Preview Changes for Round 7 - Melbourne @ AO

[JP Sauce]

Seriously Pets please leave.

Let's be ballsy and give Charlie a game.

 

[budget]

yeah and take reilly and jaensch with him please.

 

[SloaneysDanger]

Grigg to either start or be dropped. Did nothing as the sub today.

Shaw had ice on his leg so hopefully that means he won't play next week.

I think we should give Truck another week off and bring him back for Collingwood and Travis Cloke.

Same with Tex, unless he is 100% ready for AFL football.

It's Melbourne, we're going to win regardless.

 

[huludicidal]

I agree.

Out: Pets
In: Cameron

Jaensch was an absolute disgrace today but has earnt another shot at it with his prior form. Reilly was also woeful but Otten didn't do enough to displace him. Grigg a real chance to be dropped after a terrible sub performance too.

EDIT: Oh yeah, forgot about Shaw. If he's not right to go, Otten comes in.

2nd EDIT: Actually, Rutten in for Shaw if Truck is right to go. Perfect matchup for Dawes.

 

[Mckaye17]

Grigg to either start or be dropped. Did nothing as the sub today.

Shaw had ice on his leg so hopefully that means he won't play next week.

I think we should give Truck another week off and bring him back for Collingwood and Travis Cloke.

Same with Tex, unless he is 100% ready for AFL football.

It's Melbourne, we're going to win regardless.

Hate when people think stuff like this... No team are easy beats

 

[JP Sauce]

yeah and take reilly and jaensch with him please.

Unfortunately Jaensch won't get dropped after 1 shocker. And if Radar hasn't been dropped yet he won't be dropped after today.

Pets won't get dropped either and we'll probably go in unchanged. Maybe Martin in for Grigg.

 

[Dirty Bird]

I'd only consider 2 changes.
1 because the guy on his tail (Cameron) dominated SANFL, while the one in the XXII was only average (Petrenko)
The other because the guy in the AFL had no game time and was average at best (Grigg) so would drop him for the only other reserves player who was good enough to deserve a call up (CEY) - Though, that'd require some movement around on the field, but it's feasible.
2 weeks out? Let Rutten return via SANFL.

 

[JP Sauce]

Oh yeah I forgot about Shaw. Truck in for Shaw perhaps, although I'd love to see CEY get a chance at half back.

 

[SloaneysDanger]

Hate when people think stuff like this... No team are easy beats

I never say it but please... if we can't beat Melbourne by a decent margin at home, we don't deserve to finish top 12 on the ladder.

 

[1970crow]

Maybe a bit of movement amongst the vest wearers, but I doubt we'll make any other changes. Reilly will be given another week and jaensch, although showing his glaring deficiency, will get at least a couple more. Pets was poor, but I'm not sure who would replace him. One thing is certain, there will be no surprises.

 

[little graham]

I don't trust Melbourne with Roos.

 

[sbenno]

Probably go unchanged.

EDIT: Rutten still to come in, not sure who will come out for him.

 

[magtrev]

Surely Reilly has to go after that

 

[sbenno]

Surely Reilly has to go after that

OUT: Reilly
IN: Rutten

Perhaps. Doubtful though.

 

[Hell Boy6669]

Pets was shocking today, I would like to see Pets and Jaensch swap positions.

 

[hey shorty]

Shaw had ice on, time for another injury at times.

 

[Dirty Bird]

OUT: Reilly
IN: Rutten

Perhaps. Doubtful though.

Backline too tall.
If Rutten's to come in it's either Shaw or Hartigan. And I'd hate to see Shaw dropped for Rutten as we'd be a little too slow down back

 

[sbenno]

Backline too tall.
If Rutten's to come in it's either Shaw or Hartigan. And I'd hate to see Shaw dropped for Rutten as we'd be a little too slow down back

No way Hartigan deserves to be dropped. He's playing very well, and is the future of our backline.

Shaw goes out for mine.

 

[MRB37]

Danger looked like he could barely stand for the team song there.

 

[Dirty Bird]

No way Hartigan deserves to be dropped. He's playing very well, and is the future of our backline.

Shaw goes out for mine.

And Jaensch doesn't deserve to be drop, but because he's the whipping boy it's alright for people to call for his head?

 

[TubbsFarquhar]

In: Rutten, Cameron, Lyons
Out: Shaw, Petrenko, Danger (rest)

I'd like to see Reilly out too but who would replace him?

Jaensch was terrible today but keeps his spot due to his year so far.

 

[sbenno]

Danger looked like he could barely stand for the team song there.

Deserves a rest against Melbourne. That gives him 2 weeks to get himself right for Collingwood.

Not that I'm thinking Melbourne are easy beats - Patty has copped a hammering in the past 6 weeks, and deserves a bit of a break.

 

[GROTTO]

No way Hartigan deserves to be dropped. He's playing very well, and is the future of our backline.

Shaw goes out for mine.

I actually thought overall Hartigan had a good game.

Reilly is finished as an AFL player, too slow and making too many skill errors, but I think they may give him his 200th and then say goodbye.

 

[sbenno]

And Jaensch doesn't deserve to be drop, but because he's the whipping boy it's alright for people to call for his head?

I didn't say anything about Jaensch... Not sure where that comes from.

Seems funny to say it, but Jaensch has the runs on the board. Certainly doesn't deserve to be dropped just based on today.

 

[GROTTO]

So the game against the Pies our ins could be:

Tex, Rutten, Otten, Crouch, Douglas -thats so massive its not funny.