Callum Twomey's Phantom Draft afl website

[Stylo]

Reckon it's got anything to do with how your list is at the moment and your premiership window? If you pick up Burton, he'll take a lot of time whereas Rioli has the potential to perhaps impact in his first season where you really need it, ala Cyril Rioli in 2008

He weighs 69kg right now, can't see him impacting for a few years.

 

[BOMBERS 4 LIFE!!!!]

You'd surely go with Parish. Oliver's best was in a weakened team environment.

Most draft experts have Melb taking Oliver with 3/4.

Would be stoked with Francis+Parish.

 

[Rustler]

How much would you put on it?

Let Melbourne have him

 

[BOMBERS 4 LIFE!!!!]

Let Melbourne have him

Will take Oliver instead.

 

[gillo94]

Egg, face etc

He did well first 15 picks. After that the selections went all over the place but it's expected

I was hearing reports for social media that Demons were considering Harry McKay and Curnow ahead of Weideman and St Kilda to get Fiorini

But that's the draft. Rumour and last minute discussions. I think the Charlie Curnow arrest really did shape the draft as Essendon and Melbourne were strongly linked to him

 

[KohPhi]

He did well first 15 picks. After that the selections went all over the place but it's expected

I was hearing reports for social media that Demons were considering Harry McKay and Curnow ahead of Weideman and St Kilda to get Fiorini

But that's the draft. Rumour and last minute discussions. I think the Charlie Curnow arrest really did shape the draft as Essendon and Melbourne were strongly linked to him

Lost me at social media Gillo!!

 

[gillo94]

Lost me at social media Gillo!!

Well it's the draft. I bet you look at Twitter and fb phantom drafts

 

[Dez!]

He did well first 15 picks. After that the selections went all over the place but it's expected

I was hearing reports for social media that Demons were considering Harry McKay and Curnow ahead of Weideman and St Kilda to get Fiorini

But that's the draft. Rumour and last minute discussions. I think the Charlie Curnow arrest really did shape the draft as Essendon and Melbourne were strongly linked to him

No you took random crap and presumed it was true.

 

[KohPhi]

Well it's the draft. I bet you look at Twitter and fb phantom drafts

Ahhh nope..

 

[InFineForm]

He obviously speaks to 18 recruiters every day

But my point is he gets informed what the recruiters want to feed him. They hold back because they won't risk their hard work being leaked to other clubs. 2013 is irrelevant

And where is your phantom? He puts them on the block to get chopped off by the likes of you.

 

[gillo94]

No you took random crap and presumed it was true.

You saying that Melbourne were never considering Harry McKay or Charlie Curnow at Pick 7?

I have seen heaps of Phantom drafts having Demons taking Harry and Charlie and heaps having MFC even taking Darcy Parish

I think Charlie Curnow incident might have influenced the top 10 because the week prior he was in it and Demons closely linked

 

[gillo94]

And where is your phantom? He puts them on the block to get chopped off by the likes of you.

all I said I was he gets feed bad information at time. Did Crows disclose Tom Doedee intentions to him?

Did anyone see Kieren Lovell going to Hawks over Collins? I bet Hawks feeding him crap about Collins. But that's how it is and I think he did well

Mathieson I was surprised by. Think his beep test out off a lot of clubs

 

[InFineForm]

all I said I was he gets feed bad information at time.

And considering this he does OK. No-one gives out their best mail on anything. So it's pretty much a case of listening & attempting to remove the BS from recruiters statements. Which essentially allows everyone to take a free hit.

It's a bit like the news. If you only listen to news from the mainstream commercial media you'd probably be convinced that all suicide bombers were boozy hookers up until they decided to put a vest on.

 

[Dez!]

You saying that Melbourne were never considering Harry McKay or Charlie Curnow at Pick 7?

I have seen heaps of Phantom drafts having Demons taking Harry and Charlie and heaps having MFC even taking Darcy Parish

I think Charlie Curnow incident might have influenced the top 10 because the week prior he was in it and Demons closely linked

Harry McKay was never mentioned with Melbourne at all and if Melbourne wanted Curnow they would have taken him, his arrest would have changed nothing.

Parish is the only one outside of Oliver that Melbourne were linked to.

 

[gillo94]

Harry McKay was never mentioned with Melbourne at all and if Melbourne wanted Curnow they would have taken him, his arrest would have changed nothing.

Parish is the only one outside of Oliver that Melbourne were linked to.

Brett Anderson was linking Curnow to Demons pick 3, surely his arrest influenced Demons decision. Not that I'm complaining

 

[Dez!]

Brett Anderson was linking Curnow to Demons pick 3, surely his arrest influenced Demons decision. Not that I'm complaining

No he wasn't linking them, he stated numerous times that he would take Curnow amd it wasn't based on any information.