Rumour Bluemour Discussion thread

[inyourcool]

You know how it works!

Only Carlton cheats, sux, deserves to cop sh!t!

Now if only we could use that to instil an "us versus them" mentality we might show some fight...

 

[Gosha]

I love how the media says that the Lions should play hardball with Redden, GWS should play hardball with McCarthy but as soon as it's our contracted players they're worth nothing.

I wonder why that is

 

[Blue87]

Herald Sun reporting Blues have met with Plowman

 

[The Flying Doormat]

FFS, another Richmond idiot.

 

[ShanDog]

I wonder why that is

I wonder why everyone wants them then

 

[The Old Dark Navy's]

I note that Robbo once did a nice feel good story on Lennon, his former Carlton supporting family wearing Richmond scarves, just before his debut. His poo-pooing of anything of value for Yarran including Lennon makes sense in this light, notwithstanding he hates Carlton anyway.

 

[SafeAsMilk]

I wonder why that is

What are you implying? Clubs are trying to poach Bell, Menzel and Yarran (that we know about). All contracted.

 

[SickQwon]

"Carlton have met with Greater Western Sydney defender Lachie Plowman.

Plowman is seeking a trade back to Victoria after 3 years with the Giants.

Carlton is expected to have multiple top-20 picks to satisfy the Giants in a trade, after dealing out Lachie Henderson (Geelong) and Chris Yarran (Richmond)."

- Herald Sun

 

[HBF]

Herald Sun reporting Blues have met with Plowman

Hope so.
Plowman would be a good get.

 

[Blue87]

Never mind Lennon, Plowman is alot closer to a move to The Blues. The Article said we have several top 20 picks to use, what would it take people?

 

[Sin City]

Hope so.
Plowman would be a good get.

A lot cheaper (salary wise at least) than Carlisle too. Would allow us to use picks of value on more important areas.

 

[Juddrockz]

Possibly wanting Plowman as a chesper option than Carlisle?

 

[Mezzoculo]

A lot cheaper (salary wise at least) than Carlisle too. Would allow us to use picks of value on more important areas.

Not sure he and Carlisle are the same type of player. We could easily fit both into the same team.

 

[HBF]

A lot cheaper (salary wise at least) than Carlisle too. Would allow us to use picks of value on more important areas.

We're got holes all through our list, but Plowman would be a good start. Still 50/50 on Carlisle.

 

[Blue and Silver]

Missing Carlisle for Plowman might be ok. Assume Weitering at #1, then we might end up with a young up and coming backline.

Carlisle seems a little bit like stop-gap

 

[Sin City]

Not sure he and Carlisle are the same type of player. We could easily fit both into the same team.

We've got more important areas to worry about than tall defenders, especially if we're getting Weitering as well. Plowman and Weitering is plenty.

 

[Blue__Balls]

Never mind Lennon, Plowman is alot closer to a move to The Blues. The Article said we have several top 20 picks to use, what would it take people?

Very similar situation to O'Rourke, who went to Hawthorn for 19.

Our second should do it, which would be 19 if Danger has to be traded, or 20 if he goes as a FA.

 

[SafeAsMilk]

Possibly wanting Plowman as a chesper option than Carlisle?

I hope not. Plowman is undersized for a KPD. Would be a great third marking tall though, with Carlisle and Weitering as KPDs

 

[HereComesJuddy]

"Carlton have met with Greater Western Sydney defender Lachie Plowman.

Plowman is seeking a trade back to Victoria after 3 years with the Giants.

Carlton is expected to have multiple top-20 picks to satisfy the Giants in a trade, after dealing out Lachie Henderson (Geelong) and Chris Yarran (Richmond)."

- Herald Sun

Link anyone?

 

[Mezzoculo]

We've got more important areas to worry about than tall defenders, especially if we're getting Weitering as well. Plowman and Weitering is plenty.

I hope not. Plowman is undersized for a KPD. Would a great third marking tall though, with Carlisle and Weitering as KPDs

This.

 

[Blue87]

Using the "Trading Rules and Regulations of Richmond 101" we would need to give up something equivelant to pick 3 as Plowman was.

 

[Sin City]

This.

Wrong way to go and would just set us further back. We need to add stars to our on ball division and find some goal kicking forwards (tall and small).

 

[HereComesJuddy]

Plowman would be a good get. Kid could be anything. Carlisle would still be handy. Not sure at this stage of a rebuild we should be saying if we get 2 tall Backs that's enough.

 

[Mezzoculo]

Wrong way to go and would just set us further back. We need to add stars to our on ball division and find some goal kicking forwards (tall and small).

We need all teh players. Would be happy for SOS to identify available talent and have a crack at them, irrespective of position.

 

[Mezzoculo]

Club trying to manufacture a Bell for Redden trade. #bluemour

Make. It. Happen.