Charman on the mkt

[SOSForever]

Charman + Stiller for Ackland + Hartlett
​

 

[Blueinblood]

It puts more pressure on Freo to accept 24 becoz we can just say we will give that to briz...sorta

 

[mediumsizered]

Charman or White could be very handy if you miss out on Warnock.

In fact in the short term (1 or 2 seasons) both would be better than Warnock.

White is free and you would think Charman would cost very little.

So you & your fellow Freo supporters are suggesting Pick 24 is not enough for a ruckman who is still at least 1 or 2 seasons away from being any good (if White would be better in the short term, that is not a good sign, because White was shocking this year). Maybe our club have been a bit premature in offering Pick 24, if you consider White to be a better option over the next season or 2. Perhaps we should withdraw our offer & go with Pick 40 instead.

 

[iGNITER]

Charman + Stiller for Ackland + Hartlett ​

you are seriously ripping off carlton mate.

more like:

hackland+o'hailpin for charman+brown+adcock

 

[BlueFeaver]

Depending on the cost I would get Charmen.

We need some mongrel and true aggression at our Club as much as we need a ruckman.

If we could get 4 years out of him it would give Kruezer and Hampson more time to mature properly.

In the short term it would allow Cloke to play CHF while we develop another younger option.

 

[Barry Zuckercorn]

Yeah ... he looks the type that would go down on a chick on the first date.

Doesn't fit our policy.

LOL

Can you imagine locking him up in the same room as Dale Thomas. It would be the AFL's very own "Crying Game" (maybe).

 

[HBF]

Pass on Charman.

 

[campbell]

Pass on Charman.

No idea what we would do for rucks, id we let him go. We have Leuy and Clarker ( back up), both are injury prone, young and developing. Unless of clurse we get jeff white. OMG Vossy No....

 

[The Coach]

Depending on the cost I would get Charmen.

We need some mongrel and true aggression at our Club as much as we need a ruckman.

If we could get 4 years out of him it would give Kruezer and Hampson more time to mature properly.

In the short term it would allow Cloke to play CHF while we develop another younger option.

I am with you Fever. With Charman we will be getting a 3-4 years of aggression which is the stop gap and grunt we need. We don't even know whether Warnock will be as good as Blake - wouldn't that be a disappointment.

 

[Hollow Knight]

Very unlikely to get traded from what I've heard.

Lions just putting feelers out to see if any club offered over the odds.