Preview Changes vs Richmond

[Shaucob_Burjan]

****ing lol @ sub Wingard as a warning

 

[PatientMental]

Out: Ken Hinkley's ridiculous arrogance.

In: In an actual ****ing spine of 3 tall defenders and 3 tall forwards for **** sake.... I'm losing my patience with him.

 

[edgie]

******* lol @ sub Wingard as a warning

Why? He didn't do anything til the last quarter anyway. We played a man or 2 down til that point. Maybe a sub will suit his current run of form.

 

[brad the brain]

Is Steve Moneghetti available for selection this week?

Ticks all the criteria that Kane Mitchell's selection is based on and then some.

Monnas would at least get his hands on the pill.

 

[PhoenixPower]

Out: Ken Hinkley's ridiculous arrogance.

In: In an actual ******* spine of 3 tall defenders and 3 tall forwards for **** sake.... I'm losing my patience with him.

Who do you want in defense? Clurey? Oshea is the same height. Nothing much else we can do

Our defense was ok. Our offense sucked.


Out losing
In winning

 

[Forzaport]

Pointless thread.

Selection committee hasn't made sane/rational selections for weeks.

Honestly don't think selections killed us. 18 behinds would have sunk us even if we did play taller or play Newton or whoever else.

 

[JHF1870]

Chad has done nothing since the Freo and Geelong games.... can hardly count the games against rabble like Bulldogs and St Kilda. He needs to lift. He thinks hes shit doesnt stink atm.

Actually in the last two games when the game has been on the line he has popped up from nowhere and narrowly missed shots on goals, created from nothing. He gets them, hes a hero but he hasnt been able to convert. Im pretty sure this conversation has been done on buddy. Lets not forget he is playing more fwd this year, so less opportunity in the mid

 

[BornPort]

You guys aren't thinking small enough.

 

[Power Girl]

Is Steve Moneghetti available for selection this week?

Ticks all the criteria that Kane Mitchell's selection is based on and then some.

I actually laughed out loud … i needed that tonight

 

[PatientMental]

Who do you want in defense? Clurey? Oshea is the same height. Nothing much else we can do

Our defense was ok. Our offense sucked.


Out losing
In winning

We had Jonas, Hombsch and O'shea as our talls. We had Schulz and half of westhoff, lost this on thursday.

 

[PAFC66]

Actually in the last two games when the game has been on the line he has popped up from nowhere and narrowly missed shots on goals, created from nothing. He gets them, hes a hero but he hasnt been able to convert. Im pretty sure this conversation has been done on buddy. Lets not forget he is playing more fwd this year, so less opportunity in the mid

HE should be paying the majority of the game in the middle not the predictable ken lets chuck him in the middle now as shit is getting serious.

 

[AdamMarrett]

Chad has done nothing since the Freo and Geelong games.... can hardly count the games against rabble like Bulldogs and St Kilda. He needs to lift. He thinks hes shit doesnt stink atm.

Seriously?? He has had almost games where he's almost getting going but not quite as compared to earlier in the year when he was on fire,he's just in a bad run with his form, same as Ebert,Monfries,Cornes and a few more.We are just in a rut where a heap of our key players are down on form and lost 2 of our key players are out injured and more players out, we have no talls on the list which was always our glaring weakness coming into this year.The group is the 3rd youngest in the comp so this lull isn't to unexpected being realistic, but we have lost 4 games by 2,4,7 and 23 points.We sit 11-4, evidently in a rut atm but I still believe we can make top 4 and get out of this form slump, but people over reacting saying Wingard is strutting around, or should be sub, or hanging Jasper etc we should all settle down a bit.It's a long season and we are in a trough atm, every side has had em this year we are no different.Not having a go at this post in particlular just the theme of everyone's mood in general.

 

[b0ydman]

Out: Ken Hinkley's ridiculous arrogance.

In: In an actual ******* spine of 3 tall defenders and 3 tall forwards for **** sake.... I'm losing my patience with him.

I was out tonight, didn't see the game.

Come home, know we lost.

I've just started the 4th quarter only.

Boak just kicked a goal we have all the momentum and are 2 points down.

There is no way we will lose this.

Next forward thrust, um, where are our forwards? Are you kidding me, you are playing Wingard and Schultz 70 metres from goal and we have no one, NO one in the f50.

With all the momentum?

W. T. F?

Ken, have you become an idiot?

My 12 year old daughter can tell you that's just stupid.

Ken, you got exposed for playing plodders like Mitchell, space ckoggers, vs Sydney.

You made the most bizarre selections vs Adelaide with Mitchell and Sam gray and pushed Shultz up like a reiwolt v Adelaide and the empty forward line failed us......as it did against north, as it dud against Sydney, as it dud against Adelaide.

Ken, we know you're a brilliant coach and all that, but are you an idiot?

Lets make this really clear.

When you have momentum like this, you play your all Australian small forward, in goals.

And you play your 40 goal 6, Coleman medal leading talk forward, in a wet night, in the effing goal square okay.

You wanna experiment fine, but do that in pre season

this 10th minute ive just witnessed us beyond bizarre.

W.T.F?

Selections irrelevant if ken plays no forwards when you have momentum now.

Ken cost 12 points this season now

 

[Schulzenfest]

Out: Mitchell (should not be considered for selection for a long time), Cassisi (injured or dropped, either way), Monfries (teach the players a lesson that nobody is safe, Gus has had three shit games in a row)
In: Newton, Clurey, Butcher/Shaw

Youngy deserves a full game, so Newton sub I guess. Or if Monfries retains his spot, he should get the vest.

 

[BornPort]

Mitchell should be a depth player that only takes to an afl field when all other options have been exhausted.

 

[Premiers04]

Out: Lobbe
In: S.Gray

Like for like

 

[Jello_B]

Out Mitchell
In a fat kid atleast he would eat one of their players and even it up

 

[PAFCsince1870]

Honestly don't think selections killed us. 18 behinds would have sunk us even if we did play taller or play Newton or whoever else.

It's more that I don't think anyone on this board has got within a bulls roar of predicting the actual changes for months.

 

[MALTSY]

I was out tonight, didn't see the game.

Come home, know we lost.

I've just started the 4th quarter only.

Boak just kicked a goal we have all the momentum and are 2 points down.

There is no way we will lose this.

Next forward thrust, um, where are our forwards? Are you kidding me, you are playing Wingard and Schultz 70 metres from goal and we have no one, NO one in the f50.

With all the momentum?

W. T. F?

Ken, have you become an idiot?

My 12 year old daughter can tell you that's just stupid.

Ken, you got exposed for playing plodders like Mitchell, space ckoggers, vs Sydney.

You made the most bizarre selections vs Adelaide with Mitchell and Sam gray and pushed Shultz up like a reiwolt v Adelaide and the empty forward line failed us......as it did against north, as it dud against Sydney, as it dud against Adelaide.

Ken, we know you're a brilliant coach and all that, but are you an idiot?

Lets make this really clear.

When you have momentum like this, you play your all Australian small forward, in goals.

And you play your 40 goal 6, Coleman medal leading talk forward, in a wet night, in the effing goal square okay.

You wanna experiment fine, but do that in pre season

this 10th minute ive just witnessed us beyond bizarre.

W.T.F?

Selections irrelevant if ken plays no forwards when you have momentum now.

Ken cost 12 points this season now

Poor kicking cost us the points tonight. We had enough shots on goal

 

[Amstaff_]

Interesting that Young had 11 disposals in the last quarter. Mitchell had nine for the ENTIRE game. If I see Mitchell get a full game ahead of Young again I'll ****ing spew.

Mitchell is not AFL standard. GTFO now!

Out Mitchell
In Shaw

Won't happen though.

 

[El_Scorcho]

Out: Mitchell (should not be considered for selection for a long time), Cassisi (injured or dropped, either way), Monfries (teach the players a lesson that nobody is safe, Gus has had three shit games in a row)
In: Newton, Clurey, Butcher/Shaw

Youngy deserves a full game, so Newton sub I guess. Or if Monfries retains his spot, he should get the vest.

100% all of this.

Had Mitchell started in the vest and Young on the ground, we probably wouldn't have been molested as hard in the contest for 3 quarters, and Mitchell's run might have had some value in the last.

All Mitchell can do is run. In a contested slog of a game where the ball is slippery and holds up when kicked, he offers literally nothing.

I've said it 1000 times before but obviously talls need to come in. We're playing at Etihad next week. If we don't pick talls we'll get fisted by bloody Richmond of all teams.

Out: Mitchell, Cassisi, Monfries
In: Butcher, Clurey, Newton

Young better not get the vest.

 

[Scholz Supremacy]

Very tough pill to swallow! Kenny assured us that we will never give up, well now well be a good test of that!

 

[PAFC66]

How many will Riewoldt kick next week.

Ill start with 8.

 

[Jello_B]

Why? He didn't do anything til the last quarter anyway. We played a man or 2 down til that point. Maybe a sub will suit his current run of form.

That's as silly as whoever said Robbie Gray should be sub earlier in the year. If we can't find a way to make Wingard useful I am a moron

 

[RangaInTeal]

If Moore is fit and has been running, I would SERIOUSLY contemplate bringing him straight in, we lack any sort of teeth/mongrel in the guts. Don't need Ebert, Mitchell, White AND Polec in the one side!