Carlton's Cursed and Fairest

[Silvagnis]

Win it if you dare.

1999 Matthew Allan
2000 Brett Ratten and Scott Camporeale (tied)
2001 Anthony Koutoufides
2002 Corey McKernan
2003 Andrew McKay
2004 David Teague
2005 Anthony Koutoufides
2006 Lance Whitnall
2007 Andrew Carrazzo

Hopefully Judd or Murphy can break the run of outs and win it this year.

 

[Alpha1]

Win it if you dare.

1999 Matthew Allan
2000 Brett Ratten and Scott Camporeale (tied)
2001 Anthony Koutoufides
2002 Corey McKernan
2003 Andrew McKay
2004 David Teague
2005 Anthony Koutoufides
2006 Lance Whitnall
2007 Andrew Carrazzo

Hopefully Judd or Murphy can break the run of outs and win it this year.

Just goes to show that from 2001 we had 3 duds who won the B&F show how far the great CFC has fallen.

 

[magpies10]

Just goes to show that from 2001 we had 3 duds who won the B&F show how far the great CFC has fallen.

What was wrong with Andrew Mckay? thought he was one of the better Carlton players I have seen

 

[Alpha1]

What was wrong with Andrew Mckay? thought he was one of the better Carlton players I have seen

Who said anything about Andrew McKay? He was a gun one of our champion back pockets. I am talking about CM, DT, AC

 

[thylacine60]

Think TG is more pointing to the chequered future most of them had after winning the thing.

 

[magpies10]

Who said anything about Andrew McKay? He was a gun one of our champion back pockets. I am talking about CM, DT, AC

Sorry I took it as the 3 years after 2001

 

[CarltonFan]

i hope russell wins this year.

 

[Pamam]

i hope russell wins this year.

hahaha gold!!!!

 

[1eight6four]

i hope russell wins this year.

In the Geelong pre match interview Ratts was strong with his praise in his improvement and said he sees JR as a long term player. He was a discussion piece and the general concensus was he had too many expectations placed on him when drafted - but now is finding his confidence and position.

Based on that discussion - you should get used to him being around!

 

[Team Mo']

i hope russell wins this year.

in a tie with Cain Ackland

 

[koutamarto]

Kouta Kouta Kouta

 

[big_sav]

in a tie with Cain Ackland

thats just taken it too far

 

[Mentallo]

In the Geelong pre match interview Ratts was strong with his praise in his improvement and said he sees JR as a long term player. He was a discussion piece and the general concensus was he had too many expectations placed on him when drafted - but now is finding his confidence and position.

Based on that discussion - you should get used to him being around!

I suddenly feel very ill.

 

[Mike_blues]

Who said anything about Andrew McKay? He was a gun one of our champion back pockets. I am talking about CM, DT, AC

i think whitnall is more of a dud than carrots
whitnall was good until bout 2001ish.. as soon as carlton went down, so did he and unfortunantly his weight didnt go down.. it went up

 

[Brad Pearce]

thats just taken it too far

bahahahahahaha thanks for saying that exactly what i was thinking, there's always one hero who takes the joke too far

 

[Silvagnis]

i think whitnall is more of a dud than carrots
whitnall was good until bout 2001ish.. as soon as carlton went down, so did he and unfortunantly his weight didnt go down.. it went up

Garbage.

That's disrespectful to Whitnall's talents which unfortunately for us, weren't matched in the equally important areas of work ethic and athleticism.

Injuries didn't help him either.

Carrazzo will never be an AA player and kick us into a Grand Final.

 

[Mike_blues]

Garbage.

That's disrespectful to Whitnall's talents which unfortunately for us, weren't matched in the equally important areas of work ethic and athleticism.

Injuries didn't help him either.

Carrazzo will never be an AA player and kick us into a Grand Final.

perhaps i was a bit harsh
he had the footy brain, had the kicking, was born 20 years to late

 

[Gouldy]

Eddie is a shoe-in!

 

[Silvagnis]

Things look up for Andrew Carazzo Greg Baum

NO POISONED chalice has been more toxic latterly than Carlton's best-and-fairest trophy. Symptomising the Blues' blues, each of the winners from 2002 to 2006 had left the club within two years.

At least someone is reading my posts.

 

[j-ham]

Teague only won a B&F because Pagan hated Matty Lappin.

 

[blues4flag]

Teague only won a B&F because Pagan hated Matty Lappin.

Because it's Pagan's personal choice as to who gets the B&F.

 

[The Coach]

Have to think anyone who wins a B&F w/o AA ability must be a AA goer and giving their all for the team - it is these types who, when added to the cream, can make a sensational Team

 

[j-ham]

Because it's Pagan's personal choice as to who gets the B&F.

Well, considering Pagan and his bitch Tony Elshaug were about half of the deciding panel, and Teague didn't exactly win in a landslide, I'd say you should stop being so ignorant.

Stevens was a more worthy winner in 2004 also.

Pagan was so busy "politiking", he didn't have time to coach.