has Mitch Brown ever been linked to Freo?

 

[Clems Knee]

When has Mitch Brown ever been linked to Freo?

"Fremantle has been linked to former Cat Mitch Brown, and he has recently taken part in a fitness session for the club."
http://www.afl.com.au/news/2015-11-22/callum-twomeys-2015-phantom-draft

 

[Bastyy]

Updated my Phantom Draft, and added some more picks

 

[dwoody15]

Crows won't take Milera and Balic when they are lacking talls.

 

[Footywizard]

Wow imagine if that came true for carlton!! They would have a party

Sent from my SM-N9005 using Tapatalk

 

[Steel Eagles]

Where is Ryan Clarke in this phantom draft?