Remove this Banner Ad

Changes v Magpies

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

The Maggies are 90% full of no hopers and future delistees.

Although it would be early, Frampton and Patmore are the only 2 that could possibly play AFL one day.

I’ve written off Thomas, Ladhams, Neade, Barry, Trengove, Snelling, Hewett, Toumpas and McKenzie.
I reckon Garner has a bit about him as well.
 
People calling for Snelling..

Surely you jest. Just no
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

I’ve got no idea. Even before our injuries we couldn’t put the weagles away without Nat, Kennedy and Gaff. I shudder to think what Grundy will do to us with Westhoff and Wines rucking. Howard’s got a dodgy hand so do we want to take a chance on him as our key ruck.
 
We cant lose this game, simple as that.

Having said that, we will lose. Cant win with Ryder and Dixon, sure as hell cant beat a top 4 contender without them.

We can lose and we will, we also must lose so we get a better pick in the draft.

It was top 4 or bust and we are cooked. I will be so mad if we somehow come 8th and have this shit season extended by 1 more week. I can’t take this crap any longer.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Drop the ENTIRE leadership group, including Robbie, Ebert, Boak plus Motlop & other useless pea-hearts

yes he missed that goal, but Robbie Gray has won us more games of his own boot than the rest of the side combined and will go close to being our greatest ever AFL player. Its just a shame the rest of the club (player and coaches) will cost him the chance to win a Norm smith and premiership because they'd all but seal it form him.

We must look at our mids be because they fail us. They again lost the contested possession count. We should be bold and Drop Boak, yes he is a good captain, but as a footballer he is a liability, his disposal is crap, his decision making is crap. Sam Gray should never play again, did nothing but failed to make the distance kicking from what 40 ?

Boak for SPP ? Spray for Snelling.

Frampton for Dixon.
Trengove for Houston if unfit ? Previously mentioned Bonner but Trengove may be more like for like. Less run and gun, more composed.
Hope like hell Ryder can play, even if Frampton does 80% of the rucking. Maybe can bring in Hombsch for Ryder and swing Howard forward against Essendon but Coxs height could kill us.
 
Frampton will be named in the squad but Ryder will be given until the last minute to prove his fitness. He will be selected ahead of Billy.

Lindsay Thomas will be selected to replace Dixon because we will try and unbalance Collingwood's undersized defence with an undersized forward line.

Lock it in.
 
FF - Farrel SPP R.Gray

HF - Johnson Watts Motlop

C - Polec Wines Westhoff

HB - Pittard Clurey Lienert

FB - Jonas Howard DBJ

R - Frampton Rockliff Wingard

INT - Snelling Trengove Ebert Boak

Assuming Ryder and Houston are out (inj) along with Dixon.

Collingwood have a small defence so maybe can make this work. Dust and Danger can win games up forward, give SPP a chance ? Desperate times and all.

If Ryder plays, Frampton to FF and Snelling drops out. Trengove out for Houston if available.
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

The cupboard is extremely bare. We started the season in good shape regarding injury and the wheels have well and truly come off now. Hartlett was just the beginning.

The changes will not make a difference, we've exhausted our options.

The worst part about all of our injuries is how many of them are simply bad luck. Almost none of them have been due to poor conditioning. Even Pittard's in the pre-season was a freak accident getting pushed at precisely the wrong time which put unnatural force on his tendons attaching behind the knee. All of his occurrences since have been that same tendon flaring up. It hasn't been the muscle at all. He'll be fine with rest over the off-season but he's going to be carrying it till then.
 
I’ve written off Thomas, Ladhams, Neade, Barry, Trengove, Snelling, Hewett, Toumpas and McKenzie.
Ross, if you were to put those nine in order, from the most delistable player to the least, what would this order be?
 
We don't need another Dixon. We need a better version of him. I ain't that special.
Ken is gonna bring back Neade to play FF. he has been dying to get Neade back into the side before September. Neade at FF is a de rigueur selection for Ken.
 
If Ryder is ok I still reckon Frampton must come in so that Paddy can play forward.

If Ryder doesn't get up Howard plays forward. Cox is an issue down back for us but Howard could present the same issue for them. Howard is the only option on our list who is capable of kicking goals and clunking marks with any degree of reliability.
AJ got on the goal sheet but was just lucky. Shit himself too often and wasn't clean enough. Farrell about the same.

In; Hombsch, Frampton, SPP, Thomas
Out: Ryder (Inj.), Dixon (Inj.), Johnson, Farrell
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Changes v Magpies

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top