Remove this Banner Ad

Draft/Trade Talk Only Thread

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

I hope the Bulldogs chase Justin Longmuir of the Dockers. He didn't play a lot this year and will if he stays at the Dockers then he will probably be 3rd in the pecking order behind Sandilands and Warnock. His trade currency would be fairly low so shouldn't cost us much more than McDougal is.

He is very similar to McDougal in that he was a high draft pick (No 2) who has shown flashes of brilliance without the consistency. He can play in the Ruck or as a Key Forward and certainly has far more ability than Street or Skipper has. Well worth the punt.

He's knees are buggered.. If he was fit he would be an automatic selection for Fremantle.
 
McEvoy is QUICK. Perhaps the person who wrote that was looking at a stop watch and not looking at a game? I am not sure. I ask everyone to believe what they see, not what they read.

Some interesting comments here, particluarly about young Rance.I have only seen him on 3 occasions, and agree - he does look good. Be careful though when saying he is 'much better' than Walsh - whilst he might be, he hasn't actually DONE anything yet.

In u18 footy, the better players primarily play forward - the best junior CHB I have ever seen (Hansen from Gippsland, now at North) has struggled to make a consistent impact this year, and whilst I still think he will be a good player...all I am suggesting is that Rance is no sure thing, and the best juniors usually play forward.

Hansen played a fair bit of his games forward as a junior or in the ruck.

For Tasmania he has played CHF and done quite well at the end of the year. Tassie were last I believe and the club in dissaray so it was fairly hard for any kid to dominate. Having surgery after being drafted and not getting a pre season in did not help him either. He is skinny and will take a number of pre seasons to fill out.
 
http://realfooty.com.au/news/news/swan-may-head-south/2007/09/05/1188783319882.html

Swan may head south next winter

Stephen Rielly | September 6, 2007

SYDNEY ruckman Darren Jolly may play his last game for the Swans this weekend, with the lure of a return to Victoria said to be tempting him away from the SCG.

The 25-year-old, who will split Sydney's centre-square responsibilities with Peter Everitt in Saturday night's elimination final against Collingwood, is out of contract at the end of the season and is understood to be contemplating a return to Melbourne to resettle his wife and infant daughter closer to family.

Sydney general manager of football Andrew Ireland is to meet Jolly's manager, Michael Quinlan, tomorrow in the hope of further negotiations but said he was aware of Jolly's "circumstances".

"Darren has not conveyed that (his departure) to us at this point," Ireland said. "We're having discussions with his management and we certainly understand his circumstances, but we're hopeful of retaining him. He's definitely required."

Originally from regional Victoria, Jolly started his career with Melbourne seven seasons ago as a promoted rookie. Four years later, at the end of 2004, he was traded north for Sydney's first-round pick, selection 15, with which the Demons selected Lynden Dunn.

It is understood that as many as six clubs have expressed interest in acquiring Jolly, who played in Sydney's drought-breaking 2005 premiership in his first year with the club.

The Western Bulldogs, Carlton, St Kilda, Melbourne, Richmond and Collingwood are all in the market for ruckmen in a year that isn't offering many opportunities to recruit one through the draft.

It is understood that Adelaide is prepared to release John Meesen in a trade and Brisbane Lion Cameron Wood, who is contracted for next year, is also likely to make a move given Jamie Charman's hold on the first ruck position with the Lions, Matthew Leuenberger's emergence this year and the fact Beau McDonald is contracted for another season.

Both Meesen and Wood, though, are inexperienced and some way from fulfilling front-line duties. Jolly is not.Would we be tempted do make a play for Jolly? He is 25, number one ruck in a premiership winning team and would in all likelihood become our number one ruck if drafted.
-----

I think we should make a strong play for Jolly. He is 25, number one ruckman in a premiership team and would be our number one ruck if drafted.
 
http://realfooty.com.au/news/news/swan-may-head-south/2007/09/05/1188783319882.html

Swan may head south next winter

Stephen Rielly | September 6, 2007

SYDNEY ruckman Darren Jolly may play his last game for the Swans this weekend, with the lure of a return to Victoria said to be tempting him away from the SCG.

The 25-year-old, who will split Sydney's centre-square responsibilities with Peter Everitt in Saturday night's elimination final against Collingwood, is out of contract at the end of the season and is understood to be contemplating a return to Melbourne to resettle his wife and infant daughter closer to family.

Sydney general manager of football Andrew Ireland is to meet Jolly's manager, Michael Quinlan, tomorrow in the hope of further negotiations but said he was aware of Jolly's "circumstances".

"Darren has not conveyed that (his departure) to us at this point," Ireland said. "We're having discussions with his management and we certainly understand his circumstances, but we're hopeful of retaining him. He's definitely required."

Originally from regional Victoria, Jolly started his career with Melbourne seven seasons ago as a promoted rookie. Four years later, at the end of 2004, he was traded north for Sydney's first-round pick, selection 15, with which the Demons selected Lynden Dunn.

It is understood that as many as six clubs have expressed interest in acquiring Jolly, who played in Sydney's drought-breaking 2005 premiership in his first year with the club.

The Western Bulldogs, Carlton, St Kilda, Melbourne, Richmond and Collingwood are all in the market for ruckmen in a year that isn't offering many opportunities to recruit one through the draft.

It is understood that Adelaide is prepared to release John Meesen in a trade and Brisbane Lion Cameron Wood, who is contracted for next year, is also likely to make a move given Jamie Charman's hold on the first ruck position with the Lions, Matthew Leuenberger's emergence this year and the fact Beau McDonald is contracted for another season.

Both Meesen and Wood, though, are inexperienced and some way from fulfilling front-line duties. Jolly is not.Would we be tempted do make a play for Jolly? He is 25, number one ruck in a premiership winning team and would in all likelihood become our number one ruck if drafted.
-----

I think we should make a strong play for Jolly. He is 25, number one ruckman in a premiership team and would be our number one ruck if drafted.

Get him Dogs, get him.

Jolly and Minson - I like the sound of that combination.
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

Ruckman will be in huge demand this yr. Expect to give away a 1st round for a Jolly or even Wood who has been in thew system 2 yrs.
Ryan Murphy is apparently the 1st cousin of Robert Murphy. Can anyone confirm?
 
More info on possible draft picks:


Shifter's Wrap: U18 All-Australians


WELL, another NAB AFL Under-18 Championships is over – and not just any championships. It was the 30th event since all states and territories joined in 1978, and it was the first year we scheduled the championships in four states over a 19-day period as it continues to evolve.

The final task of the championships was to announce the 2007 All-Australian Under-18 team, comprising the individuals who produced for their teams throughout the championships.

It is never an easy task, particularly given the requirement to announce a team almost immediately after the siren sounds, and a number of players can consider themselves a little unfortunate not to be included. They are South Australia's Levi Greenwood and Jared Petrenko, Western Australia's Tayte Pears and Steven Browne, Northern Territory's Peter Rolfe and Queensland's Dayne Zorko and Ben Gibson.

The selectors were myself (chairman), Alan McConnell (AIS/AFL high-performance coach), AFL recruiting managers, Scott Clayton (Western Bulldogs), Blair Hartley (Port Adelaide), John Peake (St Kilda) and Rohan O’Brien (West Coast).

Here's our best shot at the achievers for 2007:
2007 ALL-AUSTRALIAN UNDER-18 TEAM

Defenders :
Nick Suban (Vic Country), Michael Hurley (Vic Metro), Alex Rance (Western Australia), Scott Selwood (Vic Country), Tom Collier (Tasmania), David Myers (Western Australia)

Midfielders:
Daniel Rich (Western Australia), Rhys Palmer (Western Australia), Cale Morton (Western Australia), Matthew Kreuzer (Vic Metro), Craig Bird (NSW/ACT), Chris Masten (Western Australia)

Forwards:
Brad Ebert (South Australia), Ben McEvoy (Vic Country), Jack Grimes (Vic Metro), Addam Maric (Vic Metro), Aaron Cornelius (Tasmania), Cyril Rioli (Northern Territory)

Interchange:
Nick Naitanui (Western Australia), Aaron Joseph (Tasmania), Patrick McGinnity (Western Australia), Taylor Walker (NSW/ACT)

Defenders

Nick Suban – Victoria Country
17 years old, 178cm, 78kg, Nth Ballarat/Bacchus Marsh
Left-footed, small defender/midfielder who averaged 23 disposals showing good poise and disposal skills whether in defence or midfield. Ineligible for this year's draft, he made the most of his opportunity and won Victoria Country's Most Valuable Player Award.

Michael Hurley – Victoria Metro

17 years old, 192cm, 88kg, Northern Knights/Macleod
A tall defender/forward, Hurley kicks the ball long and extremely well with either foot. He also competes strongly in the air. Led the championships in rebounds from defensive 50 with 22, and was a good decision-maker with or without the football. He capped off a consistent championships with very good game at full-back against Victoria Country in the final round.

Alex Rance – Western Australia

17 years old, 194cm, 87kg, Swan Districts
Tall defender who showed great dash from defence in his three championship matches. His father, Murray, played for both the Western Bulldogs and West Coast, where he was captain. Already had a taste of senior football in the WAFL and is much improved. He ranked seventh overall in handballs for the championships, helping provide Western Australia with its quick ball movement from defence.

Scott Selwood – Vic Country

17 years old, 184cm, 81kg, Bendigo/Sandhurst
A medium defender/midfielder, Selwood averaged 21 disposals for the championships, which was capped off with 32 disposals against Vic Metro. He is a no-fuss small/medium player either in defence or the midfield. His brothers Troy (Brisbane Lions), Adam (West Coast) and Joel (Geelong) already play in the AFL.

Tom Collier – Tasmania

18 years old, 192cm, 86kg, Lauderdale
Tall defender who averaged 23 disposals and showed he could run the lines throughout the championships, providing rebound from the back half. Much improved player who has already been prominent for Tasmanian Devils in the VFL. He was ranked fourth overall in contested possessions, with 11 per match.

David Myers – Western Australia

18 years old, 190cm, 85kg, Perth
Tall, left-footed defender was fourth overall in disposals, with 84 for the championships – averaging 28 per match – playing predominately across half-back. A dashing player who shows great making ability and leadership, he won the Barassi Medal in the 2006 under-17 International Rules series against Ireland.

Midfield

Daniel Rich – Western Australia
17 years old, 185cm, 77kg, Subiaco
Left-footed medium midfielder who is quick, agile and tough. Penetrating kick and decisive decision-maker, his inside 50s ranked in the top 10 for the championships. Not eligible for this year's draft but clearly an outstanding prospect for 2008.

Rhys Palmer – Western Australia

17 years, 180cm, 76kg, East Fremantle
A left footed, medium-sized midfielder with huge engine and ball-winning ability, he led the disposals for the championships with 97 – averaging 32 per match. He also had 41 effective kicks. Palmer kicked nine goals for the championships, including five in a best-on-ground performance against Vic Metro at Subiaco. He won Western Australia's Most Valuable Player Award.

Cale Morton – Western Australia

17 years old, 192cm, 75kg, Claremont
A tall midfielder who can push forward and become a marking target, Morton is a one-touch player who had 75 disposals for the championships – averaging 25 a match. He also led the marks with 28 – averaging nine a match. Ranked second in effectiveness with his kicks, he topped off an outstanding championship by winning the Larke Medal for the best and fairest division-one player.

Matthew Kreuzer – Victoria Metro

18 years old, 199cm, 91kg, Northern Knight/Bundoora
A ruckman with enormous running capacity and agility, Kreuzer was a most consistent player in the championships, finishing fourth in the hit-outs. He showed great ability at the clearances, ranking in the top 10, and averaged five tackles per match. He won Vic Metro's Most Valuable Player Award, capping off an impressive championship.

Craig Bird – NSW/ACT

18 years old, 178cm, 76kg, Nelson Bay
Small midfielder who was third overall in disposals for the championships, notching up 85 possessions at an average of 28 per match (half of which were handpasses). His clearance work was ranked No.1, with 27 – averaging nine a match. He won 44 contested possessions at an average of almost 15. He won the Harrison Medal – division two's best and fairest award – and captained NSW/ACT to the title. Tied to Sydney Swans under AFL Scholarship Scheme.

Chris Masten – Western Australia

18 years old, 179cm, 78kg, East Fremantle
A small midfielder with enormous running ability and consistently high possession rate, Masten finished fifth in disposals for the championships with 76 – averaging 25 per match. He was third overall in clearances, winning 16. A fine leader, he captained Western Australia to the division-one title and has already played nine senior matches in the WAFL.

Forwards

Brad Ebert – South Australia
17 years old, 187cm, 86kg, Port Adelaide Magpies/Henley
Medium forward/midfielder with good aerial and disposal skills. Ebert also possesses tremendous courage with his attack on the ball. He finished in the top six for disposals in division one, averaging 22 per match. His average of 10 effective kicks per match, ranked him fifth in his division. He has already made his debut at senior level in the SANFL, and showed his potential leadership captaining South Australia as a bottom-aged player.

Ben McEvoy – Victoria Country

18 years old, 199cm, 90kg, Murray Bushrangers/Dederang-Mt Beauty
A tall forward or ruckman possessing agility, endurance and strong hands, McEvoy was ranked second for marks in the championships with 23 – averaging seven per match. He was also fifth for hit-outs with 41 – average 14.

Jack Grimes – Victoria Metro

18 years old, 187cm, 76kg, Northern Knights/Hurstbridge
Medium forward/defender who displays outstanding leadership abilities and versatility. Grimes has clean ball-handling skills and makes good decisions. He is also effective around goals.

Addam Maric – Victoria Metro

17 years old, 179cm, 80kg, Calder Cannons/Greenvale
A small forward/midfielder who kicked eight goals in the championships, including four against Victoria Country in the final game, Maric is a long and accurate kick at goal and displays pin-point accuracy with his snapshots. He provided his team with ball-winning ability through the midfield.

Aaron Cornelius – Tasmania

17 years old, 191cm, 80kg, Glenorchy
Strong marking tall forward who took 18 marks in the championships – averaging six per match. His seven goals included five against Queensland during Tasmania's first match at the SCG. He has a spectacular leap and a vice-like grip, whether on the lead or in a contested marking situation. Not eligible for the 2007 NAB AFL Draft.

Cyril Rioli – Northern Territory

17 years old, 178cm, 74kg, St Marys
A small forward/midfielder with a damaging left foot around goal, he kicked seven goals against Queensland in the final division-two match at Victoria Park. He was ranked sixth overall for effective kicks – 34 – and was first for goal assists, with seven over the championships. Extremely quick and strong with his tackling, his defensive pressure inside 50 is also an attribute.

Interchange

Nick Naitanui – Western Australia
17 years old, 196cm, 88kg, Swan Districts
A ruckman with exceptional athletic ability, including speed and vertical jump, he was ranked first in division-one hit outs – winning 72 at an average of 24 per match. He was also in the top 10 for hardball gets (five per match). He had an outstanding final match against South Australia, adding contested marking to his attributes. His tackling was also rare for a tall player – he had 19 for the championships at an average of six per match. He is not eligible for the 2007 NAB AFL Draft.

Aaron Joseph – Tasmania

18 years old, 178cm, 75kg, Glenorchy
A small midfielder/defender with outstanding endurance and ball-gathering ability, he was ranked second for disposals in the championships, winning 87 in three games at an average of 29. He also had seven score assists, ranking him equal-first in that category. He also showed ability to play a run-with role and work off his opponent.

Pat McGinnity – Western Australia

18 years old, 182cm, 75kg, Claremont
A medium-sized midfielder with good pace and ability at the fall of the ball, McGinnity can play a run-with role and he has the ability to win his own footy. He was very impressive in Western Australia's win over Vic Metro in the first division-one match, which was his debut at under-age level for his state.

Taylor Walker – NSW/ACT

17 years old, 188cm, 81kg, Nth Broken Hill
A medium-sized forward with strong hands, Walker was smart on the lead and accurate in front of goal. He kicked seven goals for the championships and had seven score assists, ranking him equal first in the championships. He is tied to Adelaide under the AFL Scholarship Scheme in NSW.

http://www.afl.com.au/Season2007/New...x?newsId=47186
 
I hope the Bulldogs chase Justin Longmuir of the Dockers. He didn't play a lot this year and will if he stays at the Dockers then he will probably be 3rd in the pecking order behind Sandilands and Warnock. His trade currency would be fairly low so shouldn't cost us much more than McDougal is.

He is very similar to McDougal in that he was a high draft pick (No 2) who has shown flashes of brilliance without the consistency. He can play in the Ruck or as a Key Forward and certainly has far more ability than Street or Skipper has. Well worth the punt.

Freo would probably entertain a pick upgrade.

I believe we have pick 7 and you guy's have pick 5.
 
Scott Selwood – Vic Country
17 years old, 184cm, 81kg, Bendigo/Sandhurst
A medium defender/midfielder, Selwood averaged 21 disposals for the championships, which was capped off with 32 disposals against Vic Metro. He is a no-fuss small/medium player either in defence or the midfield. His brothers Troy (Brisbane Lions), Adam (West Coast) and Joel (Geelong) already play in the AFL.


where do people think he will go? hard nut that we need?
 
Scott Selwood – Vic Country
17 years old, 184cm, 81kg, Bendigo/Sandhurst
A medium defender/midfielder, Selwood averaged 21 disposals for the championships, which was capped off with 32 disposals against Vic Metro. He is a no-fuss small/medium player either in defence or the midfield. His brothers Troy (Brisbane Lions), Adam (West Coast) and Joel (Geelong) already play in the AFL.


where do people think he will go? hard nut that we need?

If he lasts until our second pick he would be a pretty good pick up. He has the same genes as joel selwood who was brilliant at the cats this year. Not our first pick because we need a tall forward, but would be a great 2nd pick.
 
I just heard Rocket on SEN & he said a few interesting things.

  • he didnt go to mad Monday
  • They probably wouldnt trade pick 5 for Fev
  • We have a philosophy of picking the best talent with the 1st pick.
  • It would have to be something "special" to give up the 1st round pick
Hearing that, unless we can trade for a higher pick we can forget getting Fev, Jolly, Charman or whoever for pick 5.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

I just heard Rocket on SEN & he said a few interesting things.

  • he didnt go to mad Monday
  • They probably wouldnt trade pick 5 for Fev
  • We have a philosophy of picking the best talent with the 1st pick.
  • It would have to be something "special" to give up the 1st round pick
Hearing that, unless we can trade for a higher pick we can forget getting Fev, Jolly, Charman or whoever for pick 5.

So going by this we dont intend to address our problems?
 
So going by this we dont intend to address our problems?

Not sure, if we are active on trade week, we may get involved in on-trading picks to secure a player or 2 who may be able to address our problems.

He said the 1st round wouldnt be traded, but he didnt say anything about any other rounds, so with the draft apparently being shallow this year they may not be concerned with picks after the 1st round
 
Admittadly i cant see Eade getting on radio saying we will give up our first pick to anyone with the type of player we require.

All gamesmanship, if he sees a trade he wants and pick 5 is involved expect it to go. He's just letting the other clubs know its not going easy if they're after it.
 
Admittadly i cant see Eade getting on radio saying we will give up our first pick to anyone with the type of player we require.

All gamesmanship, if he sees a trade he wants and pick 5 is involved expect it to go. He's just letting the other clubs know its not going easy if they're after it.

The rubbish that has been suggested for a first round pick is unbelievable, Jolly, Wood, Meesan, Longmuir, Murphy.....FFS - it is pick 5 and whilst its no super draft that doesn't mean you wont get a very good player. Think of the 2003, 2004 and 2005 drafts, they weren't super drafts either and we picked up Ray, Williams and Higgins - all will be long term players with the Doggies. Personally I'll be glad if we don't trade pick 5 because the player we get - short or tall - is more than likely going to be a good get.

We need to address some areas and I personally am happy that Eade/Clayton etc will do this without compromising the longer term future of the club.
 
The rubbish that has been suggested for a first round pick is unbelievable, Jolly, Wood, Meesan, Longmuir, Murphy.....FFS - it is pick 5 and whilst its no super draft that doesn't mean you wont get a very good player. Think of the 2003, 2004 and 2005 drafts, they weren't super drafts either and we picked up Ray, Williams and Higgins - all will be long term players with the Doggies. Personally I'll be glad if we don't trade pick 5 because the player we get - short or tall - is more than likely going to be a good get.

We need to address some areas and I personally am happy that Eade/Clayton etc will do this without compromising the longer term future of the club.

I agree Freddie, I didnt want to give up pick 5 either, I mentioned the possible trades for that pick as a lot of others have mentioned it on other posts.
Best to use the 1st round on young talent. If you look at the last few years, Walsh has been the only young talent to not come on.
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

I agree Freddie, I didnt want to give up pick 5 either, I mentioned the possible trades for that pick as a lot of others have mentioned it on other posts.
Best to use the 1st round on young talent. If you look at the last few years, Walsh has been the only young talent to not come on.

didnt walsh injure himself preseason 2006 then injure himself early this season.
maybe his confidence is shot.
 
didnt walsh injure himself preseason 2006 then injure himself early this season.
maybe his confidence is shot.

Probably, but what Im saying is that the record of using our 1st round / early picks have been pretty good.
Griffen, Cooney, Ray, Higgins & Everitt
I guess with the rumours about Walsh being delisted we may never know.
 
didnt walsh injure himself preseason 2006 then injure himself early this season.
maybe his confidence is shot.

He did his knee in the preseason of 2006 and then did a hammy (not unusual) not long after his return. There was basically no way that he was going to come back this year and have an impact - it was expecting way too much. For me, given that the club made a decision not to delist Walsh at the end of 2006, when another pick or two in the draft could have meant another good young player, making a decision to delist him at the end of this season does not make sense.....He's not holding anyone back (maybe Pask), he's not costing a whole lot and physically he's better developed than a skinny kid we take with pick 60-80. He played some good games in the Werribee reserves towards the seasons end. Would be a non-sensical decision to dump him.
 
He did his knee in the preseason of 2006 and then did a hammy (not unusual) not long after his return. There was basically no way that he was going to come back this year and have an impact - it was expecting way too much. For me, given that the club made a decision not to delist Walsh at the end of 2006, when another pick or two in the draft could have meant another good young player, making a decision to delist him at the end of this season does not make sense.....He's not holding anyone back (maybe Pask), he's not costing a whole lot and physically he's better developed than a skinny kid we take with pick 60-80. He played some good games in the Werribee reserves towards the seasons end. Would be a non-sensical decision to dump him.

agree and when he did his knee he was flying there was so much (on sen) said that he was set for a big 2006, i still think he should stay, as you said he is not costing us much, he will be better then a skinny kid picked up with a pick 60-80, and i wouldn't think he would even be holding back pask
 
He's knees are buggered.. If he was fit he would be an automatic selection for Fremantle.

Correct. In fact Longmuir's knees are so buggered I saw on the news last week that he had retired, although apparently this was incorrect. Regardless I don't think we should go anywhere near him.:thumbsdown:
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Draft/Trade Talk Only Thread

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top