Changes vs Geelong

[melbournemartin]

okay, firstly i guess we need to work out who we get back

Neitz?
Carroll?
Johnstone?
Green? or does he another week to go in his recovery
Whelan for sure
McDonald?
Jamar?

also what about Fergeson, you reckon he will get weeks for that? it seemed as if his elbow hit the adelaide player in about the neck area, not so much the head and it seemed light cos the adelaide player had his arm up sorta.

also it was in play, the crow was just laying a shepard and fergy was trying to get through

who do we drop? here are some candidates
Ward
Chris Johnson
Paul Johnson if ND wants to play Jamar
Armstrong, decent game but mainly just racked up possesions via our negative possession game and we have to make room for hopefully a fair few inclusions
Fergy if suspended
Bizzell
Wheatley

what are your thoughts?

 

[davey_magik]

okay, firstly i guess we need to work out who we get back

Neitz?
Carroll?
Johnstone?
Green? or does he another week to go in his recovery
Whelan for sure
McDonald?
Jamar?

also what about Fergeson, you reckon he will get weeks for that? it seemed as if his elbow hit the adelaide player in about the neck area, not so much the head and it seemed light cos the adelaide player had his arm up sorta.

also it was in play, the crow was just laying a shepard and fergy was trying to get through

who do we drop? here are some candidates
Ward
Chris Johnson
Paul Johnson if ND wants to play Jamar
Armstrong, decent game but mainly just racked up possesions via our negative possession game and we have to make room for hopefully a fair few inclusions
Fergy if suspended
Bizzell
Wheatley

what are your thoughts?

Carroll, TJ and Whelan should all be back in, not sure about the others. Neitz would really help as at least he would keep Scarlett occupied while Robbo can be our main target. Yze has been absoloutley sh*t in the last few weeks and if he is injured he should take a game off who cares about the record he is already like 3rd all time for most games played without a break. I'd prefer CJ and PJ still in, PJ is already better than Jamar.

 

[CowboyFromHell]

TJ and Whelan are the certs to return, Carroll will probs go back to Sandy. No place for him, rather Nicho.

Neitz would be an outside chance. My changes:

In: TJ, Whelan, Neitz (if fit.)
Out: C Johnson, Ward, Armstrong (unlucky, but someone has to go.)

 

[tdubfleet]

Carroll will probs go back to Sandy. No place for him, rather Nicho.

You must really rate Carroll.

 

[AllStar7]

It has gotten to a stage, where I rather Carroll than Nicho!

Nicho has gotten slower, and his ability to use the football is close to zero. He is by far the worse FB in the competition. At least Carroll comes up with entertaining hairstyles every once in a while.

 

[Supermercado]

I want Nicho this week. Kingsley will rip Carroll again

 

[melbournemartin]

i want Fergy on Kingsley. best defender goes on the best forward

 

[davey_magik]

Just on Channel 7 news Neitz said he was 50/50 this week. Would love him in but use him as a bit of a decoy for Robbo and Yze WHO HAS TO LIFT Ooze is a great player but his last few weeks have been shocking. Might as well keep Holland in the side to stretch their defense. Who knows, he might actually kick a few.

 

[AllStar7]

I want Nicho this week. Kingsley will rip Carroll again

Neither Nicho nor Carroll can play on Kingsley, who has remote speed and football smarts. They will either go with Biz again, or in a shock move, play someone decent on him, like Ferguson.

Carroll/Nicho will play on Ottens, or King if he rests up forward.

Thankfully Chapman is not likely to play. He loves kicking goals against us!

 

[CowboyFromHell]

It has gotten to a stage, where I rather Carroll than Nicho!

Nicho has gotten slower, and his ability to use the football is close to zero. He is by far the worse FB in the competition. At least Carroll comes up with entertaining hairstyles every once in a while.

Nicho > Carroll

 

[dees_best]

Nicho may struggle but at least he knows how to take a chest mark...

*shakes head at Carroll*

 

[melbournemartin]

i wasnt so much angry at carroll but i felt pity for him. poor guy, must have been so embarrassed. those marks when u are down on ya knees are harder to take then u think but yes i know, at AFL level it should be easy.