Delist/Trade

jo172 · Sep 26, 2004

Who do you guys think we should delist and trade?

Trade
Burton
Bode
Perrie

Delist
Shirley
Stevens M and S
Torney
Gallagher
Ladhams

MUST KEEP PLAYERS:
Stenglein (doesnt look that way though), McGregor, Hart, Roo, Mcleod, Johncock, Reilly, Hentshel, Watts, Edwards
Everyone else can b traded for the right price

leonmagic · Sep 26, 2004

What would you guys take for Bode?

From Collingwood that is.

jo172 · Sep 26, 2004

Didak if he wants to come home (we wish), Lonie other running midfielders

leonmagic · Sep 26, 2004

jo172 said:
Didak if he wants to come home (we wish), Lonie other running midfielders

umm......O'Bree can run..

What about pick 23?

lozstar · Sep 26, 2004

leonmagic said:
What would you guys take for Bode?

From Collingwood that is.

Doesn't Mark McGough want to be traded?
If so, feel free to send him over.

Stiffy_18 · Sep 26, 2004

jo172 said:
Delist
Torney

You are kidding yourself. If Torney gets delisted then AFC deserves to be burnt down.

Stiffy_18 · Sep 26, 2004

Bode for McGough????? NO WAY.

leonmagic · Sep 26, 2004

lozstar said:
Doesn't Mark McGough want to be traded?
If so, feel free to send him over.

McGough for Bode.

Done.

I like Goughy, but I've always been really impressed with Bode.

leonmagic · Sep 26, 2004

Stiffy_18 said:
Bode for McGough????? NO WAY.

Sshhhh.

jmorg1 · Sep 26, 2004

Does McGough consider himself a really good player or something? I mean he tells his club he wants to be traded like he's really in demand.

Mego Red · Sep 27, 2004

leonmagic said:
umm......O'Bree can run..

What about pick 23?

Sounds alright. What if we did want Didak?

Cove Cobra · Sep 27, 2004

jo172 said:
Who do you guys think we should delist and trade?

Trade
Burton
Bode
Perrie

Delist
Shirley
Stevens M and S
Torney
Gallagher
Ladhams

MUST KEEP PLAYERS:
Stenglein (doesnt look that way though), McGregor, Hart, Roo, Mcleod, Johncock, Reilly, Hentshel, Watts, Edwards
Everyone else can b traded for the right price

1. Stinger is gone.

2. Ladhams will be kept on as he is under contract.

3. We need Torney's toughness. He is a required player IMO. I think we need Perrie as well - give him 1 full year at CHF.

I'd also consider trading Reid and Trigg. Worth a 3rd Rounder??

jo172 · Sep 27, 2004

rainmage said:
I'd also consider trading Reid and Trigg. Worth a 3rd Rounder??

Not even the Dockers are that badder traders

jo172 · Sep 27, 2004

rainmage said:
1. Stinger is gone.

2. Ladhams will be kept on as he is under contract.

3. We need Torney's toughness. He is a required player IMO. I think we need Perrie as well - give him 1 full year at CHF.

1. Yeah i kinda accept that.
3. Maybe so but he fell way out of favour this year and as for Perrie he is standing in the way of Watts, Hentshel, Bock etc. development. Every year he does just enough not to be delisted and then he plays the first 15 games of the season badly and plays a decent last half dozen games.

Kane McGoodwin · Sep 27, 2004

jo172 said:
1. Yeah i kinda accept that.
3. Maybe so but he fell way out of favour this year and as for Perrie he is standing in the way of Watts, Hentshel, Bock etc. development. Every year he does just enough not to be delisted and then he plays the first 15 games of the season badly and plays a decent last half dozen games.

I would argue playing Bock at CHF for a few games was holding back Perrie's development.

Cove Cobra · Sep 28, 2004

jo172 said:
1. Yeah i kinda accept that.
3. Maybe so but he fell way out of favour this year and as for Perrie he is standing in the way of Watts, Hentshel, Bock etc. development. Every year he does just enough not to be delisted and then he plays the first 15 games of the season badly and plays a decent last half dozen games.

I think that Bock is developing a lot slower than the other 'newbies' that we blooded. I see bright futures for Reilly, Rutten, Jericho and Fergus. I think the jury is still out on Bock.

The really good thing about Perrie is that he PRESENTS. He can find the ball with no problem but handling and skill errors need improving. This problem I believe is confidence-related.

As I said before, give him the next year at CHF then reassess.

Watts_Bode_N_Jericho · Sep 28, 2004

leonmagic said:
What would you guys take for Bode?

From Collingwood that is.

NOTHING, Bode CAN'T be traded, we need him too much!... And I like him way too much to see him in black and white!

... Nothing personal, they're ok colours.

leonmagic · Sep 28, 2004

Kristof said:
Sounds alright. What if we did want Didak?

If Stevens isn't worth Dids, then Bode surely isn't.

Besides, Dids is my favourite player, so you're asking the wrong person.

Kane McGoodwin · Sep 28, 2004

Watts_Bode_N_Jericho said:
NOTHING, Bode CAN'T be traded, we need him too much!... And I like him way too much to see him in black and white!

... Nothing personal, they're ok colours.

Bode is tradeable IMO. May be a good in & under player, but his field kicking looks like it won't come up to scratch. I would trade him for the Pies 2nd rounder if we were able to trade for someone like a Thompson.

Watts_Bode_N_Jericho · Sep 28, 2004

rainmage said:
I think that Bock is developing a lot slower than the other 'newbies' that we blooded. I see bright futures for Reilly, Rutten, Jericho and Fergus.

I agree

Watts_Bode_N_Jericho · Sep 28, 2004

Kane McGoodwin said:
Bode is tradeable IMO. May be a good in & under player, but his field kicking looks like it won't come up to scratch. I would trade him for the Pies 2nd rounder if we were able to trade for someone like a Thompson.

He can work on his feild kicking goals, he's a great player, and I want to keep him. He's better at it in the SANFL, and I wouldn't trade him.

Kane McGoodwin · Sep 28, 2004

Watts_Bode_N_Jericho said:
He can work on his feild kicking goals, he's a great player, and I want to keep him. He's better at it in the SANFL, and I wouldn't trade him.

He has has several years to improve his field kicking, but hasn't. Why would this pre-season be any different? We have plenty of SANFL "stars" who haven't made it at AFL level.

AngelEyes · Sep 28, 2004

leonmagic said:
Besides, Dids is my favourite player, so you're asking the wrong person.

Didak is as dumb as a stump, and you are as stubborn as a stump

Luke Shackleton and 3rd round pick for Bode

may aswell try.

leonmagic · Sep 28, 2004

AngelEyes said:
Didak is as dumb as a stump, and you are as stubborn as a stump

Luke Shackleton and 3rd round pick for Bode

I think you better point at that you're joking or you'll get killed here...

AngelEyes · Sep 28, 2004

leonmagic said:
I think you better point at that you're joking or you'll get killed here...

I withdraw my trade suggestion

Log In or Create New Account

Guest - BigFooty Tipping 2026 - Get on! - $500 first prize - Weekly Prizes - Click to Join

Delist/Trade

Brownlow Medallist

Norm Smith Medallist

Brownlow Medallist

Norm Smith Medallist

Premiership Player

Hall of Famer

Hall of Famer

Norm Smith Medallist

Norm Smith Medallist

Norm Smith Medallist

The Artist Formerly Known As Kristof

Club Legend

Brownlow Medallist

Brownlow Medallist

Make me an Admin!

Club Legend

Debutant

Norm Smith Medallist

Make me an Admin!

Debutant

Debutant

Make me an Admin!

Norm Smith Medallist

Norm Smith Medallist

Norm Smith Medallist

Similar threads