Changes for semi-final v Collingwood

[jathanas]

Congrats on a fantastic game yesterday and good luck for Saturday night. You seem to be hitting a golden patch at the right time of the year.

I back my side to just get over the line in a close one this week, but if we lose I'll be cheering for you to go all the way. Should be a great game, and lets hope there's no more injuries for either side.

I can't see Maxwell getting off his striking charge, and he is likely to be replaced by Goldsack. Waters is a huge out for you and I feel for the guy getting injured in his breakout year.

Peace & good luck!

P.S: I hope I'm welcome to post here.

 

[Eagles77]

Congrats on a fantastic game yesterday and good luck for Saturday night. You seem to be hitting a golden patch at the right time of the year.

I back my side to just get over the line in a close one this week, but if we lose I'll be cheering for you to go all the way. Should be a great game, and lets hope there's no more injuries for either side.

I can't see Maxwell getting off his striking charge, and he is likely to be replaced by Goldsack. Waters is a huge out for you and I feel for the guy getting injured in his breakout year.

Peace & good luck!

P.S: I hope I'm welcome to post here.

Agreed with everything in this post, of course you're welcome to post here should be a cracking game if round 13 was anything to go by

 

[flipper]

outs could be: waters (inj), butler (susp), lynch (susp). would be very disappointing if butler is penalised for that silly trip, lynchys issue may be a poor record that might see him get over the points for a reprimand.

thought butler really stood up when waters went off

on a side note doubt dick will come in didnt have much impact for EF in what was a relatively easy win
could be ins of rosa, smith and brown

 

[The Falcon Strike]

Not having seen the butler trip - it would damn near have to have broken his leg to get suspended.

Butler has a good record - so it would need to be a bloody serious trip.

intentional, body, low impact gets a 93 point reprimand.

it would need to be intentional, body, medium for him to cop a suspension. medium impact would require some damage to the player

 

[flipper]

if thats the case he should only get a reprimand if anything. was just a little cheeky swing of his leg like an ankle tap, was definatley intentional

 

[Lyyynnnchy]

on a side note doubt dick will come in didnt have much impact for EF in what was a relatively easy win could be ins of rosa, smith and brown

While I agree he won't come in, he did have 6 scoring shots...

 

[Gizza]

Not having seen the butler trip - it would damn near have to have broken his leg to get suspended.

Butler has a good record - so it would need to be a bloody serious trip.

intentional, body, low impact gets a 93 point reprimand.

it would need to be intentional, body, medium for him to cop a suspension. medium impact would require some damage to the player

I don't think trips are measured using that system are they? Players get rubbed out for tripping even if they didn't make contact.

 

[ChampRevesby]

Out: Lynch, Waters
In: Brown, Rosa

Should be a cracker.
We can win this one!

 

[the harry]

Where does Brown play? Please don't say forward.....

 

[Marlin01]

Geez I'd like to see Embley, Rosa and Gaff all in the same side.

 

[The Falcon Strike]

I don't think trips are measured using that system are they? Players get rubbed out for tripping even if they didn't make contact.

yeah they are - schofield as assessed as a level 2 trip against Marc Murphy last year - 125 down to 93.75

 

[getgaff]

Please not Ash Smith. I know its like for like - mid size back for mid size back but Smith hasnt shown anything to suggest why he should be picked. I know stats arent the be all and end all behind selection but 11 possessions, 2 marks and a tackle with Perth RESERVES in a final isnt up to scratch in my book. May as well give Papertalk a gig on that sort of form

IN - Stevenson, Hams / Dick*
OUT - Waters, Lynch*

 

[Patron]

Comon Stevenson. This is your time. We've been saving him all year. Not playing our secret weapon. just so we can play him in a final.

 

[kiwiii]

In: Pies for dinner.

Who's bringing the sauce

 

[pantskyle]

You would think the Pies will have that extra motivation now that a ex team mate has sadly passed away.

It will be a sombre moment watching that minute of silence.

 

[vonn]

Does anyone have footage of what Lynch did? Must have walked out of the room.

 

[Keys]

Does anyone have footage of what Lynch did? Must have walked out of the room.

Or watching the tv sideways if your avatar is any guide

 

[vonn]

Or watching the tv sideways if your avatar is any guide

Haha pay that! Neck excersies are important when sitting at the computer KS.

 

[vonn]

Where does Brown play? Please don't say forward.....

He has to play. Honestly though I can't really see Brown being that effective in the backline for you, can't think of a direct match up that would suit him off the top of my head... but Brown on Brown would make my night.

EDIT: Just read the WAFL report. Sounds like he was impressive. Hope he gets selected.
Sad to hear about Beau too.

 

[Hairy Lager]

Haha pay that! Neck excersies are important when sitting at the computer KS.

Yes, important not to over do it and strain the neck.Take it easy sweety.

 

[Chris_6678]

Waters is out for the season according to Gary Stocks on Twitter,

 

[The Falcon Strike]

Waters is out for the season according to Gary Stocks on Twitter,

8 - 10 weeks - so at least he doesn't miss next year

http://www.westcoasteagles.com.au/News/NewsArticle/tabid/7155/Default.aspx?newsId=147338

 

[Chris_6678]

http://www.westcoasteagles.com.au/News/NewsArticle/tabid/7155/Default.aspx?newsId=147338

8-10 weeks

Will be fine for next year.

 

[the harry]

Lame.

Wont miss much of the pre season at least, if we have another 3 games and then 4 weeks off, he'll be sweet to go.

Shit news for the now, but good that it wasn't anything likely to hamper him into the future

 

[Miguel Sanchez]

Lynch got a week. Maxwell got two. Harvey got four.

Butler looked at, not charged.