Dylan Shiel on Curtis Taylor
- Thread starter Bald
- Start date
- Tagged users None
JT_the_Man
Draft King
Madness, what a joke.
AFL logic
Rohan - Fine. Because player gets up
Pickett - Fine. Because player gets up
Ebert - 1 week. Because player gets up
Shiel - 2 weeks. Taylor is back on the field 90 seconds later.
Long - 3 weeks. Puts player out of game with concussion.
Concussing a player is 50% worse than a player missing 90s of action. But a player missing 90s of action is twice as worse as missing 5-10s.
Rohan - Fine. Because player gets up
Pickett - Fine. Because player gets up
Ebert - 1 week. Because player gets up
Shiel - 2 weeks. Taylor is back on the field 90 seconds later.
Long - 3 weeks. Puts player out of game with concussion.
Concussing a player is 50% worse than a player missing 90s of action. But a player missing 90s of action is twice as worse as missing 5-10s.
Leory Jetta getting banned for staging
Zaharakis getting banned for an attempted gut punch when Cotchin got away with it twice
The AFL have it in for us i swear
Choco Williams said fck this s**t
quotemokc
Brownlow Medallist
Seen worse get less.
- Oct 9, 2014
- 12,119
- 21,280
- AFL Club
- Western Bulldogs
All this was missing was upgraded to severe impact for potential to cause injury
This is what gets me. How the hell did you guys fail this hearing?
Imo it looks 2 but guidelines say 1. Not high impact at all.
Christian doesn't like us
I think we're the only club to have players suspended for gut punches....twice no less.
This was a lucky fine or 1 week suspension at worse.
How he's missing another game has me as baffled as i was when Cotchin was able to put Shiel out of a prelim and play the following week.
Taylor was back on the field 90s later. 90 ******* seconds. He can't have been that rattled.
- Nov 14, 2010
- 42,236
- 46,459
- AFL Club
- North Melbourne
Perfect so they wasted their time and money
good job dons
good job dons
The King!
Chosen One
i think they left it at 2 just for the essendon fan reactions
- Banned
- #113
2 is the right penalty.
Longs is the one that is wrong. Essendon should have argued that Taylor had no broken bones just a concussion, ongoing neck pain and an unknown layoff before getting back to training and he would have been let off.
Longs is the one that is wrong. Essendon should have argued that Taylor had no broken bones just a concussion, ongoing neck pain and an unknown layoff before getting back to training and he would have been let off.
- May 16, 2014
- 12,163
- 15,984
- AFL Club
- Carlton
Laughable what the tribunal has become.
Former assistant coaches giving "character references" and talking about "second chances".
* me. No one is saying Shiel is a murderer. We don't need to hear evidence of his character. The MRO ruled it careless, not intentional. His character does not matter.
It's as bad as media personalities giving character references for punches to jaws. It has absolutely no bearing on a football incident, what you do off field or whether you've played fairly before.
Glad he got 2 weeks because of the utter s**t waffled on about. Did only deserve 1 week for medium impact but as soon as it wandered off into Choco giving 'character' references it became a big eye roll. So suck it. Not a ******* court case.
Former assistant coaches giving "character references" and talking about "second chances".
* me. No one is saying Shiel is a murderer. We don't need to hear evidence of his character. The MRO ruled it careless, not intentional. His character does not matter.
It's as bad as media personalities giving character references for punches to jaws. It has absolutely no bearing on a football incident, what you do off field or whether you've played fairly before.
Glad he got 2 weeks because of the utter s**t waffled on about. Did only deserve 1 week for medium impact but as soon as it wandered off into Choco giving 'character' references it became a big eye roll. So suck it. Not a ******* court case.
- Oct 9, 2014
- 12,119
- 21,280
- AFL Club
- Western Bulldogs
At least it wasn't a tv host and the PM as character witnesses this time
- Banned
- #118
that wasnt the point
HirdsTheWord
🏆🏆🏆🏆🏆🏆🏆🏆🏆🏆🏆🏆🏆🏆🏆🏆
Veteran
Essendon Player Sponsor 2023 - Archie Perkins and Nic Martin
10k Posts
Essendon Player Sponsor 2022 - Anthony McDonald-Tipungwuti and Archie Perkins
Sin City Swamp Rats - Sweet F.A.
Essendon Player Sponsor 2021 - Anthony McDonald-Tipungwuti and Archie Perkins
Essendon Player Sponsor 2020 - Orazio Fantasia, Anthony McDonald Tipungwuti, Shaun McKernan
BeanCoiNFT Investor
- Jun 19, 2014
- 13,381
- 15,521
- AFL Club
- Essendon
- Other Teams
- New York Rangers, New York Knicks
we have money
Unlike your s**t club that requires constant propping up.
anyways I’m happy for shiel to get 2. He chose to bump. But how the * did Rohan get off?
the inconsistency is maddening
- Nov 14, 2010
- 42,236
- 46,459
- AFL Club
- North Melbourne
Ooo think we hit a nerve
Yeah no. Dougal Howard was suspended for a gut punch to Harry Taylor last season.
To me the whole judgement of careless and intentional is wrong in the AFL.
Intentionally throw a punch at an opponents chest, and make high contact because he ducked and its rated as careless because you weren't intentionally trying to punch in the head.
Dylan Shiel made high contact with Taylor as a result of intentionally laying a bump. It wasn't careless contact that occurred while both players were trying to take possession of the ball. He went past the ball to lay the bump. That should see it rated intentional.
Mind you Shiel's decision to bump instead of trying to take possession could have been because of the change in to the holding the ball interpretation. Deciding to get rid of Taylor so that he won't be tackled while taking possession. More unforeseen consequences of the AFL blinking after Clarko's whinge.
Last edited:
Shiel being punished for Taylor being a softc***.
The anti-Essendon AFL conspiracy grows deeper. Every time we're on track for a premiership they step in to try and derail us. Sad!
The anti-Essendon AFL conspiracy grows deeper. Every time we're on track for a premiership they step in to try and derail us. Sad!
- Nov 14, 2010
- 42,236
- 46,459
- AFL Club
- North Melbourne
Lol
You mean coming back and playing the rest of the game?
Why wouldn't he play the whole game? There was literally nothing wrong with him. Shouldn't have even come to the bench. But North kept him off longer than needed and sent him for scans to milk it for all it's worth. "High impact" - what a joke. This isn't fair. North and the AFL are in kahoots I reckon.
It’s your money as well. Will be sorry.
Similar threads
