Changes vs Carlton

[Lefti93]

injury list update this week has given jared 5-7 weeks, still haven't ruled him out for the season. i've missed this dude more than anyone else we've had out the last 3 years. we are seriously a much more stagnant side without him in it. if moore doesn't make the team this week my head will explode.

 

[Lefti93]

Broady, Pittard, Hartlett and Lobbe are all on very thin ice.

A braver coaching group would drop at least 2 of them.

i thought brogsy's last two weeks have been just the answer we were looking for from him after getting dropped.

 

[Adz2332]

i thought brogsy's last two weeks have been just the answer we were looking for from him after getting dropped.

Since coming back from being dropped thought Broady has been good...
So with Ryder ruled out for this week my ins and out

In
Trengove, Moore, Mitchell and a big tall Butcher or Harvey

Out
White Gray Stewert Clurey

 

[pastmyprimus]

I've changed my mind a few times over the years on who's the better player : Young or Moore. I'd say Moore right now as Young's form has dropped away of late. I thought Young was playing some reasonable footy earlier in the season but not now.

But I wouldn't be surprised if I changed my mind again. Probably a sign that I don't think there's a big talent gap between two players who sit more at the bottom end of our first 22.

 

[bringbackbucky]

i thought brogsy's last two weeks have been just the answer we were looking for from him after getting dropped.

Broadbent hasn't hit a target since he came back.

 

[SgtSchulz]

Out: Young, Clurey, Stewart, White, S.Gray,
In: Trengove...Mitchell, Neade?

Geez our depth is actually pretty average...

 

[Forzaport]

Hmmm

Not very exciting this week in all honesty

In: Amon, Mitchell, Moore, Trengove
Out: Clurey (omit), S.Gray (omit), White (inj), Young (omit)

 

[FallingLiefs]

Warming to the idea of O'Shea on a wing. I think I'd prefer him over Mitchell. Also thinking Ah Chee could be ahead of Moore as sub just on the basis of looking at SANFL bests.

 

[simmo_bc]

I'm not sure where Butcher is at but I wouldn't be surprised if we see him at some point again this season. Probably just to raise his trade currency or to give him one last chance at the PAFC before he gets the chop.

changes will be minimal this week, can't risk disrupting any synergy that we have at the moment and we were starting to become settled. Trengove would be a big inclusion if fit, we were clearly undersized against the Cats.

 

[shewho]

On the basis of awarding those who played well in the SANFL and punishing those in the AFL who didn't-

In- Moore, AhChee, Amon, O'Shea, Trengove
Out- White (inj), Young, Stewart, Clurey, S.Gray

I wish Krakauer hadn't been returned to the rookie list.

 

[ozph1870]

O'Shea must replace Clurey. Nothing to do with leapfrogging and everything to do with picking our best side.

I'm sensing you are not a fan of Clurey....

 

[ozph1870]

Broady, Pittard, Hartlett and Lobbe are all on very thin ice.

A braver coaching group would drop at least 2 of them.

at least 2, or all, my money is on 0

 

[PowerKidd]

Broadbent hasn't hit a target since he came back.

This, Dropped marks, butter fingers, OOTF, turn overs

 

[Wargreymon90]

Just so im clear. Is the rational behind dropping hartlett to send him a message or is it because people dont believe that he is best 22 on current form?

 

[Adz2332]

Got to love facebook.
I made mention that i believe the selection panel has a lot to answer for. that some of the inclusions this year has been baffling.

Already deleted 3 comments having a go at me and that i dont know what im talking about...
Edit another comment, Utter rubbish. Maybe you shld be coach...

im sorry i have no idea

 

[Wargreymon90]

This, Dropped marks, butter fingers, OOTF, turn overs

Then we could probably 3/4 of the side

 

[PatientMental]

Just so im clear. Is the rational behind dropping hartlett to send him a message or is it because people dont believe that he is best 22 on current form?

Not best 22 when we have Moore, Ah Chee, and even Mitchell in better form.

 

[simmo_bc]

Warming to the idea of O'Shea on a wing. I think I'd prefer him over Mitchell. Also thinking Ah Chee could be ahead of Moore as sub just on the basis of looking at SANFL bests.

O'shea won't play and will be traded at the end of the year, makes far too many critical errors and has really struggled this year.

Ah Chee has to come in this week, he has clearly grown as a player and appears to have done everything the club wanted from him over the pre-season and after going back to the SANFL after his debut. He only has a 1 year contract so give him a decent crack to see whether he has a future at the PAFC beyond 2016.

 

[Coobk001]

I'm sensing you are not a fan of Clurey....

I want to pick a side that'll win, I've not started to consider picking a side for development yet. Picking Clurey is for development and not based on his current position on our list. I've watched him closely and we gain more from using Jonas and O'Shea as the 3rd tall than we do through Clurey.

 

[Wargreymon90]

Not best 22 when we have Moore, Ah Chee, and even Mitchell in better form.

ok

well im firmly in the camp of keeping hartlett in the side to find form.

 

[PowerKidd]

Not best 22 when we have Moore, Ah Chee, and even Mitchell in better form.

Im sure if Hartlett was playing SANFL he would dominate aswell

 

[ozph1870]

Im sure if Hartlett was playing SANFL he would dominate aswell

That's what he needs for a week or two.

 

[tribey]

Got to love facebook.
I made mention that i believe the selection panel has a lot to answer for. that some of the inclusions this year has been baffling.

Already deleted 3 comments having a go at me and that i dont know what im talking about...
Edit another comment, Utter rubbish. Maybe you shld be coach...

im sorry i have no idea

Facebook.

If the Facebook groundswell had its way Thomas, Brett, Rodan and Logan would play 500 games each.

 

[240volt]

As much as Lobbe should get the big sars this week there is nobody fit enough to replace him so the Lobster escapes the cray net.

 

[PowerBaz]

Then we could probably 3/4 of the side

Exactly