Does having Judd actually make us worse?

[Team Mo']

Congrats. You broke the record for "most questions in an OP ever!"...

 

[The Flying Doormat]

Get real. Stevens is past it. Murph, Gibbs, Kruze and Hampson are still learning the trade. Why am bothering to reply.

 

[fevz_d_king]

i wonder if u woulda posted this if we won by 69points or even for that matter jsut won???????

cos you dont see these posts when we get up...

rubish!

 

[HARKER]

I admire your courage gbatman.

I haven't the time now to consider your reasoning, but an interesting concept none the less.
Without even reading another post, my assumption is that you will be dragged through the coals, for it.
The fact is that there have been situations previously where superstars have actually held their own teams back inadvertently from moving forward.

Is this the case with Judd?
I doubt it, but good on you for thinking outside the square. (God, I hate that term)

 

[Beloved]

Delist the players! Sack the coach! Get a new President!

Everyone out!

 

[gbatman]

When have I not had to balls to bring up this kind of stuff? I just don't care about being popular on BF. Any how, I do recon we use Judd wrong, I recon we need to get him on the wing more and I recon when things aren't working in the center.

I recon we need to mix up which player is roving more than we do.

 

[Carlton_Blues]

let me put it in another context.

Say you are a mechanic/boss (Judd) or something like that ...blah blah blah...etc etc etc...quote]

Our record is 6-7, suggesting that your theory is correct approx 54% of the time.

So in my mind your theory doesnt really hold water. Not one bit.

And to suggest that a players' performance will drop off because Judd is on the park is, well, beyond laughable.

 

[Blue_Ninja]

Delist the players! Sack the coach! Get a new President!

Everyone out!

I'm with you EBIAC, while we're at it we should also get rid a lot of dead wood from amongst the supporters....... and introduce a Sydney style 'no d!ckheads' policy when getting new ones...........

 

[gbatman]

let me put it in another context.

Say you are a mechanic/boss (Judd) or something like that ...blah blah blah...etc etc etc...quote]

Our record is 6-7, suggesting that your theory is correct approx 54% of the time.

So in my mind your theory doesnt really hold water. Not one bit.

And to suggest that a players' performance will drop off because Judd is on the park is, well, beyond laughable.

Sigh, no matter what I do people half read things, then go off making comments like this. When did I suggest not having Judd in the team or off the ground?


We have done nothing to fix our clearance problems and nothing to beat Judd's tags. We have done very little to develop Murphy and Gibbs latle by giving them decent jobs and roles.