Delisted free agency

[swans4eva]

I don't see the point of delisting Seaby if we're going to pick up another mid-20s hack for ruckman depth. I think delisting Seaby was a mistake to be honest. We should have kept him for another year or two and taken a ruckman with our first or second pick this year and develop him.

 

[CAS79]

We need ruck depth to replace Seaby's departure and I think it would have to be someone who is ready to step in if required and not some skinny 18 year old.

Agree we need to be looking at a ruck but I think we can bank one from the draft or scour a young one from the VFL/SANFL/WAFL who's had some exposure but may need a seasons afl body work. If we can land depth great if not to the draft. Cam Wood does not excite me.

 

[The King!]

I don't see the point of delisting Seaby if we're going to pick up another mid-20s hack for ruckman depth. I think delisting Seaby was a mistake to be honest. We should have kept him for another year or two and taken a ruckman with our first or second pick this year and develop him.

Should of sent him to adelaide

 

[Mick Oxlong]

Lucas Cook would be worth a punt.

 

[swansfan51]

Collingwood are desperate for senior ruckmen, if Wood had any talent at all they would have kept him.

 

[Membling]

1 of Ceglar, Cook or Irons would be worth a punt i would think

 

[dangle]

Forget the scum, let's get some good kids at the draft

 

[TripleB]

Collingwood just delisted a few players, I think Cam Wood (as ruck backup) and Luke Rounds (half-forward/tagger) could be worth looking at.

Grim's a/c has been hacked?

I can scarcely believe my eyes you would consider Cam Wood. He could supply a dozen McDonalds with fries for a month...

 

[CAS79]

Gram anyone, keeps on trying that man just wont give up......

 

[Jeffers]

Rhys Cooyou would be a good pickup. Has talent.

 

[SydneyPhilly]

Rhys Cooyou would be a good pickup. Has talent.

GWS delisted him? Tough break.

Seconded, along with the Lucas Cook idea.

 

[Riders of Rohan]

Wouldn't mind going after toy, surey better than a pick in the 100's

 

[Superstar swan]

I'd be interested in gillies and pettard

 

[replicant]

I watched a few GC games when Toy was playing. Not very convincing. He'd need a lot of work before he made it onto the field for us. Pass.

 

[S120]

Toy leaving Gold Coast is due to him wanting to return to Victoria so I doubt Sydney would bother trying to coax him out of doing that or snatching him away from a Vic club.

 

[S120]

Matthew Panos (just been delisted by the Dogs) could be worth a look. Sounded like he was doing OK in the VFL this year and was an AA as an 18yo.

 

[CAS79]

Wouldn't mind going after toy, surey better than a pick in the 100's

It's a fair call, very very talented footballer but we don't know if that medical condition is really holding him back.

 

[SydneyPhilly]

Matthew Panos (just been delisted by the Dogs) could be worth a look. Sounded like he was doing OK in the VFL this year and was an AA as an 18yo.

From the looks/sounds of things, he was a Grundy on draft day. Could be one to keep an eye on...

 

[Mick Oxlong]

Tom Gillies from Geelong, KPD, was second in line to the great Matthew Scarlett. Wanted to leave the Cats last year but was not traded in case Scarlett went down (which inevitably happened) but was in and out of the side and never given the opportunity really. Worth a shot considering our backs have had a dream run with injury (and Grundy's suspension).

 

[tombomb]

What about Reimers from Essendon. Seems like a bit of a flog, but 69 goals in 60 games says the bloke does have a bit of ability. Only 23. If he isn't picked up by someone there must be serious attitude issues or perhaps he doesnt want to play.

His type of player is probably not what we need, but you can never have too many goal kickers.

 

[Blood Bath]

Gram anyone, keeps on trying that man just wont give up......

gram would be the last player we need. he'd ruin our culture.

 

[barry fu]

What about Reimers from Essendon. Seems like a bit of a flog, but 69 goals in 60 games says the bloke does have a bit of ability. Only 23. If he isn't picked up by someone there must be serious attitude issues or perhaps he doesnt want to play.

His type of player is probably not what we need, but you can never have too many goal kickers.

I'd rather Reimers at GWS Tombomb.

 

[Bonz]

Matthew Panos (just been delisted by the Dogs) could be worth a look. Sounded like he was doing OK in the VFL this year and was an AA as an 18yo.

Can't see us giving him a chance.

Whilst he was impressive at under 18's level to some extent he got most of his goals by out muscling smaller players.

Lacks the ability to play several positions and is arguably not big enough to be a KPF at AFL level.

Whilst I had some hope around the time he was drafted he could be a very good payer at AFL level (A leading forward similar to perhaps Edwards) he really doesn't have the speed or the versatility to play at AFL level, and was only solid at VFL level for Williamstown this year.

He is still a wonderful kick for goal... but apart from that really doesn't have a lot going for him (Unless he can gain another coupe of metres off the mark).

 

[Bonz]

What about Reimers from Essendon. Seems like a bit of a flog, but 69 goals in 60 games says the bloke does have a bit of ability. Only 23. If he isn't picked up by someone there must be serious attitude issues or perhaps he doesnt want to play.

His type of player is probably not what we need, but you can never have too many goal kickers.

Weren't Port looking at him?

 

[S120]

Weren't Port looking at him?

Are you thinking of Monfries? They gave him a 4 year contract for some reason...