Chad Wingard or Cyril Rioli

[Atley]

This question was brought up on SEN. What do the people of Bigfooty think?

Who is the better player?

 

[Tiger Titus]

Who is the better player?

Cyril.

Who would I pick going forward?

The Chad. I rate him above just about every young gun in the comp (Higher than Cotchin, Dangerfield, Fyfe, Heppell etc).

I might be a little bit mental, but I just see something really special about Wingard. I reckon he will become Port's AFL era GOAT. I liked how the commentators on Saturday were saying that there was no easy comparison for Wingard, he's just his own player.

 

[headache1]

Wingard

 

[juss]

The Chad is already better.

 

[Ishmael_]

If not for his body - Rioli easily. Has the ability to completely turn a game from anywhere on the ground, more capable all round and yet a fantastic team player. Love watching that tackling ability.

Wingard is a flashy player, but he constantly looks like and does cry whenever he gets pushed around, not a good look.

Pragmatically though, would probably pick Wingard going forward. Younger and seems to be more durable.

 

[Bailey01]

Chingard

 

[Crafted]

The Chad. I rate him above just about every young gun in the comp (Higher than Cotchin, Dangerfield, Fyfe, Heppell etc).

I might be a little bit mental, but I just see something really special about Wingard. I reckon he will become Port's AFL era GOAT. I liked how the commentators on Saturday were saying that there was no easy comparison for Wingard, he's just his own player.

Although I agree that Rioli IS the better player and I would take Wingard, That's a huge call.

 

[benbanjo]

When on the field Rioli.....
going forward, wingard only due to Rioli being injury prone.

 

[Spitter9]

Rioli's best > Wingard's best

but Rioli brings his best once every 7-8 games so therefore i choose wingard

 

[Chrizzt]

Remember that Rioli is 4 years older than Wingard, and had the benefit of playing his whole career in a very strong team.
Wingard is in his third year, the first of which was in a poorly performing team.

Wingard has the bigger tank, and I reckon his bag of tricks is just as good as Rioli's. Add in the consistency and durability and I'd say Wingard has him covered.

inb4PortBias

 

[quotemokc]

Wingard way more consistent and is fundamental to Port's current success, Rioli on the other hand is kind of the icing on the cake on top of a very solid Hawthorn side

 

[Tank Girl]

Rioli at his best is like a slightly above average Wingard game.

 

[jakson68]

Both can have special days but Wingard has his days much more often.

 

[Heaps of fun]

Remember that Rioli is 4 years older than Wingard, and had the benefit of playing his whole career in a very strong team.
Wingard is in his third year, the first of which was in a poorly performing team.

Wingard has the bigger tank, and I reckon his bag of tricks is just as good as Rioli's. Add in the consistency and durability and I'd say Wingard has him covered.

inb4PortBias

I agree with most of that but Rioli has more talent. He's an absolute freak with the ball in hand.

 

[Tulip]

We were discussing it at work yesterday too.

Has to be Wingard.

 

[Rainfall]

Rioli at his best is like a slightly above average Wingard game.

Opposite of this.

 

[Underdog]

I'm a big fan of Cyril and have defended him on numerous occasions but you'd just have to go for Wingard.

 

[TyHawk]

Rioli! Chad is very good but has a way to go yet.

 

[MiloStedman]

Who is the better player?

Cyril.

Who would I pick going forward?

The Chad.

/Thread.

 

[juss]

Rioli! Chad is very good but has a way to go yet.

Chad is younger and has arguably already achieved more on an individual level.

Wouldn't say he has a way to go at all.

 

[QPower]

Rioli's output does not match his talent.Wingard has Rioli comfortably covered on any measure you could make.

 

[a_fighting_fury]

Winnie the Port

 

[Vass]

I voted Rioli, but i would choose Wingard for my team. He is/will be a star, Rioli is too injury prone.

 

[QPower]

Rioli is an icing on cake player. Wingard is the cake and the icing.

 

[Big Trozza]

Lebron just ask him.