Can someone point out the incorrect decisions??

[Helix]

you are an idiot, go watch the match tool

No need. Seems pretty obvious that Sydney fans are blaming the umpires instead of not getting enough of the footy. 1 or 2 dodgy decisions does not a game decide.

 

[Total_Juddshanks]

I'll agree to that, he isn't the best footballer in my books, there are plenty on equal terms or better. You just never see him at the bottom of packs getting the hardball, unlike hird, voss, buckley, riccuito, goodwin, cousins, goodes, bolton, kirk etc. The only thing that makes him a standout is his pace and ability to break through a tackle, and without that, he would just be an ordinary midfielder capable of kicking goals

*sigh* I think I'm going to make a habit of saving the following stats in a
notepad file each week to stop me from having to go to cut and paste them.

Contested Possessions Per Game
Judd 4.5 pg (1st in the League)

Clearances Per Game.
Judd 7.0 pg (1st in the League)

1st Possessions Per Game
Judd 7.4 pg (2nd in the League)

Brain cells per post.
MrSquashed 0pp (6 000 000 000th on the planet)

In summary, Chris Judd wins more hard ball than anyone in the league, and you are a tool.

 

[ben9909]

*sigh* I think I'm going to make a habit of saving the following stats in a
notepad file each week to stop me from having to go to cut and paste them.

Contested Possessions Per Game
Judd 4.5 pg (1st in the League)

Clearances Per Game.
Judd 7.0 pg (1st in the League)

1st Possessions Per Game
Judd 7.4 pg (2nd in the League)

Brain cells per post.
MrSquashed 0pp (6 000 000 000th on the planet)

In summary, Chris Judd wins more hard ball than anyone in the league, and you are a tool.

Judd or Davey for the Brownlow?

 

[Bestbird]

The fact that at this point in the thread there is a distict lack of many actual examples suggest the umpiring wasn't that biased.

More so considering the other thread is reaching epic proportions in terms of posts

 

[RizzoTheRat]

The fact that at this point in the thread there is a distict lack of many actual examples suggest the umpiring wasn't that biased.

More so considering the other thread is reaching epic proportions in terms of posts

The majority of Sydney fans can't be bothered going over and over this. Nothing will change. Weagles won, on to next week.

 

[natlovestheswans]

I'll give you that one. Should have been a free kick. Congratulations, after thousands of posts of bitch whining you guys have come up with one legit example (I'm sure there's more but the umpiring was no way near as bad as you all make out).

Now, care to address the umpiring that gave you your first two goals?

How about your first goal? I remember Jolly being pulled up for "kneeing in the head" which was actually funny seeing he was in mid air falling, so what else was he supposed to do?

I didn't see much in the free kick that Ryan O'Keefe got for his goal but the umpire awarded a free kick againest Jolly for something pathetic aswell, so atleast it was consistent.

 

[Quinz]

I'll agree to that, he isn't the best footballer in my books, there are plenty on equal terms or better. You just never see him at the bottom of packs getting the hardball, unlike hird, voss, buckley, riccuito, goodwin, cousins, goodes, bolton, kirk etc. The only thing that makes him a standout is his pace and ability to break through a tackle, and without that, he would just be an ordinary midfielder capable of kicking goals

Here we have difinitive proof that Judd is not the best footballer in the AFL. Two stupid eagle-hating trolls agree, it must be true.

Honestly MrSquashed, you have a lot to learn about football. I suggest you begin by watching last nights game, and tell us what you notice Judd doing, and why Sydney didn't manage to hold on to a large lead and kick only 1 goal in an entire half.

 

[natlovestheswans]

Here we have difinitive proof that Judd is not the best footballer in the AFL. Two stupid eagle-hating trolls agree, it must be true.

Honestly MrSquashed, you have a lot to learn about football. I suggest you begin by watching last nights game, and tell us what you notice Judd doing, and why Sydney didn't manage to hold on to a large lead and kick only 1 goal in an entire half.

I remember all his ineffective disposals, just like he did in the GF.

 

[Quinz]

I didn't notice that many, can you tell me when they were in the game exactly?
And what happened?

Judd is the best player in the AFL atm, equal with Goodwin for the Brownlow at this stage. His errors per game, according to pro-stats, sits as 2.5/match.
Which isn't even in the top 50 per game, and is less than Luke Hodge, Chad Cornes, Aaron Davey, Jude Bolton, Sam Mitchell, Luke Power, Barry Hall, Adam Goodes, Simon Black, Daniel Kerr, Cameron Bruce, Jason Ackermanis, Simon Goodwin, Nathan Buckley, Scott West, Nick Reiwoldt, Nick Dal Santo, Matthew Pavlich and Brad Johnson.

 

[jko'neal]

Has anyone mentioned the mark to Hunter in the goal square which he took out of Lynch's hands.Clearly Lynch had a fair bit of the ball!
On Juddy, great player but gets away with murder in regards to holding the ball, beats one player then tries to fend off another and is tackled and brought down. That is holding the ball 100 times out of a #*%#ing 100.
But he gets away with it week in week out so least the umps are consistent.

 

[larrikin]

Has anyone mentioned the mark to Hunter in the goal square which he took out of Lynch's hands.Clearly Lynch had a fair bit of the ball!
On Juddy, great player but gets away with murder in regards to holding the ball, beats one player then tries to fend off another and is tackled and brought down. That is holding the ball 100 times out of a #*%#ing 100.
But he gets away with it week in week out so least the umps are consistent.

So maybe it's not 100 times out 100 then

 

[jko'neal]

So maybe it's not 100 times out 100 then

Na you missed out the ****IN!!!

 

[natlovestheswans]

I didn't notice that many, can you tell me when they were in the game exactly?
And what happened?

His first kick, kicked it right to Tadhg Kennelly. I remember that one seeing me and my sister were talking about his bad disposals and bam, kicks it to Tadhg.

Like i said, i won't be watching the game again and if i did watch any of it i won't be sitting down with my pen and notepad seeing i really don't care.

Also, to whoever made this thread. There really aren't many that stand out because they were all free kicks for pretty much no reason.. so it's hard to say them. Maybe just watch in the 3rd and last quarter for the string of free kicks the Eagles kept getting, one after the other.

 

[Bretski]

The moral of the story is dont give away free kicks and applaud good umpireing

 

[Bretski]

First it was "we dislike team x for such and such reason" now its "I dislike YOU for not disliking the team x in which i dislike"

honestly none of us play for any AFL teams so dont give the evils to one another

 

[West Coast 06]

How about your first goal? I remember Jolly being pulled up for "kneeing in the head" which was actually funny seeing he was in mid air falling, so what else was he supposed to do?

I didn't see much in the free kick that Ryan O'Keefe got for his goal but the umpire awarded a free kick againest Jolly for something pathetic aswell, so atleast it was consistent.

Ha Ha you just lost all credibility right there! He clearly and deliberately landed knees first into Selwoods head, umpire was right there and that my friend is a free kick every day of the week and twice on Sunday!

 

[GoSydneySwans]

Has anyone mentioned the mark to Hunter in the goal square which he took out of Lynch's hands.Clearly Lynch had a fair bit of the ball!
On Juddy, great player but gets away with murder in regards to holding the ball, beats one player then tries to fend off another and is tackled and brought down. That is holding the ball 100 times out of a #*%#ing 100.
But he gets away with it week in week out so least the umps are consistent.

Vividly remember seeing that two or three times. Tries to break a couple of tackles, breaks the first one, gets taken down in the second one, and is still allowed to get the ball out after being brought down. Great player, as you said, but the umpires seem to be more lenient when it comes to him holding the ball.

 

[natlovestheswans]

Ha Ha you just lost all credibility right there! He clearly and deliberately landed knees first into Selwoods head, umpire was right there and that my friend is a free kick every day of the week and twice on Sunday!

How could he cleary and deliberately put his knees into his head? He was in mid air, where else was his knees ment to go? It's common sense. How the friggen hell else was he ment to fall from that position?

 

[weagles_fan]

How could he cleary and deliberately put his knees into his head? He was in mid air, where else was his knees ment to go? It's common sense. How the friggen hell else was he ment to fall from that position?

Umm the Selwood free he was laying on the ground with heaps of players around him falling ontop of him then Jolly comes in a puts his knees into his head.

 

[West Coast 06]

How could he cleary and deliberately put his knees into his head? He was in mid air, where else was his knees ment to go? It's common sense. How the friggen hell else was he ment to fall from that position?

Player A is on the ground with his head over the ball. Player B lands on the head of Player A with his knees. Free kick EVERY time.
It's common sense.

 

[West Coast 06]

Vividly remember seeing that two or three times. Tries to break a couple of tackles, breaks the first one, gets taken down in the second one, and is still allowed to get the ball out after being brought down. Great player, as you said, but the umpires seem to be more lenient when it comes to him holding the ball.

Replace the word allowed with the word able and you will see why he is such a good player.

 

[Capper admirer]

... umpireing

Brrrr!! Free kick to the WCE for atrocious spelling. (Yes, I know it should have gone the other way but that would upset the flow of things).