MVP Eagle board MVP 2012 - progress thread

[Miguel Sanchez]

AKA the Second Annual Rowan Jones Award for Outstanding Achievement in the Field of Excellence.

We probably need a better name.

Anyway, results from your votes are being diligently tallied and will be revealed progressively in this thread during the season, until some point later in the year when votes will go in-camera (that's a fancy way of saying we'll stop announcing them to avoid giving away the winner).

 

[Miguel Sanchez]

Round 1 - Western Bulldogs v West Coast @ Etihad

After a tight first half the Eagles ran out comfortable winners by 49 points.

Your votes were as follows:

Name            Tot.    Weighted average
Josh Kennedy	301	4.85
Scott Selwood	232	3.74
Matt Priddis	170	2.74
Will Schofield	82	1.32
Matt Rosa	47	0.76
Nic Naitanui	41	0.66
Shannon Hurn	19	0.31
Dean Cox	17	0.27
Josh Hill       6	0.10
Andrew Gaff	4	0.06
Ashton Hams	4	0.06
Jack Darling	3	0.05
Luke Shuey	2	0.03
Chris Masten	1	0.02
Adam Selwood	1	0.02

(The weighted average converts the votes back to the 5-4-3-2-1 total, so the maximum a player could get is 5. It is designed to ensure that equal weighting is given for each match).

West Coast has decided to strike a medal for the best afield in the Eagles-Bulldogs clash, honouring a past great of both clubs. As this game was the WEST Coast Eagles against the WESTern Bulldogs, it is only fitting that the award be named after Robbie West.

The inaugural winner of the Robbie West Medal, as voted by you, is Josh Kennedy.

 

[Miguel Sanchez]

Round 2 - West Coast v Melbourne @ Subiaco

West Coast won every quarter en route to a 108-point thrashing of the hapless Dees.

Your votes were as follows:

Name            Tot.    Weighted average
Scott Selwood	264	4.89
Matt Priddis	121	2.24
Chris Masten	107	1.98
Shannon Hurn	94	1.74
Jack Darling	93	1.72
Andrew Gaff	54	1.00
Luke Shuey	22	0.41
Will Schofield	13	0.24
Darren Glass	10	0.19
Nic Naitanui	7	0.13
Quinten Lynch	7	0.13
Josh Hill	7	0.13
Daniel Kerr	4	0.07
Beau Waters	4	0.07
Adam Selwood	3	0.06

As with the first round match, the club has struck a medal for the best afield in the Eagles-Dees clash, honouring a past great of both clubs.

The inaugural winner of the Dean Irving Medal, as voted by you, is Scott Selwood. 50 out of 54 voters had Scooter as best afield, making him a near-unanimous winner.

 

[Miguel Sanchez]

Round 3 - GWS Giants v West Coast @ Blacktown

After bursting out of the blocks in the first quarter, West Coast cruised to an 81-point win in their first meeting with the competition's newest club.

Your votes were as follows:

Name            Tot.    Weighted average
Luke Shuey	212	4.71
Scott Selwood	150	3.33
Chris Masten	146	3.24
Andrew Gaff	91	2.02
Will Schofield	53	1.18
Shannon Hurn	15	0.33
Quinten Lynch	3	0.07
Adam Selwood	2	0.04
Beau Waters	1	0.02
Nic Naitanui	1	0.02
Jack Darling	1	0.02

The club has struck a medal for the best afield in the Eagles-Giants clash, honouring the great rivalry over the years with one particular Giants figure.

The inaugural winner of the Kevin Sheedy Jacket, as voted by you, is Luke Shuey.

 

[pantskyle]

Good thread. Good to know the updates.

Which fool has been voting for A. Selwood?

 

[Miguel Sanchez]

Round 4 - West Coast v Hawthorn @ Subiaco

In the rain, West Coast trailed for much of the match before hitting the front late to win an inaccurate contest by 5 points.

Your votes were as follows:

Name            Tot.    Weighted average
Daniel Kerr	268	4.96
Eric MacKenzie	183	3.39
Beau Waters	124	2.30
Jack Darling	85	1.57
Nic Naitanui	45	0.83
Scott Selwood	34	0.63
Andrew Gaff	22	0.41
Will Schofield	22	0.41
Luke Shuey	7	0.13
Darren Glass	7	0.13
Dean Cox	5	0.09
Matt Rosa	4	0.07
Matt Priddis	1	0.02
Josh Hill	1	0.02
Adam Selwood	1	0.02
Ashton Hams	1	0.02

Surprise surprise, the club has struck a medal for the best afield in the Eagles-Hawks match to honour a past great of both clubs.

The inaugural winner of the Richard Taylor Medal, as voted by you, is Daniel Kerr. 52 out of 54 voters gave Kerr the maximum votes.

 

[Miguel Sanchez]

Current leaderboard - to round 4

Name            Total   Rd 1    Rd 2    Rd 3    Rd 4 
Scott Selwood	12.59	3.74	4.89	3.33	0.63
Luke Shuey	5.28	0.03	0.41	4.71	0.13
Chris Masten	5.24	0.02	1.98	3.24	0
Daniel Kerr	5.04	0	0.07	0	4.96
Matt Priddis	5.00	2.74	2.24	0	0.02
Josh Kennedy	4.85	4.85	0	0	0
Andrew Gaff	3.49	0.06	1.00	2.02	0.41
Eric MacKenzie	3.39	0	0	0	3.39
Jack Darling	3.37	0.045	1.72	0.02	1.57
Will Schofield	3.15	1.32	0.24	1.18	0.41
Beau Waters	2.39	0	0.07	0.02	2.30
Shannon Hurn	2.38	0.31	1.74	0.33	0
Nic Naitanui	1.65	0.66	0.13	0.02	0.83
Matt Rosa	0.83	0.76	0	0	0.07
Dean Cox	0.37	0.27	0	0	0.09
Darren Glass	0.31	0	0.19	0	0.13
Josh Hill	0.24	0.10	0.13	0	0.02
Quinten Lynch	0.20	0	0.13	0.07	0
Adam Selwood	0.13	0.02	0.06	0.04	0.02
Ashton Hams	0.08	0.06	0	0	0.02

 

[lmach]

A well deserved lead from my man Scooter

 

[Marlin01]

Thanks FS.

Early days obviously, but it's starting to look like EMac has matured and is starting to take that senior role from Glassy. As much as I rate EMac, I've always thought we'd be very vulnerable if Glassy copped a LTI. These days, I still think we'd miss Glass, but I think we could cope.

 

[no1bankteller]

Great format and the numbers man in me approves the use of weighted averages .

On a seperate note I like naming the match after a "great" from both clubs although I am not sure if the naming "the great" is in jest or for real.

If its in jest I am confused at how Bulldogs - WCE medal was not named after Andrew Mcdougal.

If its supposed to be a genuine "great" then surely Peter Wilson/Ben Cousins, Daniel Chick and Craig Turley names are better choices.

 

[The Falcon Strike]

Bitterly disappointed Craig Turley was overlooked for Dean Irving

 

[scooterselwood]

Darren Glass needs more love

Cheers for the effort Fivey.

 

[Toshowyouwhy]

The fact that Luke Shuey is coming second says a lot about this board.

 

[scooterselwood]

The fact that Luke Shuey is coming second says a lot about this board.

He won't be once the other 2 rounds are counted...did you not agree he was BOG against GWS?

 

[Toshowyouwhy]

He won't be once the other 2 rounds are counted...did you not agree he was BOG against GWS?

Yeah that's true I spose. Yeah I gave him 5 that day, I guess apart from Scooter the votes have been pretty well spread. Just found it funny given that he's had a pretty average start to the year IMO.

 

[Belltower]

Also amazing how low nicnat is. Against Richmond his tapwork was outstanding and should of at least get him 2votes.

 

[scooterselwood]

Yeah that's true I spose. Yeah I gave him 5 that day, I guess apart from Scooter the votes have been pretty well spread. Just found it funny given that he's had a pretty average start to the year IMO.

Yeah well the votes do reflect that. Other than his BOG he's been rated our 13th 7th and 9th best. His game against the tigers won't attract any votes and against the roos he will get minimal.

Expect Kerr, Priddis, Darling and possibly Waters to leapfrog him after round 6 votes which will leave him 5-6th which is fair enough IMO.

 

[HoneyBadger35]

This is so phenomenal compared to last year. Might not have to wait til 2013 for the 2012 results

Top effort Fivey.

 

[September_Glory]

It's official, Scott Selwood is 2.5x better than Luke Shuey.

 

[kane249]

If the award for the St Kilda game isn't called the Phil Narkle helmet then i'm going to call a formal protest

The Dean Irving arm guard is more suited IMO as well

 

[HoneyBadger35]

Hawks one should have undoubtedly been the Daniel Chick finger stump.

 

[no1bankteller]

If the award for the St Kilda game isn't called the Phil Narkle helmet then i'm going to call a formal protest

The Dean Irving arm guard is more suited IMO as well

Michael Gardiner handcuffs?

 

[Miguel Sanchez]

Round 5 - Richmond v West Coast @ Etihad

Pushed all day by a determined Richmond outfit and behind at times during the final quarter, West Coast eventually prevailed by 10 points.

Your votes were as follows:

Name            Votes   Weighted avg
Daniel Kerr	254	4.98
Nic Naitanui	160	3.14
Jack Darling	149	2.92
Matt Priddis	113	2.22
Andrew Gaff	36	0.71
Scott Selwood	22	0.43
Beau Waters	17	0.33
Chris Masten	9	0.18
Josh Hill	4	0.08
Darren Glass	1	0.02

The winner of the Todd Breman Medal, as voted by you, is Daniel Kerr. 50 out of 51 voters gave Kerr the maximum votes, the closest to polling top votes so far this season.

 

[dajesmac]

Great stuff Fivey. Lol @ the lead Selwood has.

 

[Ochre]

We probably need a better name.

Duck off.