![](https://images.bigfootymedia.com/icons/mobile-bullets/west_coast.png)
Isaac Cumming (GWS) .... F farking lol
Along with all the other dubious ones, its inconsequential so don't worry about it and just agree
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
Weekly Prize - Join Any Time - Tip Finals Wk 1
The Golden Ticket - MCG and Marvel Medallion Club tickets and Corporate Box tickets at the Gabba, MCG and Marvel.
AFLW 2024 - Round 1 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Isaac Cumming (GWS) .... F farking lol
So you'd have him.....Isaac Cumming (GWS) .... F farking lol
If you think my outcomes are wrong, then point out where and why. Out of 776 players, I'm going to get a few wrong.Along with all the other dubious ones, its inconsequential so don't worry about it and just agree
B ... verging on B+ .... but to be fair that was just one of many bad hot takes throughout the rankings. Any ranking that far off can't form the basis for any serious analysis
Zac Williams ... played huge games for us and on an 850k a year contract at Carlton, probably better than F. Matt deBoer C at least, James McDonald played one year in our first year as a playign coach to set standards so more than F for us and much more than F over his career. Andrew Phillips would be in the Matt Kennedy category. That's just for gws, multiply this by 18 and you see there is a huge problem with your ratingsAre there any others?
See, think just wrecks all you're good work.You used a lot of words to say nothing.
Williams can't get a game at Carlton.Zac Williams ... played huge games for us and on an 850k a year contract at Carlton, probably better than F. Matt deBoer C at least, James McDonald played one year in our first year as a playign coach to set standards so more than F for us and much more than F over his career. Andrew Phillips would be in the Matt Kennedy category. That's just for gws, multiply this by 18 and you see there is a huge problem with your ratings
A | 2 | Sam Taylor | Jack Steele | |||||
B | 7 | Brent Daniels | Devon Smith | Taylor Adams | Harrison Himmelberg | Jeremy Finlayson | Jake Riccardi | Aidan Corr |
Are your feeling hurt too? Bro posted an essay as to why he was upset that I don't rate Mike Pyke. Turned out he was half decent in one game.See, think just wrecks all you're good work.
Williams missed this year with an acl ... dude, if you don't know the players, how can you even begin to rank tehm?Williams can't get a game at Carlton.
deBoer is a C
McDonald may have been great for you guys, but he played 1 year.
Phillips? Played 82 games in 10 years?
So let's get this straight, there's 2 guys who are F's that should be C's. (Cumming at this stage of his career isn't better than a C)
That makes 0 difference to the end result.
Do you know how I ranked the teams? This:
A 2 Sam Taylor Jack Steele B 7 Brent Daniels Devon Smith Taylor Adams Harrison Himmelberg Jeremy Finlayson Jake Riccardi Aidan Corr
Those player you talk of, don't matter. They are loose change.
If you want to argue that loose change matters, fine, go for it, but waste time talking about 1 or 2 players than are mis-ranked by 1 grade.
I noticed you have declined to give feedback on my final rankings, but get stuck and spin your wheels on players that don't really matter......Williams missed this year with an acl ... dude, if you don't know the players, how can you even begin to rank tehm?
Agree. Not upset at all. CheersAre your feeling hurt too? Bro posted an essay as to why he was upset that I don't rate Mike Pyke. Turned out he was half decent in one game.
My apologies, KeysFor people, especially those visiting the WCE board, reading this thread -
It’s a very broad brush analysis (the OP has said as much in the first post and in several replies) designed to compare the eagles drafting against other clubs. It is not a detailed breakdown of players careers like Champion Data might do but just a rough guideline
Make your own mind up about how the list was compiled and that will guide how much weight you place on its conclusions. But nitpicking over how player A should have been this or that is boring
If you don’t like it, move on. In the grand scheme of things it’s an interesting discussion point but don’t get bogged down in the minutiae of a bigger picture - like critiquing a painting of the Grand Canyon and complaining a tree was drawn in the wrong spot
PS: I’m not directly equating this thread to the Grand Canyon, it isn’t that grand
Intriguing post Keys .For people, especially those visiting the WCE board, reading this thread -
It’s a very broad brush analysis (the OP has said as much in the first post and in several replies) designed to compare the eagles drafting against other clubs. It is not a detailed breakdown of players careers like Champion Data might do but just a rough guideline
Make your own mind up about how the list was compiled and that will guide how much weight you place on its conclusions. But nitpicking over how player A should have been this or that is boring
If you don’t like it, move on. In the grand scheme of things it’s an interesting discussion point but don’t get bogged down in the minutiae of a bigger picture - like critiquing a painting of the Grand Canyon and complaining a tree was drawn in the wrong spot
PS: I’m not directly equating this thread to the Grand Canyon, it isn’t that grand
Intriguing post Keys .
However, I have noticed that you have not bothered to finish many sentences with a full stop, exclamation point or a question mark.
How can a moderator post with so many errors be taken seriously?
Intriguing post Keys .
However, I have noticed that you have not bothered to finish many sentences with a full stop, exclamation point or a question mark.
How can a moderator post with so many errors be taken seriously?