Collingwood Team of the 21st Century

[curnow inferno]

CHANGES AT END OF 2022:
IN: MAYNARD
OUT: MAXWELL

CHANGES AT END OF 2021:
Positional Change: Crisp to half back flank. Burns to interchange.

CHANGES AT END OF 2020:
IN: D.MOORE, T.ADAMS
OUT: B.REID, S.O'BREE

FB	J.CLEMENT	S.PRESTIGIACOMO	B.MAYNARD*
HB	J.CRISP*	D.MOORE*	H.LUMUMBA
C	S.SIDEBOTTOM*	N.BUCKLEY (c)	P.LICURIA
HF	A.DIDAK	T.CLOKE	D.BEAMS
FF	L.DAVIS	A.ROCCA	C.TARRANT
RR	B.GRUNDY*	S.PENDLEBURY* (vc)	D.SWAN
INT	S.BURNS	T.LOCKYER	T.ADAMS* - D.THOMAS
COACH:	MICK MALTHOUSE

Minimum 50 games qualification.

Thoughts?

 

[sr36]

I'd go with Heater over Harry O. Howe over Maxwell. Treloar and JDG over OBree and Lockyer. Davis to defence.

 

[Baird]

Howe - Presti - Maxwell
Shaw - Clement - Crisp
Thomas - Buckley - Sidebottom
Beams - Cloke - Didak
De Goey - Rocca - Davis
Grundy - Swan - Pendlebury
Burns - Johnson - Licuria - Adams

 

[jsdsgn]

FB Ben Johnson -- Simon Prestigiacomo -- Nick Maxwell
HB Harry O'Brien -- James Clement -- Heath Shaw
C Steele Sidebottom -- Nathan Buckley -- Dale Thomas
HF Alan Didak -- Anthony Rocca -- Dayne Beams
FF Leon Davis -- Travis Cloke -- Chris Tarrant
Fol Brodie Grundy -- Dane Swan -- Scott Pendlebury
Int Scott Burns -- Paul Medhurst -- Paul Licuria -- Luke Ball
Coach: Mick

Close: Holland, Fraser, Ball, Jolly, O'Bree, Reid, S Wakelin, Blair, Elliott, Lockyer, De Goey, Treloar, Adams, Lone

 

[Robroy22]

Davis--Tarrant--Maxwell
Shaw--Moore--Clement
Thomas--Buckley--Sidebottom
Beams--Cloke--Didak
Stephenson--Rocca--De Goey
Grundy--Pendlebury--Swan

Licuria, Burns, Elliot, Johnson

Ps....don't care about the 50 games min.....Stevo is best 22 any day of the week.

 

[jmac70]

I’ll post my team in 81 years.

 

[Robroy22]

I’ll post my team in 81 years.

Shame.....I'll be 151 and I mightn't be able to read it by then!

 

[jmac70]

Shame.....I'll be 151 and I mightn't be able to read it by then!

They have BigFooty in heaven. God is a Collingwood supporter

 

[Robroy22]

They have BigFooty in heaven. God is a Collingwood supporter

If I get to heaven I WON'T be looking at BF!!! I'll be surfing perfect waves all day and loving my wife the rest of the time!

 

[Professor Knowall]

They have BigFooty in heaven. God is a Collingwood supporter

Given our GF results and injury history, he has a very strange way of showing it.

 

[jmac70]

Given our GF results and injury history, he has a very strange way of showing it.

God is also a masochist

 

[Tarkyn_24]

B: S Iles - J Frost - M Lokan
HB: D Stanley - T Walker - S Buckley
C: R Cook - J Rowe - D Nicholls
HF: A Williams - C Cloke - A Corrie
F: T Armstrong - J Paine - P Karnezis
R: D Fanning - J Russell - A Iacobucci
Int: C Morrison - L Rounds - C Mooney
Sub: B Kinnear

 

[ExcitementMachine]

B: S Iles - J Frost - M Lokan
HB: D Stanley - T Walker - S Buckley
C: R Cook - J Rowe - D Nicholls
HF: A Williams - C Cloke - A Corrie
F: T Armstrong - J Paine - P Karnezis
R: D Fanning - J Russell - A Iacobucci
Int: C Morrison - L Rounds - C Mooney
Sub: B Kinnear

Ugle before Karnezis and Armstrong shouldn't be in the team on the count that he actually had neat disposal. Billy Morrison not making the team is a travesty. And where is David King?

 

[Tarkyn_24]

Ugle before Karnezis and Armstrong shouldn't be in the team on the count that he actually had neat disposal. Billy Morrison not making the team is a travesty.

Considered Ugle and Gault but I think the hype around Karnezis gets him over the line. Can’t leave a fan favourite out, I’d be sacked.

Tony Armstrong only gets a run if it’s his third game on a given day. Thankfully for him I come from the Collingwood school of injury management so I have no problem doing this.

On Billy Morrison I’ve limited myself to Collingwood footballers only. Mostly because I’m trying to forget Steven Eichner and Toby Thoolen ever graced our list.

 

[jsdsgn]

on second thought shannon cox and corey gault should be the ones we build the team around

 

[nahnah]

B: S Iles - J Frost - M Lokan
HB: D Stanley - T Walker - S Buckley
C: R Cook - J Rowe - D Nicholls
HF: A Williams - C Cloke - A Corrie
F: T Armstrong - J Paine - P Karnezis
R: D Fanning - J Russell - A Iacobucci
Int: C Morrison - L Rounds - C Mooney
Sub: B Kinnear

Captain Ryan Cook

 

[Sub_Zero]

Considered Ugle and Gault but I think the hype around Karnezis gets him over the line. Can’t leave a fan favourite out, I’d be sacked.

Tony Armstrong only gets a run if it’s his third game on a given day. Thankfully for him I come from the Collingwood school of injury management so I have no problem doing this.

On Billy Morrison I’ve limited myself to Collingwood footballers only. Mostly because I’m trying to forget Steven Eichner and Toby Thoolen ever graced our list.

Wow I completely forgot about that guy

 

[adammania9]

B: S Iles - J Frost - M Lokan
HB: D Stanley - T Walker - S Buckley
C: R Cook - J Rowe - D Nicholls
HF: A Williams - C Cloke - A Corrie
F: T Armstrong - J Paine - P Karnezis
R: D Fanning - J Russell - A Iacobucci
Int: C Morrison - L Rounds - C Mooney
Sub: B Kinnear

Needs more Peter Yagmoor

 

[Sub_Zero]

B: Ben Johnson - Simon Prestigiacomo - Nick Maxwell (VC)
HB: Heath Shaw - James Clement - Scott Burns
C: Dale Thomas - Nathan Buckley (C) - Steele Sidebottom
HF: Dayne Beams - Travis Cloke - Alan Didak
F: Leon Davis - Anthony Rocca - Chris Tarrant

R: Brodie Grundy - Dane Swan - Scott Pendlebury

I: Jordan DeGoey - Harry O'Brien - Adam Treloar - Paul Licuria

Man that was hard

 

[Gaben]

B: S Iles - J Frost - M Lokan
HB: D Stanley - T Walker - S Buckley
C: R Cook - J Rowe - D Nicholls
HF: A Williams - C Cloke - A Corrie
F: T Armstrong - J Paine - P Karnezis
R: D Fanning - J Russell - A Iacobucci
Int: C Morrison - L Rounds - C Mooney
Sub: B Kinnear

Bo Nixon very stiff.

 

[Tarkyn_24]

Bo Nixon very stiff.

Shackleton, Hall and King too. We had an abundance of riches in 2004

 

[jsdsgn]

surprised more people dont have medhurst. perplexing

 

[Tarkyn_24]

surprised more people dont have medhurst. perplexing

Surprised so many people do.

He had one good year. Doesn’t deserve a spot in this team ahead of many others who produced consistently for longer.

 

[jsdsgn]

Surprised so many people do.

He had one good year. Doesn’t deserve a spot in this team ahead of many others who produced consistently for longer.

one good year?
was brilliant for us in the finals in 07, was decent that year
2008 kicked 50 goals and was all-australian
2009 decent again
2010 looked good when in the team but didnt get much opportunity due to macaffer etc

i think when in the side he was one of the better forwards weve had this 21st century and he changed the look of the forward line
imagine Medhurst, DIdak, Davis and Krakouer in the one forward line. wouldve caused nightmares

 

[Tarkyn_24]

So he was held out by Macaffer of all people. Don’t see too many people including him in their sides.

Was brilliant in 2008 and reasonable in 2007. Nearly got dropped in 2009 and was regularly dropped in 2010.

The degree to which he was overrated by so many is insane.