C4 has solved the Judd problem !!!!

[C4[2]Yo`DooR]

ok .. here's the deal:

Thornton + Pick #20 to Hawthorn for #12

#3 + #12 to WCE

We Keep JK, we keep #1, Hawthorn get Thornton .... everyone is happy ...

Effectively we lose: #3, #20 and Thornton for Judd.

Now .. to get Hawthorn to agree to it ...

 

[Smell The Glove]

If only it were that simple.....

 

[Bluebear]

ok .. here's the deal:

Thornton + Pick #20 to Hawthorn for #12

#3 + #12 to WCE

We Keep JK, we keep #1, Hawthorn get Thornton .... everyone is happy ...

Effectively we lose: #3, #20 and Thornton for Judd.

Now .. to get Hawthorn to agree to it ...

Thornton to Hawks
Boyle + pick 3 to WCE
Judd to Blues

 

[Hawks2009]

sounds good but, only problem is Hawthorn really want to keep their pick 12 because they are going after cyril rioli in the draft. may even want up upgrade their 12 to a better first round

 

[Sharks On A Plane]

Happy with that deal. Sick of Thornton.

Also, respect for your location, C4.

 

[anti.]

3 + 12 is not enough for judd.

 

[Bluebear]

3 + 12 is not enough for judd.

It will never be enough.

 

[matty89]

3 + 12 is not enough for judd.

add in a later draft pick

 

[Crippa#9]

This should be the deal:

Carlton give Hawthorn Thornton.

Hawthorn give WCE Boyle

Carlton give WCE #3, #20.

WCE Give Carlton Judd.

Carlton keep Kennedey.

simple. now sign it and get it done.

 

[RoK]

This should be the deal:

Carlton give Hawthorn Thornton.

Hawthorn give WCE Boyle

Carlton give WCE #3, #20.

WCE Give Carlton Judd.

Carlton keep Kennedey.

simple. now sign it and get it done.

yup good get it done

 

[Bluebear]

This should be the deal:

Carlton give Hawthorn Thornton.

Hawthorn give WCE Boyle

Carlton give WCE #3, #20.

WCE Give Carlton Judd.

Carlton keep Kennedey.

simple. now sign it and get it done.

Wow.......wish I had of thought of that.......and posted it ........above......in post 3.

 

[Nightwolf]

And give up a good chance at Cyril Rioli? Pelchin will laugh at that trade offer..

 

[C4[2]Yo`DooR]

And give up a good chance at Cyril Rioli? Pelchin will laugh at that trade offer..

I'll then laugh at the way he speaks.

 

[BlueYoss]

Wow.......wish I had of thought of that.......and posted it ........above......in post 3.

You've gotta be quick Bear -way too many great minds sharing their brilliance on here these days!

 

[Bluespoon]

C4 needed to be quicker too...
Posted by myself at 16:13

As much as i like Thornton if he still wants to play with Hawthorn then offer him along with pick 20 for Hawthorn's pick 12 ...Pick 3 and 12 would be better than Richmond's pick 2 and 18 offer for Judd, and we could keep JK....

 

[albyg]

Thornton to Hawks
Boyle + pick 3 to WCE
Judd to Blues

Isn't Mark Williams from WA, i think that would be the better more lucrative deal for WCE....not sure if Hawthorn would agree, however they do want Thornton......Hence, i would replace Boyle with Williams....

 

[Nightwolf]

Isn't Mark Williams from WA, i think that would be the better more lucrative deal for WCE....not sure if Hawthorn would agree, however they do want Thornton......Hence, i would replace Boyle with Williams....

Williams will not play for a W.A club. Ever. He hates both of them with a passion. Trust me on this one...

 

[Team Chemistry]

i dont rate Thornton that much to tell you the truth, i thought he was good last year but this year not at all. But the thing is although he isnt fantastic, he is your full back and the question is do you have a replacement. At the moment you seem to be building a great midfield on top of your good forward line. Whats going to happen to the defence if this hypothetical trade goes through?

TC

 

[Mayesy_23]

This should be the trade.
Russell to Port for Pick 33
Thornton and pick 33 to Hawthorn for pick 12
Pick 3, 12, and 20 for to Eagles for Judd.

Keep JK, Bower
Lose Russell, Thornton, Pick 3, 20
Get Judd

DONE.. I wish.

 

[The Old Dark Navy's]

It has been said that Josh is just as important to the Eagles as Pick 3 if not more. They rate him. You can not just package any player as a sweetener. If this is the case there is no other deal that will get the job done.