changes vs North Melbourne

[RookiePick]

Plenty of room for improvement then. Tally ho! Stiff upper lip etc

 

[SpaceClef]

I have never blamed simmo for any of our losses but if we lose on sunday, im willing to blame simmo and mc for retaing an outside player in the expense of an inside mid.

We are also playing the competition's biggest spud all because he had a bit of a flat-track against a VFL side, and retaining one of the most injury prone spuds in the side as ruck back up, rather than the ruckman we gave a 3 year contract to

Can't wait for some classic Brown hoiks off the side of the boot from 50m

 

[truman]

His last game in the wet was atrocious.

? Not the Sydney game, easily our most skilled and cleanest on that day

 

[The wily weagle]

So what was the basis of Nelsons omission exactly? It cant be form because otherwise Jackson would be lining up in the middle and Jetta would be suiting up for East Perth....

 

[Biggie]

Lol.

Midfield battle will be embarrassing.

 

[Chris_6678]

Simmo did mention depending on weather there might be another change.

 

[avishka5]

We are also playing the competition's biggest spud all because he had a bit of a flat-track against a VFL side, and retaining one of the most injury prone spuds in the side as ruck back up, rather than the ruckman we gave a 3 year contract to

Can't wait for some classic Brown hoiks off the side of the boot from 50m

I dont mind the other two selections.Giles is a first ruck and won't offer much other than his ruckining. Brown not good in front of goals but will offer us something around the arcs and is big and dangerous enough to get one of their talls. Also could be thrown in defence. Around the stoppages his a fighter and his second and third efforts were really impressive last weel. Mcginnity looked lively around the goals an we need a bit of his tougness till we get going. This is hard to say as im not mcginnitys biggest fan.

? Not the Sydney game, easily our most skilled and cleanest on that day

nah the peel game.

 

[Keys]

Expect that nelson will be sitting out the EP game on Saturday and may be a late in on Sunday if the weather is shit

 

[Eaglespur]

Expect that nelson will be sitting out the EP game on Saturday and may be a late in on Sunday if the weather is shit

What will your erection status be if this occurs

 

[Here2tellyouwhy]

Nelson out. **** me.
Hopefully Jetta keeps on the improve.

 

[SpaceClef]

I dont mind the other two selections.Giles is a first ruck and won't offer much other than his ruckining. Brown not good in front of goals but will offer us something around the arcs and is big and dangerous enough to get one of their talls. Also could be thrown in defence. Around the stoppages his a fighter and his second and third efforts were really impressive last weel. Mcginnity looked lively around the goals an we need a bit of his tougness till we get going. This is hard to say as im not mcginnitys biggest fan.

nah the peel game.

His second and third efforts last week were against a couple of past it and injured ruckmen. I'm not a big advocate of Giles but in a wet weather match where we are lacking mids, playing Brown ahead of Redden, Duggan or Nelson is worse than the fact we are playing Jetta.

Brown is absolutely 100% useless as a forward.

 

[frenchconnection]

Nelson out. **** me.
Hopefully Jetta keeps on the improve.

When he played for Sydney, what was Jetta like in the "wet"?

 

[frenchconnection]

His second and third efforts last week were against a couple of past it and injured ruckmen. I'm not a big advocate of Giles but in a wet weather match where we are lacking mids, playing Brown ahead of Redden, Duggan or Nelson is worse than the fact we are playing Jetta.

Brown is absolutely 100% useless as a forward.

Maybe our MC has no idea?

 

[mitchzz]

Don't like the Nelson out. Liked his game last week + the toughness he brings

 

[Godfather32]

Lol.

Midfield battle will be embarrassing.

Maybe Simmo's decided that if his midfield is shit he's just not going to play any of them....doesn't explain Jetta over Nelson though

 

[avishka5]

His second and third efforts last week were against a couple of past it and injured ruckmen. I'm not a big advocate of Giles but in a wet weather match where we are lacking mids, playing Brown ahead of Redden, Duggan or Nelson is worse than the fact we are playing Jetta.

Brown is absolutely 100% useless as a forward.

true buts thats if gov rucks. but im not a fan of that. Gov has been our best defender all season and has made us look better than we are at times.

 

[Carbine Chaos]

We already have 3 tall defenders in the side, Brown can't ruck, Brown can't play forward anymore.

This is a really special selection. Against Essendon sure, do anything, but come on.

Nelson should feel aggrieved too. At least Redden didn't come straight in.

 

[avishka5]

one of nelson or redden will come in on sunday. I would love redden to spend a couple of weeks for ep but this is one game i wouldnt mind him playing.

 

[Carbine Chaos]

one of nelson or redden will come in on sunday. I would love redden to spend a couple of weeks for ep but this is one game i wouldnt mind him playing.

Why? He's provided nothing physically this year.

 

[wce4premiership]

Was our last really wet game Sydney?

If I recall Masten and Duggan showed the most heart in the wet conditions and fought harder than others. Perhaps Duggan would have been a wise inclusion, the game simplifies in the wet and his (or Nelson's) intent would have been welcomed.

Positive thinking has me believing Mcginnity may be suited to the wet, because everyones skills will be down, yet his heart will still be there.

 

[flyinghi64]

I don't mind Jetta keeping his spot.
He may not get heaps of it but geez you gotta admit he rarely wastes it. He has quick clean disposal and more often than not finds someone, to there advantage as well.
Improving every week so deserves to be stuck with for now.

 

[avishka5]

Why? He's provided nothing physically this year.

I still prefer jacko but redden will offer us more than jetta.

 

[Biggie]

What will your erection status be if this occurs

For Keyser Soze?

Most likely unused.

 

[Carbine Chaos]

I still prefer jacko but redden will offer us more than jetta.

If there is a late change on Sunday it will be a tall (Brown) out, not Jetta.

 

[DanWCE]

Was our last really wet game Sydney?

If I recall Masten and Duggan showed the most heart in the wet conditions and fought harder than others. Perhaps Duggan would have been a wise inclusion, the game simplifies in the wet and his (or Nelson's) intent would have been welcomed.

Positive thinking has me believing Mcginnity may be suited to the wet, because everyones skills will be down, yet his heart will still be there.

Yeah Duggan really cracked in during the wet Sydney game.