Can Hawthorn succeed while ignoring the elite end of the draft?

[blaisee]

You missed this:

Average age of top 5 in 2019 club B&Fs (sorted oldest to youngest)
28 FREM GEEL NTH
27 RICH WCE
26 BRIS ADEL COLL
25 GCS CARL ESS PORT SYD
24 HAW GWS STK MELB WBD

Not sure what your point is?

Hawthorn finished 9th and hasn’t won a final in 4 years

 

[Pessimistic]

Not sure what your point is?

Hawthorn finished 9th and hasn’t won a final in 4 years

By your 'age' profile, Freo and North should be worrying the most

 

[Marcel Proust]

Who is ccp and why are we discussing a 12yo?

best young ruck in afl ...

 

[HeHateMe]

Worpel is better

He sure was when they went head to head RD21 but only just.

Worpel - Taranto
D: 31 - 25
CP: 14 - 8
CLR: 8 - 4
T: 6 - 6

 

[blaisee]

By your 'age' profile, Freo and North should be worrying the most

The three clubs are all about the same

 

[blaisee]

He sure was when they went head to head RD21 but only just.

Worpel - Taranto
D: 31 - 25
CP: 14 - 8
CLR: 8 - 4
T: 6 - 6

Funny thing is

You actually believe that and are serious

 

[WWSD]

Funny thing is

You actually believe that and are serious

Nobody would take Taranto over Worpel. If you are that confident then go and start a poll on the polls board and see which player the majority will vote for.

 

[Marcel Proust]

Nobody would take Taranto over Worpel.

i would

id take most the gws list over warps

 

[WWSD]

i would

Of course you would. You’d take Castagna over Breust, Caddy over Gunston, Soldo over McEvoy etc.

Richmond fans are full of shite.

 

[Marcel Proust]

Of course you would. You’d take Castagna over Breust, Caddy over Gunston, Soldo over McEvoy etc.

Richmond bias.

but Taranto is a giants player

 

[blaisee]

Nobody would take Taranto over Worpel. If you are that confident then go and start a poll on the polls board and see which player the majority will vote for.

this is a joke right ?

 

[WWSD]

but Taranto is a giants player

And? They play the exact same role.

 

[Marcel Proust]

And? They play the exact same role.

just trying how to understand how my Richmond bias affects my thoughts or warps v taranto

 

[HeHateMe]

this is a joke right ?

Best 2 young inside mids in the comp. Comparable in almost every area down to even how they celebrate for goal.

It doesn't matter which one you or i rate higher.

But you can continue doubling down if you wish.

 

[Marcel Proust]

Best 2 young inside mids in the comp.

Jack Graham though

 

[blaisee]

Of course you would. You’d take Castagna over Breust, Caddy over Gunston, Soldo over McEvoy etc.

Richmond fans are full of shite.

Um

yep, yep, yep

Castagna in particular laps breust
Gunston is close, and has had a better career, but he lacks the intensity to get a game for the tigers,Caddy is younger and can play mid which gives him the nod, and this is the case even though Gunston is one of your stars and Caddy is a fringe player at Richmond
And there is no way I would trade Soldo for a 30 yr old ruckman that even Clarko wants to play as a defender.

 

[blaisee]

Best 2 young inside mids in the comp. Comparable in almost every area down to even how they celebrate for goal.

It doesn't matter which one you or i rate higher.

But you can continue doubling down if you wish.

Yes comparable in everything except for ability, ceiling, and value lol

 

[HairyO]

You missed this:

Average age of top 5 in 2019 club B&Fs (sorted oldest to youngest)
28 FREM GEEL NTH
27 RICH WCE
26 BRIS ADEL COLL
25 GCS CARL ESS PORT SYD
24 HAW GWS STK MELB WBD

Must be made up. We have no youf.

Not sure what your point is?

Hawthorn finished 9th and hasn’t won a final in 4 years

How were Richmond looking in 2016? At what point during 2017 did your own supporters stop calling for the sacking of your coach?

 

[HeHateMe]

Jack Graham though

Good player. Not even close.

If you wish to throw up some stats that back up your statement go ahead. Otherwise back in your hole.

 

[blaisee]

Good player. Not even close.

If you wish to throw up some stats that back up your statement go ahead. Otherwise back in your hole.

I will give you a stat

1 stat for the tigers is worth 4 stats for hawthorn

 

[Marcel Proust]

Good player. Not even close.

If you wish to throw up some stats that back up your statement go ahead. Otherwise back in your hole.

i wonder who Sloane rates of the three

good player that rory sloane

 

[HeHateMe]

That was easy.

 

[Marcel Proust]

View attachment 766243
That was easy.

like snagging 3 goals in a winning gf in your 5th game

 

[matey]

I will give you a stat

1 stat for the tigers is worth 4 stats for hawthorn

I’ll give you a better stat between our clubs .... last 38 years NINE premierships to TWO. You have got absolutely nothing on the Hawks. Tigers fans have such short memories they have been a rabble, a comical act for decades. Three years doesn’t change for me they can and will fall as quick as they rose from 2016 when they were close to sacking their coach.

 

[Marcel Proust]

I’ll give you a better stat between our clubs .... last 38 years NINE premierships to TWO. You have got absolutely nothing on the Hawks. Tigers fans have such short memories they have been a rabble, comical act for decades. Three years doesn’t change for me they can and will fall as quick as they rose from 2016 when they were close to sacking their coach.

38 is a very specific number to pick