Changes versus Richmond

[Holden Hillbilly]

If you're Paul Stewart, and you just watched that performance, how would you feel if you were not picked next week?

Talk to your manager - he would surely get a game at Melbourne or Carlton or the Gold Coast or Brisbane.

 

[davesnothere]

O'Shea White Mitchell out.
OLLIE Bobby Hoon in.
I want to see Ah Chee in but maybe at the expense of Cornes the following week. 3 changes is maybe all you can do and get away with in a week?

 

[x_les_x]

If westhoff gets a game next week I'll pull my hair out. If he doesn't wanna be out there he doesn't deserve too.

There is no replacement for him, stewart is too small

 

[davesnothere]

There is no replacement for him, stewart is too small

Stewart is in no man's land wouldn't take him as a mid over Ah Chee wouldn't take him as a defender or forward over Westoff.

 

[BornPort]

Do we have any flankers left to bring in?

 

[davesnothere]

Do we have any flankers left to bring in?

Hoon.

 

[edgie]

Butcher would be an improvement over Hoff right now.

Stewart to CHF, Ryder HFF, Sarge as the sole tall would be preferable though.

Neade to FP, doesn't leave the 50 unless chasing and harrasaing an opponent.

Out: Impey, O'Shea, Mitchell
In: Young, Stewart, Neade.

 

[Janus]

Hoon.

Pretty sure it was a joke. As is the idea that Colquhoun should be playing in the side.

 

[Nemisis]

OUT: Mitchell, O'Shea, white.
IN: Young, Bobby, Thighs

 

[tribey]

There is no replacement for him, stewart is too small

Stewart's 191cms. Deserved a game over COS this week. By any measure.

 

[Dopamine]

I don't think Ken rates Stewart at all, can't see him coming in


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[Forzaport]

If you're Paul Stewart, and you just watched that performance, how would you feel if you were not picked next week?

Still thrilled that I have an AFL contract until the end of 2016 and bloody lucky to be honest.

 

[Andre]

I have no doubt the selections will be mind-boggling.

They won't be. They'll be tinkering at the edges again.

 

[PowerKidd]

Outs - Amon and O'Shea
In - Carlile and Wines

Emerg - Amon, Neade and Ah Chee/Stewart

Thought Amon played well as the sub and kicked a nice goal from 50m but unfortunately he comes out for Wines.

I don't see Ken making anymore changes for the Richmond game.

 

[Andre]

Cut the head off a snake and the rest will die. We can talk about other areas of the ground (and there are players who deserve to go), but 95% of our problems this year have started, continued and ended with the midfield. The loss of Wines was huge. The downright stupidity of Moore to touch an umpire (and yes the sentence was excessive), just when we needed his big body most was unforgivable and the dropping of Ah Chee when we got smashed in the centre last week without those two downright inexplicable.

I said in the game day thread I don't give a **** who are outs, but our in's next week MUST be Wines, Moore and Ah Chee (for a full game). The rest of the game has finished and those in's 100% stand. Boak, Gray, Ebert, Hartlett, etc. need the big bodied mids able to provide space so we get clean clearances. Get clean clearances and we won't be ditching any structure trying to force a turnover, having no players up the ground when we do and time for all their players to flood back as we start our run from the back end of the ground. Unless AT LEAST 2 of Wines, Moore and Ah Chee are playing our structure is screwed and the rest is tinkering at the edges.

Ins: Carlile, Wines, Moore, Ah Chee (full game).

Outs : Mitchell - when our game is clogged to shit we need to be able to hit teammates who can get into space, before it gets clogged again. I don't give a shit if he runs a lot, players who can't dispose of it effectively will kill any game plan we play.
O'Shea - come back when you're in form in the SANFL.
White - FFS, he's been playing injured all year. Without his express pace he's not bringing the tools to justify his spot. Let him heal up properly and come back when he's able to perform the valuable role a fully fit White can. This continued selection is not helping him or the team.
Impey - with Krak, Pittard, Broadbent already in the side, unless we get Pittard or Krak on a wing, Krak forward or Broadbent getting decent midfield time our side is Half-back flanker heavy.

 

[ozph1870]

Butcher would be an improvement over Hoff right now.

butcher had 3 touches today, didnt get a touch in the last half. butch is lucky we cant drop afl listed players to the sanfl reserves, he is struggling big time these days.

 

[port always]

I don't think Ken rates Stewart at all, can't see him coming in


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Yeah probably right He rates Mitchell Oshae Impey Hoon (3 touches?)..... I don't rate Hinkley at the moment....If you don't reward performance "you get what you deserve"

 

[Premiers04]

I want to see the pumping fist float next week in place of NTAU and NGI. If we're going to be shit, we may as well be ****ing good at it. Chuck a tarp on one of the bays for good measure.

 

[Dave Omsby]

Out: Mitchell , White , O'Shea
In : Arch , Wines , Carlile

 

[port always]

Talk to your manager - he would surely get a game at Melbourne or Carlton or the Gold Coast or Brisbane.

Unfortunately it will be Adelaide...

 

[ozph1870]

we dont need to replace hoff with another tall, we messed up what we had as one of the highest scoring sides in the afl with two real key tall forwards an a plethra of smaller running forwards who all kicked their fair share of goals, we changed our structure, it hasnt worked, time to man up, accept we got it wrong, go back to what worked when we were a genuine top side.

 

[Wargreymon90]

Out: mitchell, white, oshea, impey
In: Wines, Carlile, Neade, Young

 

[port always]

Cut the head off a snake and the rest will die. We can talk about other areas of the ground (and there are players who deserve to go), but 95% of our problems this year have started, continued and ended with the midfield. The loss of Wines was huge. The downright stupidity of Moore to touch an umpire (and yes the sentence was excessive), just when we needed his big body most was unforgivable and the dropping of Ah Chee when we got smashed in the centre last week without those two downright inexplicable.

I said in the game day thread I don't give a **** who are outs, but our in's next week MUST be Wines, Moore and Ah Chee (for a full game). The rest of the game has finished and those in's 100% stand. Boak, Gray, Ebert, Hartlett, etc. need the big bodied mids able to provide space so we get clean clearances. Get clean clearances and we won't be ditching any structure trying to force a turnover, having no players up the ground when we do and time for all their players to flood back as we start our run from the back end of the ground. Unless AT LEAST 2 of Wines, Moore and Ah Chee are playing our structure is screwed and the rest is tinkering at the edges.

Ins: Carlile, Wines, Moore, Ah Chee (full game).

Outs : Mitchell - when our game is clogged to shit we need to be able to hit teammates who can get into space, before it gets clogged again. I don't give a shit if he runs a lot, players who can't dispose of it effectively will kill any game plan we play.
O'Shea - come back when you're in form in the SANFL.
White - FFS, he's been playing injured all year. Without his express pace he's not bringing the tools to justify his spot. Let him heal up properly and come back when he's able to perform the valuable role a fully fit White can. This continued selection is not helping him or the team.
Impey - with Krak, Pittard, Broadbent already in the side, unless we get Pittard or Krak on a wing, Krak forward or Broadbent getting decent midfield time our side is Half-back flanker heavy.

Heres the reason ...Arch currently does not have the tank to go 4 quarters in the AFL..That is why he didn't get a full game this week ..If you look at his game last week he couldn't move half way thru the last quarter

 

[Powerade 08]

If you're Paul Stewart, and you just watched that performance, how would you feel if you were not picked next week?

Anyone who watched the SANFL game is not sure if you are joking or not. He was rubbish.*

* I'd still take him over 5 or 6 guys in the AFL team though.

 

[port always]

Anyone who watched the SANFL game is not sure if you are joking or not. He was rubbish.*

* I'd still take him over 5 or 6 guys in the AFL team though.

ERRR???? named as best on the port website......good try Cam