List Mgmt. Collingwood Trade Talk 2016

[PieBeast]

The worst thread on here by miles, even worse than the oh so regular of late look on the bright side ones.

 

[DWil6]

No chance I'd be trading in Patton unless it was a no brainer trade which the one proposed here just isn't. He's got a history of ACL's and we have enough of them on our list. It's like suicide by trade. No thanks!!

 

[TradeDraft]

Whatever, kid. Obviously you're incapable of participating in a rational discussion about something like this.

The 1st Rounder be the Big thing in the Trade. Not Patton

 

[left at home]

The worst thread on here by miles, even worse than the oh so regular of late look on the bright side ones.

so going forward what would you like us to do in terms of recruiting

 

[AmellyPies]

so going forward what would you like us to do in terms of recruiting

Half back with composure and skills.

 

[PieBeast]

so going forward what would you like us to do in terms of recruiting

Ask me this question somewhere in the vicinity of trade/draft time.

But don't let this be a discouragement for people with great imagination, zest for arguing the merits of something that will never happen and a shit load of spare time on their hands

 

[left at home]

Ask me this question somewhere in the vicinity of trade/draft time.

But don't let this be a discouragement for people with great imagination, zest for arguing the merits of something that will never happen and a shit load of spare time on their hands

l like reading then for my amusement, but l agree better some time near trade time to talk about these things

 

[sirlothie]

Half back with composure and skills.

That's meant to be Scharenberg.

 

[TradeDraft]

That's meant to be Scharenberg.

That makes how big his ACL Injury is

 

[The Royal Sampler]

The only one I would consider for Moore is Hogan. Even Jeremy Cameron I'd say no.

On talent, yes, but you'd be dicing with the go-home factor bigtime.

 

[The Royal Sampler]

Cloke for Trent Mckenzie and Gold Coast first rounder.

Done.

 

[Kappa]

Yeah nah.. Moore has shown more already than Patton has. Moore's younger and has not ruptured his acl twice which for any afl footballer is a huge drawback to their potential and longevity in the game.

Unless their name is Scharenberg

 

[TradeDraft]

Unless their name is Scharenberg

But we already have him

 

[Anzacday]

I'm not a "kid".

You realise that's what all kids say?

 

[sirlothie]

You realise that's what all kids say?

My 4 year old niece thinks she's grown up!

 

[AmellyPies]

You realise that's what all kids say?

u wanna go bru. i'll beat you wif my scoota

 

[Fruit]

We will be drafting Daicos and Brown and that will probably be it next year lol.

We will seriously need to shop some players around next year if we want draft picks.

I would love us to trade Cloke to get in a younger option who can come through with our group. He would be good for a club in contention.

 

[sirlothie]

I would love us to trade Cloke to get in a younger option who can come through with our group. He would be good for a club in contention.

You'd make a good used car salesman.

 

[Scodog10]

Ask me this question somewhere in the vicinity of trade/draft time.

But don't let this be a discouragement for people with great imagination, zest for arguing the merits of something that will never happen and a shit load of spare time on their hands

Or another word for it, fun! You should try it some time

My favourite is when you can see the rage blazing through the computer screen at you ala Robroy's post! This is how club's disintegrate haha.

 

[Robroy22]

Or another word for it, fun! You should try it some time

My favourite is when you can see the rage blazing through the computer screen at you ala Robroy's post! This is how club's disintegrate haha.

Rage? lol
Disbelief actually...but if it helps you float an argument then so be it Sco.

 

[Scodog10]

Rage? lol
Disbelief actually...but if it helps you float an argument then so be it Sco.

This notion is seriously flawed. This is how clubs disintegrate, chucking their gun kids names about.

That seems like pretty strong language from someone in disbelief, just sayin'

Argument? Nah. Like I said I'm having a bit of fun discussing a hypothetical I know won't happen and would be against anyway...

I keep my arguments bottled up for anyone that says our injuries are down to luck or refuses to acknowledge how precarious our position is currently

 

[Robroy22]

That seems like pretty strong language from someone in disbelief, just sayin'

Argument? Nah. Like I said I'm having a bit of fun discussing a hypothetical I know won't happen and would be against anyway...

I keep my arguments bottled up for anyone that says our injuries are down to luck or refuses to acknowledge how precarious our position is currently

How precarious is "our" position Sco? I'm currently quite content with my situation and hope you're the same
This is probably where I have to admit that Footy has always just been a game to me and that losses and wins really for me come down to being beaten by a better opponent on the day. Sorry if that's old and silly talk but it's how Bobby Rose was and that'll do me just fine.

 

[PieBeast]

Or another word for it, fun! You should try it some time

Oh I'm having right now, don't you worry about that.


Even though it's at the expense of your idea of fun

 

[Scodog10]

How precarious is "our" position Sco? I'm currently quite content with my situation and hope you're the same
This is probably where I have to admit that Footy has always just been a game to me and that losses and wins really for me come down to being beaten by a better opponent on the day. Sorry if that's old and silly talk but it's how Bobby Rose was and that'll do me just fine.

Straying from the thread so this is it from me, but precarious in terms of the clubs season. In the past decade no club has made finals from the position we currently find ourselves in at 1-2 with a % sub 70.

FWIW though I'm not particularly interested in your situation it's still good to know you're content and well! I guess in relation Bobby Rose if that was his attitude towards the game he would have enjoyed this thread given the fun discussion that was going on given its only a game. One thing I think we can agree on is that if Buckley were half the coach Rose was this board would be a lot more fun overall!

 

[THATSGOLD]

You've outdone yourself on that one.

I would hate Boyd and Moore as our key forwards for the next 10 years. What a disaster we would be....