Remove this Banner Ad

Best Eagle player with each jumper number

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Belgarion

All Australian
Feb 17, 2002
816
40
Werribee
AFL Club
West Coast
Other Teams
Wallabies
Being preseason and not having much football news to read or think about, I got thinking about who are or have been the best players wearing each number and the result is the list below.

I built it mainly from memory and using the Eagles website’s past players section. However the website has some wrong information. For example it shows:
Mitchell White as 47, when I remember it was a lower number, 15 I believe but I am not sure.
John Worsfold as 24, when he had 29.
Dean Kemp as 33 when I am sure he ran around with 2 on his back.
Ashley McIntosh was shown as 53. since I cannot remember his real number I haven’t got him on the list. Would someone who remembers his number help?

I reckon that perhaps the website shows the first number issued to the player, not the number he used for most of his career.

The numbers for Brett Heady and Fraser Gehrig are the numbers shown on the website, and although they look wrong to me I cannot recall what numbers they had while playing. Input from other posters will be welcome.

The list is also my opinion based on my recollection of the numbers, so it’s subject to change with further knowledge.

Here it is:

1 Gardiner
2 Kemp
3 Judd, Mainwaring
4 Kerr, Sumich
5 Dwayne Lamb
6 Banfield
7 Craig Turley
8 Metropolis, Malaxos
9 Cousins
10 Don Pike, Braun
11 Priddis
12 Mitch Morton
13 Josh Wooden
14 Brennan, Cummins
15 Mitchell White
16 Micahel Prior
17 McKenna, Chick
18 Rowan Jones
19 Langdon
20 Cox
21 Mark Merenda
22 Jayme Graham
23 Glass
24 Mat Rosa
25 Laurie Keene
26 Alex Ischenko
27 Jackovich
28 Chris Lewis
29 Worsfold
30 Peter Matera
31 Waterman
32 Embley
33 Phil Matera
34 Geghrig
35 Troy Ugle
36 David Hart, Brett Jones
37 A Selwood
38 Barich
39 Heady, Hunter
40 Tony Evans
41 Staker
42 Chad Morrison
43 Paul Symons
44 Wirrapanda
45 Laurie Bellotti
46 Jarrad Schofield
47 Kasey Green
50 Ryan Turnbull.

As mentioned previously, many numbers come from the past players section in the Eagles website, which I reckon has many wrong numbers. So some players could be on the list when they don’t deserve it, and some others, like Ashley McIntosh, are missing out.

Opinions, please.
 
I did a series of polls last year. I think they're in the Birds of Prey board. I'll put (my recollection of) the results in bold.

Mitchell White as 47, when I remember it was a lower number, 15 I believe but I am not sure. Most of his career he wore 12. Also wore 31 for a season
John Worsfold as 24, when he had 29. No, 24.
Dean Kemp as 33 when I am sure he ran around with 2 on his back. Wore 33 in his first year, then 2.
Ashley McIntosh was shown as 53. since I cannot remember his real number I haven’t got him on the list. Would someone who remembers his number help? Wore 11 most of his career.

I reckon that perhaps the website shows the first number issued to the player, not the number he used for most of his career.

The numbers for Brett Heady and Fraser Gehrig are the numbers shown on the website, and although they look wrong to me I cannot recall what numbers they had while playing. Input from other posters will be welcome. Heady was 1 most of his career, wore 39 in his first season. Gehrig wore 7 during most of his Eagles games, also wore 25 briefly and was allocated 34 in his first season though he didn't play a senior game.

The list is also my opinion based on my recollection of the numbers, so it’s subject to change with further knowledge.

Here it is:

1 Gardiner Heady
2 Kemp
3 Judd, Mainwaring Judd beat Mainy about 66% to 33%
4 Kerr, Sumich Can't recall which of these guys won.
5 Dwayne Lamb
6 Banfield
7 Craig Turley
8 Metropolis, Malaxos Malaxos won
9 Cousins
10 Don Pike, Braun I think Brauny pipped Pyke.
11 Priddis McIntosh easily
12 Mitch Morton White easily
13 Josh Wooden
14 Brennan, Cummins Brennan easily
15 Mitchell White Dean Laidley won this from memory
16 Micahel Prior Paul Symmons
17 McKenna, Chick McKenna easily
18 Rowan Jones Tony Evans beat RoJo
19 Langdon
20 Cox
21 Mark Merenda I think Lynch won this.
22 Jayme Graham David Hynes
23 Glass
24 Mat Rosa Woosha will shirtfront you into next week for saying this.
25 Laurie Keene Yes, with Hurn catching up rapidly
26 Alex Ischenko Jason Ball
27 Jackovich
28 Chris Lewis
29 Worsfold Ash Hansen
30 Peter Matera
31 Waterman Waterman wore 39 most of his career. I think Nicoski won this. No-one has worn it for more than a handful of games.
32 Embley
33 Phil Matera
34 Geghrig Dean Irving might have won this won. Kerr also wore it in his first year.
35 Troy Ugle Cousins wore it in his first season.
36 David Hart, Brett Jones Hart easily. Bones wears 38.
37 A Selwood
38 Barich I think Bones beat Barich.
39 Heady, Hunter Waterman beat Hunter. Heady only wore it for one season.
40 Tony Evans Evans wore 18 most of his career. I think Troy Wilson won this poll.
41 Staker
42 Chad Morrison
43 Paul Symons The only 3 players to wear 43 were Neil Marshall, Zach Beeck and ... can't even remember the third. But it was basically a nil-all draw.
44 Wirrapanda
45 Laurie Bellotti
46 Jarrad Schofield
47 Kasey Green
50 Ryan Turnbull.

As mentioned previously, many numbers come from the past players section in the Eagles website, which I reckon has many wrong numbers. So some players could be on the list when they don’t deserve it, and some others, like Ashley McIntosh, are missing out.

Opinions, please.
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

What about the number with the most appearances?

9, 4 17 maybe?
Here is the top 10 numbers, how many games they were used and who wore them.
# Games
10 - 388 - Dean Turner, Don Pyke, Michael Braun
7 - 379 - Phil Narkle, Craig Turley, Fraser Gehrig, Chad Fletcher
17 - 377 - Guy McKenna, Daniel Chick, Josh Kennedy
5 - 369 - Dwayne Lamb, Andy Lovell, Chad Morrison, Tyson Stenglein
6 - 362 - Geoff Miles, Paul Peos, Drew Banfield, Mark Nicoski
27 - 353 - Mark Zanotti, Steven Jackson, Glen Jakovich, Ben McKinley
14 - 346 - Michael Brennan, Ilijia Grgic, Scott Cummings, Mark Seaby
9 - 342 - Glen O'Loughlin, Brent Hutton, Peter Wilson, Brayden Lyle, Ben Cousins
3 - 335 - Chris Mainwaring, Chris Judd
2 - 330 - Robert Wiley, John Annear, Dean Kemp, Andrew McDougall, Mark LeCras
 
The results of the polls I did mid-last year:


Well I've tallied the results of my little project, and here they are, the winners and the runners-up for each number:

#1: Brett Heady (91%), Michael Gardiner (7%)
#2: Dean Kemp (99%), Andrew McDougall (1%)
#3: Chris Judd (67%), Chris Mainwaring (33%)
#4: Daniel Kerr (60%), Peter Sumich (33%)
#5: Dwayne Lamb (67%), Tyson Stenglein (31%)
#6: Drew Banfield (100%)
#7: Craig Turley (54%), Chad Fletcher (39%)
#8: Beau Waters (61%), Steve Malaxos (35%)
#9: Ben Cousins (95%), Glenn O’Loughlin (5% - smartarses)
#10: Michael Braun (79%), Don Pyke (20%)
#11: Ashley McIntosh (95%), Matt Priddis (5%)
#12: Mitchell White (100%)
#13: Josh Wooden (73%), Chris Masten (17%)
#14: Michael Brennan (80%), Scott Cummings (20%)
#15: Dean Laidley (71%), Callum Chambers (26%)
#16: Paul Symmons (81%), John Annear (10%)
#17: Guy McKenna (97%), Daniel Chick (3%)
#18: Tony Evans (50%), Rowan Jones (46%)
#19: Karl Langdon (73%), Michael Gardiner (17%)
#20: Dean Cox (98%), Trent Cummings (2%)
#21: Quinten Lynch (94%), Jarrad Schofield/Mark Merenda (3%)
#22: David Hynes (84%), Beau Waters (13%)
#23: Darren Glass (100%)
#24: John Worsfold (95%), Matt Rosa (5%)
#25: Shannon Hurn (56%), Laurie Keene (39%)
#26: Jason Ball (77%), Sam Butler (20%)
#27: Glen Jakovich (95%), Mark Zanotti/Ben McKinley (2%)
#28: Chris Lewis (100%)
#29: Ashley Hansen (88%), Andrew Donnelly (9%)
#30: Peter Matera (94%), Clinton Browning/Matt Spangher (3%)
#31: Mark Nicoski (74%), Will Schofield (14%)
#32: Andrew Embley (100%)
#33: Phil Matera (100%)
#34: Daniel Kerr (62%), Dean Irving (38%)
#35: Ben Cousins (82%), Kasey Green (9%)
#36: David Hart (100%)
#37: Adam Selwood (97%), Andrew Williams (3%)
#38: Brett Jones (97%), Adrian Barich (3%)
#39: Adam Hunter (56%), Chris Waterman (44%)
#40: Troy Wilson (97%), Tony Evans (3%)
#41: Brent Staker (100%)
#42: Chad Morrison (97%), Beau Wilkes (3%)
#43: Neil Marshall (67%), Zach Beeck (19%)
#44: David Wirrpanda (98%), Tony Begovich (2%)
#45: Andrew Lockyer (73%), Quinten Lynch (10%)
 
Here is the top 10 numbers, how many games they were used and who wore them.
# Games
10 - 388 - Dean Turner, Don Pyke, Michael Braun
7 - 379 - Phil Narkle, Craig Turley, Fraser Gehrig, Chad Fletcher
17 - 377 - Guy McKenna, Daniel Chick, Josh Kennedy
5 - 369 - Dwayne Lamb, Andy Lovell, Chad Morrison, Tyson Stenglein
6 - 362 - Geoff Miles, Paul Peos, Drew Banfield, Mark Nicoski
27 - 353 - Mark Zanotti, Steven Jackson, Glen Jakovich, Ben McKinley
14 - 346 - Michael Brennan, Ilijia Grgic, Scott Cummings, Mark Seaby
9 - 342 - Glen O'Loughlin, Brent Hutton, Peter Wilson, Brayden Lyle, Ben Cousins
3 - 335 - Chris Mainwaring, Chris Judd
2 - 330 - Robert Wiley, John Annear, Dean Kemp, Andrew McDougall, Mark LeCras

Thanks mate. Didnt expect some of those results.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

1 Gardiner
2 Kemp
3 Judd, Mainwaring
4 Kerr, Sumich
5 Sheppard Dwayne Lamb
6 Banfield
7 Craig Turley
8 Metropolis, Malaxos
9 Naitanui Cousins
10 Don Pike, Braun
11 Priddis
12 Sharrod Mitch Morton
13 Shuey the ****ing Shue Josh Wooden
14 Brennan, Cummins
15 Mitchell White
16 Michael Prior
17 McKenna, Chick
18 Rowan Jones
19 Langdon
20 Cox
21 Mark Merenda
22 Jayme Graham
23 Glass
24 Mat Rosa
25 Laurie Keene
26 Alex Ischenko
27 Jackovich
28 Chris Lewis
29 Worsfold
30 Peter Matera
31 Waterman
32 Embley
33 Phil Matera
34 Geghrig
35 Troy Ugle
36 David Hart, Brett Jones
37 A Selwood
38 Barich
39 Heady, Hunter
40 Tony Evans
41 Staker
42 Chad Morrison
43 Paul Symons
44 Wirrapanda
45 Laurie Bellotti
46 Jarrad Schofield
47 Kasey Green
50 Ryan Turnbull.
 
Wow tough call between Naitanui and Cousins.

If people had the choice between the two, who would you pick and why?
 
Wow tough call between Naitanui and Cousins.

If people had the choice between the two, who would you pick and why?
The one that causes the most outrage.

Considering the controversy both players bring, it's hard to work out who.
 
1 Gardiner (Heady?)
2 Kemp
3 Judd, Mainwaring
4 Kerr, Sumich
5 Sheppard Dwayne Lamb
6 Banfield
7 Craig Turley
8 Metropolis, Malaxos
9 Naitanui Cousins
10 Don Pike, Braun
11 Priddis
12 Sharrod Mitch Morton
13 Shuey the ******* Shue Josh Wooden
14 Brennan, Cummins
15 Mitchell White
16 Michael Prior
17 McKenna, Chick (Kennedy)
18 Rowan Jones
19 Langdon
20 Cox
21 Mark Merenda
22 Jayme Graham
23 Glass
24 Mat Rosa
25 Laurie Keene (Hurn)
26 Alex Ischenko (Butler)
27 Jackovich
28 Chris Lewis
29 Worsfold
30 Peter Matera
31 Waterman
32 Embley
33 Phil Matera
34 Geghrig
35 Troy Ugle (McGinnity)
36 David Hart, Brett Jones
37 A Selwood
38 Barich
39 Heady, Hunter
40 Tony Evans
41 Staker
42 Chad Morrison
43 Paul Symons
44 Wirrapanda
45 Laurie Bellotti
46 Jarrad Schofield
47 Kasey Green
50 Ryan Turnbull.
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

1 Gardiner HEADY
2 Kemp
3 Judd, Mainwaring
4 Kerr, Sumich
5 Sheppard Dwayne LambLAMB, Shep has a way to go yet
6 Banfield
7 Craig Turley/FLETCHER
8 Metropolis, Malaxos/WATERS
9 Naitanui Cousins
10 Don Pike, Braun
11 Priddis/MCINTOSH
12 Sharrod Mitch MortonWHITE
13 Shuey the ******* Shue Josh Wooden
14 Brennan, Cummins
15 Mitchell WhiteCRIPPS, White was 12
16 Michael PriorMACKENZIE, Symmons and Chipper Adkins both well ahead of Prior too
17 McKenna, Chick, JK probably deserves a mention
18 Rowan Jones/EVANS
19 Langdon
20 Cox
21 Mark Merenda - LYNCH says "not anymore Mark"
22 Jayme Graham - HYNES
23 Glass
24 Mat Rosa - WOOSH!!!
25 Laurie Keene - BUNGA!!
26 Alex Ischenko - BUTTS! Or Jason Ball
27 Jackovich
28 Chris Lewis
29 Worsfold - HANSEN, Woosh was 24
30 Peter Matera
31 Waterman - SCHOFIELD - Waterman only wore it his first few seasons
32 Embley
33 Phil Matera
34 Geghrig - IRVING/HUTCHINGS - Gehrig only wore it his rookie year (0 games)
35 Troy Ugle - MCGINNITY has a strong claim here
36 David Hart, Brett Jones - HART, Bones was 38
37 A Selwood
38 Barich - B.JONES
39 Heady, Hunter - HUNTER/WATERMAN - Heady only wore it his rookie year
40 Tony Evans - TROY WILSON - Evans only wore it for two games
41 Staker
42 Chad Morrison
43 Paul Symons - STEAMED HAMS - Symmons only wore it his rookie year (0 games)
44 Wirrapanda
45 Laurie Bellotti - LOCKYER
46 Jarrad Schofield - CARROLL - Schofield wore it for 1 game
47 Kasey Green/STEVENSON
50 Ryan Turnbull.

Some fairly big errors and omissions, my comments in BOLD CAPS just because
 
Cousins in a landslide, NN may end up one of our great ruckman if not the greatest although Cox still has a stranglehold on that but Cousins is arguably our greatest ever player full stop. In 50 years he will still probably be our greatest number 9 and in the mix for greatest ever Eagle player.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Best Eagle player with each jumper number

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top