Changes 4 next week

[dee_123]

Who goes out for Moloney?

I say Godfrey out Moloney in?

Leave the rest.

Although depending on how the Sandy players go.

 

[Daniel138]

I agree
Godfrey out for Moloney

 

[Marns]

Armstrong?

 

[Super Demon]

I agree
Godfrey out for Moloney

I agree, Moloney IN

Godfrey OUT

 

[melbournemartin]

yeh armstrongs great spoil got him in my good books

he did pretty well from limited time on the ground

 

[Sylvia Saint]

In. Nicholson, Heffernan
Out. Ferguson, Bell

Only joking.

In. Moloney
Out. Godfrey

Nothing against Godders, but someone is going to be unlucky.

 

[melbournemartin]

yeh godfrey will most likely only be a replacement player this year

 

[Demon ADI]

Godders will go but holland had a great game 4 sandy so u may see maybe jamar or even sylvia drop out for Dutchy

 

[melbournemartin]

nah cant afford to drop Jamar

sylvia perhaps though but we will have Miller back up forward cos freo dun have any power full forwards

 

[Marns]

Seems stupid to drop an up-and-comer in Sylvia, for a soft fart in Holland.

 

[Demon ADI]

Yeah well Marns u gotta be harsh sometimes in this great game cause u dont want players getting games for the sake of it u want them getting games cause they deserve their spot every week and that is something that Col is going to have to do.

 

[Marns]

Yeah well Marns u gotta be harsh sometimes in this great game cause u dont want players getting games for the sake of it u want them getting games cause they deserve their spot every week and that is something that Col is going to have to do.

Yes I understand, its just that he has to get some AFL time under his belt. He's spent plenty of time playing for Sandy last year. We're only 5 games into the season, give him a few more and see how he goes. Anyway, you can't say that Holland hasn't had a fair run in the 1's either...He was also given a chance to play FF against Essendon whilst Neitz was out, during the finals, and I'm pretty sure he ended up with just the one possession. He let the team down.

 

[Sylvia Saint]

In a way I want Sylvia to go back to Sandy and rack up 35 touches, but he doesn't deserve to be dropped just yet.

 

[dees_best]

IN: Moloney, Read

OUT: Godfrey, Rigoni

Shouldn't be too long before Chris Johnson or Lynden Dunn gets themself a game.

 

[melbournemartin]

cant drop rigoni after 1 quiet game

he was great vs saints in an otherwise poor preformance overall

 

[BT]

In: Moloney

Out: I suppose it has to be Godfrey, although he's stiff because he like the rest were good considering the ground time they got.

If Motlop has to miss I'd bring Read in...might bring him back regardless to take on Freo actually .

 

[The Shev]

OFFICIAL CHANGES

IN: Moloney & Holland
OUT: Sylvia (omitted) & Jamar (calf)

I think Holland deserves a go, after booting 5 & 6 in the last two weeks. But he has to prove himself in the seniors every week when he plays, as he doesn't have a concrete spot in the team. He will probably play off the bench, backing up White when neede,d and playing as the third tall up forward. Moloney comes back and goes straight back into the middle.

Don't like Sylvia being dropped, as I think he has done more than Armstrong. But I suppose Armstrong needs a chance to prove himself too, and gain his confidence again. Sylvia will be back soon though, as the likes of Armstrong, Motlop, Godfrey and Rigoni won't be getting a game every week.

 

[Marns]

F*ing disgrace to see holland back. Who cares if he can kick 6 goals on second rate defenders? He let us down last year, should've waited until he's kicked another 6 goals for the next 10 matches in the VFL to see if he's proved himself good enough to come back.

 

[melbournemartin]

well freo dont have great ruckman so we can afford to have Holland

he is ahead of Johnson and Smith who are our only other possible ruck options

 

[DemonDoob]

you peanut your talking about Holland as a ruckman and he has no idea. at least johnson is a pure ruckman which means he know what to do. holland is a goose and has no idea how to get the ball. he is slow and ******** too. can't just put him in the side because he kicked a few goals in teh vfl. he doesn't dserve to be in the side when he doesn't fit in or has no talent.

 

[Marns]

well freo dont have great ruckman so we can afford to have Holland

he is ahead of Johnson and Smith who are our only other possible ruck options

I'd take Johnson any day over the fat sh1t.

 

[The Shev]

You don't mess with form I'm afraid. If the guy has kicked 11 in 2 weeks, he is obviously doing something right. Johnson obviously hasn't proved himself enough to warrant selection. Relax anyway, if Holland plays poorly he will go straight back to Sandringham, and not play most games like last year.