Beach Boys or Beatles?

[lioness]

Originally posted by Grendel


Yea right, next thing you will be telling me theres shots of men in that clip or something......

LOL Just Carl. The rest...........I dunno so much. LOL

By the way, the 'scenery' in the film clip is actually their WIVES lol.

 

[lioness]

Originally posted by jod23
Give it up Lioness...

The Beatles were great but the Beach Boys were the greatest. Especially Carl.

End Of Story.

Jod that is one of the best things you have ever said.

I know it's what u really meant to say!!!!!!

 

[CURVE]

Originally posted by lioness22


Absolutely the Bigfooty post of the year!!!!!!!!!!!! Ahhhhhhhh.

Which version of Good Vibrations, there are many.

The Good Vibrations version that was recently voted the GREATEST SONG OF ALL TIME, by all the rock Gods and Godesses including Paul, Ringo and George. The Beach Boys version.

 

[Mcchawk]

So results is Beatles by a mile....

 

[RichmondEmma]

Beatles but i don't like them both

 

[lioness]

Originally posted by Mcchawk
So results is Beatles by a mile....

*grabs her 'Pet Sounds Sessions' box set and ignores the non-believers*

 

[The Hippie]

Originally posted by localyokel
All bloody hippies for mine.

Oi, don't take my name in vain, unless you're willing to pay for the copyright.

 

[Mcchawk]

Originally posted by Mcchawk


Obviously all the Beach Boys were involved in No 1 singles and records. You're failing to understand my point.

My statement / point is this. The Beatles were the only band where each individual member sung lead vocals on a song & that single reached number 1 in both the US & UK. For example, Ringo Starr (Yellow Submarine), George Harrison (Something) and John Lennon & Paul McCartney obviously having a series of number 1 singles each where they sang lead for the band.

Now, did the Beach Boys match this? Or was the band made up of one average lead vocalist compared to the combined genius of four of the greatest all round musicians & vocalists of all time.

And don't get me started about quality of lyrics between the 2 bands. The Beatles could find something to sing & celebrate other than surf & daddy's T-Bird!!!

When are you going to answer this Lioness???? Or is it too hard for you because this is the knockout punch???

 

[lioness]

Originally posted by Mcchawk


When are you going to answer this Lioness???? Or is it too hard for you because this is the knockout punch???

I actually thought I had........... Had puter probs the other night so perhaps it didn't post, I dunno.

The Beach Boys actually stopped singing about surf and cars around 1965.......the music evolved. It's just that all Captiol Records know how to release is the Hits........

Anyway, if any of you actually KNEW the entire Beach Boys catalogue, you would know that it's THE most creative, amazing music you will hear. But none of you go past the Hits, and that's good enough for you. Makes you look a little stupid when it comes to arguing points though......

 

[Mcchawk]

Originally posted by Mcchawk


Obviously all the Beach Boys were involved in No 1 singles and records. You're failing to understand my point.

My statement / point is this. The Beatles were the only band where each individual member sung lead vocals on a song & that single reached number 1 in both the US & UK. For example, Ringo Starr (Yellow Submarine), George Harrison (Something) and John Lennon & Paul McCartney obviously having a series of number 1 singles each where they sang lead for the band.

Now, did the Beach Boys match this? Or was the band made up of one average lead vocalist compared to the combined genius of four of the greatest all round musicians & vocalists of all time.

I believe Lioness you didn't answer this above? Name for me the member's of the Bleach boys and their respective number one hits in both the US & UK.. Look forward to you reply!!!! That's if you don't choose to ignore this, like you did answering this question orginally..

 

[lioness]

Originally posted by Mcchawk


I believe Lioness you didn't answer this above? Name for me the member's of the Bleach boys and their respective number one hits in both the US & UK.. Look forward to you reply!!!! That's if you don't choose to ignore this, like you did answering this question orginally..

OK after some late-night discussion with some prominent Beach Boys people (and the finest hack on the Black Board....... MTG ) the general feeling is that it's a waste of time discussing our fabulous boys with a bunch of hacks who have an out-dated Greatest Hits album as their reference to 40 years of Beach Boys magic............when you've listened to each band's entire catalogue and can actually form a proper argument, we will talk. On behalf of the Beach Boys and their most prominent fans............... lol you know the rest.

 

[Mcchawk]

Originally posted by lioness22



when you've listened to each band's entire catalogue and can actually form a proper argument, we will talk. On behalf of the Beach Boys and their most prominent fans............... lol you know the rest.

When I can form a proper argument!! Bit rich you can't even answer my previous question!!

 

[lioness]

Originally posted by Mcchawk


When I can form a proper argument!! Bit rich you can't even answer my previous question!!

Read the statement again. Do what it says, then we'll talk.

 

[Mcchawk]

Originally posted by lioness22


Read the statement again. Do what it says, then we'll talk.

I now take it Lioness your refusal to answer my question leads to one thing. The Beatles are a better band than The Bleach Boys. Some fan you are....

 

[lioness]

Originally posted by Mcchawk


I now take it Lioness your refusal to answer my question leads to one thing. The Beatles are a better band than The Bleach Boys. Some fan you are....

AHAHAHAHAHAHAHA. We told you, we are not speaking. I told you, when you know BOTH bands' entire catalogues, we will talk. Till then, tell it to someone else. We don't have to justify a thing.

 

[Mcchawk]

Originally posted by lioness22


AHAHAHAHAHAHAHA. We told you, we are not speaking. I told you, when you know BOTH bands' entire catalogues, we will talk. Till then, tell it to someone else. We don't have to justify a thing.

Last chance to answer the question, because you know what the answer is don't you? Just don't want to admit that you've been done by hiding behind stupid comment like the above. Ashamed to admit your wrong? Don't worry Lioness it'll be our secret that The Beatles are a better band than The Bleach Boys. Keep on going living a dream that the Bleach Boys are better but we know the truth don't we???? ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha fall off chair ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha

 

[lioness]

"she'll return in love with her liberty, just away from the non-believers.........."

You call yourself a fan??? What kind of comment is that??? I'm not a fan I'm part of the action.

 

[Mcchawk]

Originally posted by lioness22
"she'll return in love with her liberty, just away from the non-believers.........."

You call yourself a fan??? What kind of comment is that??? I'm not a fan I'm part of the action.

Just answer the question... the secret's between you and I ha ha ha ha ha ha Bleach Boys ha ha ha ha ha ha part of the action ha ha ha ha ha ha